Colorado Case Commentaries

Townsell v. People (2026 CO 11): Pleading Strickland Prejudice as a Prerequisite to Appointed Rule 35(c) Counsel—Conclusory DNA-Investigation Claims Are “Wholly Unfounded”

Date: Mar 31, 2026

Pleading Strickland Prejudice to Obtain Appointed Rule 35(c) Counsel: Conclusory DNA-Ineffectiveness Claims Are “Wholly Unfounded” Case: Townsell v. People, 2026 CO 11, 585 P.3d 838 (Colo. 2026)...

Noncustodial Requests for Counsel Do Not Trigger Edwards—Even After a Miranda Advisement Attempt (People v. Lulei)

Date: Mar 31, 2026

Noncustodial Requests for Counsel Do Not Trigger Edwards—Even After a Miranda Advisement Attempt Case: The PEOPLE of the State of Colorado v. Dakotah J. LULEI, 586 P.3d 184 (Colo. 2026) (2026 CO 17)...

Per-Facility Statistical Counts of Child-Abuse Hotline Reports Are Disclosable Under CORA Despite § 19-1-307(1)(a) Confidentiality

Date: Mar 31, 2026

Per-Facility Statistical Counts of Child-Abuse Hotline Reports Are Disclosable Under CORA Despite § 19-1-307(1)(a) Confidentiality Case: Brubaker v. Colorado Sun, 2026 CO 18 (Colo. Mar. 30, 2026)...

Guilty Verdict Stands Despite “No Deadly Weapon” Crime-of-Violence Interrogatory When It Does Not Negate an Element and the Jury’s Intent Is Discernible (People v. Shockey)

Date: Mar 31, 2026

Guilty Verdict Stands Despite “No Deadly Weapon” Crime-of-Violence Interrogatory When It Does Not Negate an Element and the Jury’s Intent Is Discernible (People v. Shockey) I. Introduction In People...

People v. Day (2026): Competency as a Prerequisite to § 16-8-107(3)(b) Mental-Condition Examinations

Date: Mar 19, 2026

Competency First: A Defendant Must Be Competent Before Undergoing a § 16-8-107(3)(b) Mental-Condition Examination Case: The People of the State of Colorado v. Maria Laida Day Citation: People v. Day,...

Competency Is a Prerequisite to a § 16-8-107(3)(b) Mental-Condition Examination

Date: Mar 17, 2026

Competency Is a Prerequisite to a § 16-8-107(3)(b) Mental-Condition Examination I. Introduction In People v. Day, 585 P.3d 857, 2026 CO 16, the Colorado Supreme Court addressed the procedural gateway...

Competency as a Prerequisite to § 16-8-107(3)(b) Mental-Condition Examinations

Date: Mar 17, 2026

Competency as a Prerequisite to § 16-8-107(3)(b) Mental-Condition Examinations Introduction In People v. Maria Day, the Colorado Supreme Court confronted a recurring tension in criminal practice:...

People v. Torres (2026 CO 15): “Nah” Plus Continued Engagement Is an Ambiguous Silence Invocation; Accurate Consequence-Talk and Truthfulness Appeals Are Not Coercion

Date: Mar 11, 2026

People v. Torres (2026 CO 15): “Nah” Plus Continued Engagement Is an Ambiguous Silence Invocation; Accurate Consequence-Talk and Truthfulness Appeals Are Not Coercion Court: Colorado Supreme Court...

People v. McGee: Probable Cause Requires Arrest-Specific Identifiers—Generic Matching Descriptions Cannot Supply the Nexus

Date: Mar 11, 2026

People v. McGee: Probable Cause Requires Arrest-Specific Identifiers—Generic Matching Descriptions Cannot Supply the Nexus I. Introduction People v. Austin Rhys McGee (2026 CO 14) arose from an...

Single-Subject Rule: A TABOR Fee-Vote Initiative Cannot Also Redefine “Fee” Statewide

Date: Mar 11, 2026

Single-Subject Rule: A TABOR Fee-Vote Initiative Cannot Also Redefine “Fee” Statewide I. Introduction In Proposed Initiative 2025-2026 #158, 2026 CO 13, the Colorado Supreme Court reviewed—through an...

People v. Torres (2026 CO 15): “Nah” Plus Continued Engagement Is an Ambiguous Non-Invocation; Consequence-Talking and Cooperation Appeals Are Not Coercion

Date: Mar 10, 2026

People v. Torres (2026 CO 15): “Nah” Plus Continued Engagement Is an Ambiguous Non-Invocation; Consequence-Talking and Cooperation Appeals Are Not Coercion I. Introduction In The PEOPLE of the State...

Colorado Single-Subject Rule: Redefining “Fee” Statewide Is a Separate Subject from Requiring Voter Approval of High-Revenue Fees (Initiative #158)

Date: Mar 10, 2026

Colorado Single-Subject Rule: Redefining “Fee” Statewide Is a Separate Subject from Requiring Voter Approval of High-Revenue Fees (Initiative #158) Case: In the MATTER OF the TITLE, BALLOT TITLE, AND...

People v. McGee (2026 CO 14): Probable Cause Requires Arrest-Triggering Descriptors to Specifically Identify the Suspect

Date: Mar 10, 2026

People v. McGee (2026 CO 14): Probable Cause Requires Arrest-Triggering Descriptors to Specifically Identify the Suspect I. Introduction In The PEOPLE of the State of Colorado v. Austin Rhys MCGEE,...

Bright-Line Rule: Criminal Violation of a Protection Order Qualifies as the Predicate “Crime Against Another Person or Property” for Second Degree Burglary

Date: Mar 6, 2026

Bright-Line Rule: Criminal Violation of a Protection Order Qualifies as the Predicate “Crime Against Another Person or Property” for Second Degree Burglary Case: People v. Dilka, 2026 CO 12, 25SA187...

Bright-Line Predicate Rule: Criminal Violation of a Protection Order Qualifies as a “Crime Against Another Person or Property” for Second-Degree Burglary

Date: Mar 3, 2026

Bright-Line Predicate Rule: Criminal Violation of a Protection Order Qualifies as a “Crime Against Another Person or Property” for Second-Degree Burglary Case: People v. Dilka, 584 P.3d 564 (Colo....

Townsell v. People (2026 CO 11): Nonconclusory Strickland-Prejudice Pleading Required to Trigger Appointment of Postconviction Counsel Under Crim. P. 35(c)

Date: Feb 20, 2026

Townsell v. People (2026 CO 11): Nonconclusory Strickland-Prejudice Pleading Required to Trigger Appointment of Postconviction Counsel Under Crim. P. 35(c) 1) Introduction In Townsell v. People, 2026...

Deadly-Weapon Crime-of-Violence Interrogatory Does Not Nullify a Second-Degree Murder Conviction Absent Elemental Conflict

Date: Feb 20, 2026

Deadly-Weapon Crime-of-Violence Interrogatory Does Not Nullify a Second-Degree Murder Conviction Absent Elemental Conflict I. Introduction In People v. Shockey, 2026 CO 10, the Colorado Supreme Court...

Waste-Prevention Statutes in Title 37 Create No Private Cause of Action and Do Not Confer Water-Court Jurisdiction Over Flooding Torts

Date: Feb 18, 2026

Waste-Prevention Statutes in Title 37 Create No Private Cause of Action and Do Not Confer Water-Court Jurisdiction Over Flooding Torts 1. Introduction In Byers Peak Properties, LLC v. Byers Peak Land...

County-Court Anti-SLAPP Final Judgments Are Not Appealable to the Colorado Court of Appeals

Date: Feb 5, 2026

County-Court Anti-SLAPP Final Judgments Are Not Appealable to the Colorado Court of Appeals 1. Introduction Hinds v. Foreman, 2026 CO 9 addresses a structural question of Colorado appellate...

Selective Prosecution in Colorado: “Similarly Situated” Is Fact-Intensive, and General Statistics Alone Rarely Prove Discriminatory Effect or Purpose

Date: Feb 4, 2026

Selective Prosecution in Colorado: “Similarly Situated” Is Fact-Intensive, and General Statistics Alone Rarely Prove Discriminatory Effect or Purpose I. Introduction In Mitchell v. People, 2026 CO 8,...