Colorado Case Commentaries

People v. McGee (2026 CO 14): Probable Cause Requires Arrest-Triggering Descriptors to Specifically Identify the Suspect

Date: Mar 10, 2026

People v. McGee (2026 CO 14): Probable Cause Requires Arrest-Triggering Descriptors to Specifically Identify the Suspect I. Introduction In The PEOPLE of the State of Colorado v. Austin Rhys MCGEE,...

Bright-Line Rule: Criminal Violation of a Protection Order Qualifies as the Predicate “Crime Against Another Person or Property” for Second Degree Burglary

Date: Mar 6, 2026

Bright-Line Rule: Criminal Violation of a Protection Order Qualifies as the Predicate “Crime Against Another Person or Property” for Second Degree Burglary Case: People v. Dilka, 2026 CO 12, 25SA187...

Bright-Line Predicate Rule: Criminal Violation of a Protection Order Qualifies as a “Crime Against Another Person or Property” for Second-Degree Burglary

Date: Mar 3, 2026

Bright-Line Predicate Rule: Criminal Violation of a Protection Order Qualifies as a “Crime Against Another Person or Property” for Second-Degree Burglary Case: People v. Dilka, 584 P.3d 564 (Colo....

Townsell v. People (2026 CO 11): Nonconclusory Strickland-Prejudice Pleading Required to Trigger Appointment of Postconviction Counsel Under Crim. P. 35(c)

Date: Feb 20, 2026

Townsell v. People (2026 CO 11): Nonconclusory Strickland-Prejudice Pleading Required to Trigger Appointment of Postconviction Counsel Under Crim. P. 35(c) 1) Introduction In Townsell v. People, 2026...

Deadly-Weapon Crime-of-Violence Interrogatory Does Not Nullify a Second-Degree Murder Conviction Absent Elemental Conflict

Date: Feb 20, 2026

Deadly-Weapon Crime-of-Violence Interrogatory Does Not Nullify a Second-Degree Murder Conviction Absent Elemental Conflict I. Introduction In People v. Shockey, 2026 CO 10, the Colorado Supreme Court...

Waste-Prevention Statutes in Title 37 Create No Private Cause of Action and Do Not Confer Water-Court Jurisdiction Over Flooding Torts

Date: Feb 18, 2026

Waste-Prevention Statutes in Title 37 Create No Private Cause of Action and Do Not Confer Water-Court Jurisdiction Over Flooding Torts 1. Introduction In Byers Peak Properties, LLC v. Byers Peak Land...

County-Court Anti-SLAPP Final Judgments Are Not Appealable to the Colorado Court of Appeals

Date: Feb 5, 2026

County-Court Anti-SLAPP Final Judgments Are Not Appealable to the Colorado Court of Appeals 1. Introduction Hinds v. Foreman, 2026 CO 9 addresses a structural question of Colorado appellate...

Selective Prosecution in Colorado: “Similarly Situated” Is Fact-Intensive, and General Statistics Alone Rarely Prove Discriminatory Effect or Purpose

Date: Feb 4, 2026

Selective Prosecution in Colorado: “Similarly Situated” Is Fact-Intensive, and General Statistics Alone Rarely Prove Discriminatory Effect or Purpose I. Introduction In Mitchell v. People, 2026 CO 8,...

Crim. P. 16(I)(c)(2) Nonparty Discovery Orders Require Personal Jurisdiction by Proper Service

Date: Feb 4, 2026

Crim. P. 16(I)(c)(2) Nonparty Discovery Orders Require Personal Jurisdiction by Proper Service Case: In re the PEOPLE of the State of Colorado v. Juan Manuel CASTORENA, 2026 CO 2, 582 P.3d 459 Court:...

Byers Peak: No Private Waste Claim Under § 37-84-108; §§ 37-84-124/-125 Protect Water Rights (Not Flooding) and Constrain Water-Court Ancillary Jurisdiction

Date: Jan 29, 2026

Byers Peak: No Private Waste Claim Under § 37-84-108; §§ 37-84-124/-125 Protect Water Rights (Not Flooding) and Constrain Water-Court Ancillary Jurisdiction 1. Introduction Case: Byers Peak Props. v....

PUC Tariffs Cannot Limit Electric Utility Tort Liability to Non-Customers; HVSA Notice Binds Only Contracting Parties and Triggers No-Causation Indemnity

Date: Jan 29, 2026

PUC Tariffs Cannot Limit Electric Utility Tort Liability to Non-Customers; HVSA Notice Binds Only Contracting Parties and Triggers No-Causation Indemnity Case: Pub. Serv. Co. of Colo. v. Outdoor...

“Substance” Means the Entire Product: Colorado Narrows Involuntary Intoxication When Multiple Intoxicants Are Alleged

Date: Jan 29, 2026

“Substance” Means the Entire Product: Colorado Narrows Involuntary Intoxication When Multiple Intoxicants Are Alleged Case: The People of the State of Colorado v. Isaac U. Mion Citation: People v....

Child-Abuse “Testimony” Exception Does Not Reach Medical Records; Body-Cam Hospital Footage Requires Privilege-and-Policy Findings

Date: Jan 15, 2026

Child-Abuse “Testimony” Exception Does Not Reach Medical Records; Body-Cam Hospital Footage Requires Privilege-and-Policy Findings Case: People v. Soron, 2026 CO 3, 25SA203 (Colo. Jan 12, 2026)...

Rule 16 Discovery Orders to Nonparties Require Personal Jurisdiction Through Proper Service

Date: Jan 15, 2026

Rule 16 Discovery Orders to Nonparties Require Personal Jurisdiction Through Proper Service Case: People v. Castorena, 2026 CO 2 (Colo. Jan. 12, 2026) (No. 25SA179) | Court: Colorado Supreme Court...

People v. McGee (2026): Timely Second-Opinion Competency Evaluations Are Mandatory After a Completed CMHHIP Evaluation

Date: Jan 14, 2026

People v. McGee (2026): Timely Second-Opinion Competency Evaluations Are Mandatory After a Completed CMHHIP Evaluation Citation: People v. McGee, 2026 CO 4, 25SA224 (Colo. Jan 12, 2026) Court:...

People v. McGee (2026): Timely Second-Opinion Competency Evaluations Are Mandatory After a CMHHIP Evaluation, and Trial Courts May Not Retroactively Undo the Initial Order

Date: Jan 13, 2026

People v. McGee (2026): Timely Second-Opinion Competency Evaluations Are Mandatory After a CMHHIP Evaluation, and Trial Courts May Not Retroactively Undo the Initial Order Court: Colorado Supreme...

Colorado: Child-Abuse Exception to Physician–Patient Privilege Is Limited to Testimony (Not Medical Records); Body-Worn Camera Footage Requires Privilege and Public-Policy Findings

Date: Jan 13, 2026

Colorado: Child-Abuse Exception to Physician–Patient Privilege Is Limited to Testimony (Not Medical Records); Body-Worn Camera Footage Requires Privilege and Public-Policy Findings I. Introduction In...

Uniform State Sentencing Caps and Municipal Home-Rule: Operational Preemption in People v. Michelle (Camp & Simons)

Date: Dec 26, 2025

Uniform State Sentencing Caps and Municipal Home-Rule: Operational Preemption in People v. Michelle (Camp & Simons) I. Introduction The Colorado Supreme Court’s decision in People v. Michelle, 2025...

Rebutting the Body‑Worn Camera Presumption: People v. Havens and the Limits of Discovery Sanctions in Colorado

Date: Dec 26, 2025

Rebutting the Body‑Worn Camera Presumption: People v. Havens and the Limits of Discovery Sanctions in Colorado I. Introduction People v. Havens, 2025 CO 65, is a significant Colorado Supreme Court...

State Sentencing Caps Preempt Harsher Home-Rule Municipal Penalties for Identical Conduct

Date: Dec 23, 2025

State Sentencing Caps Preempt Harsher Home-Rule Municipal Penalties for Identical Conduct Case: In re People v. Camp; In re People v. Simons | Citation: 2025 CO 64 | Court: Colorado Supreme Court (en...