7th Circuit Case Commentaries

Strict Rule 56.1 Enforcement and FMLA Third-Opinion Noncooperation: Seventh Circuit Affirms Summary Judgment in Brown v. CTA

Date: Jun 26, 2026

Strict Rule 56.1 Enforcement and FMLA Third-Opinion Noncooperation: Seventh Circuit Affirms Summary Judgment in Brown v. Chicago Transit Authority 1. Introduction Russia Brown v. Chicago Transit...

TCPA Vicarious Liability in Multi-Tier Telemarketing Requires Authority at Each Delegation Level; Treble Damages Require Knowing or Reckless Violations

Date: Jun 26, 2026

TCPA Vicarious Liability in Multi-Tier Telemarketing Requires Authority at Each Delegation Level; Treble Damages Require Knowing or Reckless Violations Case: Robert Hossfeld v. Allstate Insurance...

Speculation Cannot Prove Knowledge or Personal Responsibility: Summary Judgment Standards for Prison Retaliation and Eighth Amendment Claims

Date: Jun 26, 2026

Speculation Cannot Prove Knowledge or Personal Responsibility: Summary Judgment Standards for Prison Retaliation and Eighth Amendment Claims Case: Stanley Boclair v. Rob Jeffreys, et al. (No....

Referral Specialists Are Not State Actors Absent State Control: Seventh Circuit Reaffirms Limits of § 1983 Liability for Private Prisoner Care

Date: Jun 25, 2026

Referral Specialists Are Not State Actors Absent State Control: Seventh Circuit Reaffirms Limits of § 1983 Liability for Private Prisoner Care 1. Introduction In Denon Taylor v. Samuel Byrd (7th Cir....

Seventh Circuit Tightens TCPA Vicarious Liability: Subagency Requires Authority at Each Delegation Level; Treble Damages Require Knowing or Reckless Violations

Date: Jun 25, 2026

Seventh Circuit Tightens TCPA Vicarious Liability: Subagency Requires Authority at Each Delegation Level; Treble Damages Require Knowing or Reckless Violations I. Introduction Parties. Robert...

LHWCA § 20(a) “Harm” Includes Respiratory Symptoms Without a Definitive Diagnosis; Fee Challenges Are Waived Without Record Support

Date: Jun 25, 2026

LHWCA § 20(a) “Harm” Includes Respiratory Symptoms Without a Definitive Diagnosis; Fee Challenges Are Waived Without Record Support Case: Jeffboat, Incorporated v. Director, OWCP (7th Cir. June 23,...

RFRA Permits a Total Supervised-Release Alcohol Ban Despite a Requested Sabbath Wine Exception When the Record Shows Any Drinking Predictably Triggers Dangerous Relapse

Date: Jun 24, 2026

RFRA Permits a Total Supervised-Release Alcohol Ban Despite a Requested Sabbath Wine Exception When the Record Shows Any Drinking Predictably Triggers Dangerous Relapse I. Introduction In United...

Stays Denied Where a State Attorney General’s Out-of-State Enforcement Suit Appears Retaliatory and Bad-Faith: Younger’s Bad-Faith Exception and “Express Aiming” Jurisdiction

Date: Jun 23, 2026

Stays Denied Where a State Attorney General’s Out-of-State Enforcement Suit Appears Retaliatory and Bad-Faith: Younger’s Bad-Faith Exception and “Express Aiming” Jurisdiction 1. Introduction American...

FOIA Sanctions Must Not Force Overbroad Disclosure That Harms Innocent Third Parties; FOIA Release Injunctions Must Satisfy Rule 65(d)

Date: Jun 23, 2026

FOIA Sanctions Must Not Force Overbroad Disclosure That Harms Innocent Third Parties; FOIA Release Injunctions Must Satisfy Rule 65(d) Case: Jacqueline Stevens v. UNITED STATES IMMIGRATION AND...

FOIA Sanctions Must Not Compel Overbroad Disclosure: Rule 65 Specificity and Protection of Innocent Third-Party Interests

Date: Jun 23, 2026

FOIA Sanctions Must Not Compel Overbroad Disclosure: Rule 65 Specificity and Protection of Innocent Third-Party Interests Introduction In Jacqueline Stevens v. ICE, the Seventh Circuit reviewed a...

United States v. Cornelius Jackson — Probable Cause for Device Searches in Sex-Trafficking Investigations Despite Initial Victim Denials; Experience-Based Trafficking Expert Testimony Admissible Under Daubert with Tight Limits

Date: Jun 23, 2026

Probable Cause for Device Searches in Sex-Trafficking Investigations Survives Initial Victim Denials; Experience-Based Trafficking Expert Testimony Admissible Under Daubert When Narrowly Cabined...

United States v. Jackson (7th Cir. 2026) Commentary

Date: Jun 23, 2026

Experience-Based Sex-Trafficking Expert Testimony and Digital-Nexus Probable Cause: Narrow Tailoring Under Daubert, No Franks Hearing for Non-Material “Initial Denial” Omissions Case: United States...

Seventh Circuit: Below-Guidelines Sentences Satisfy § 3553(a)(6), and “Risk-Notification” Supervised-Release Conditions Must Be Specifically Defined

Date: Jun 22, 2026

Seventh Circuit: Below-Guidelines Sentences Satisfy § 3553(a)(6), and “Risk-Notification” Supervised-Release Conditions Must Be Specifically Defined I. Introduction In United States v. Daniel Quiggle...

CAFA Mass-Action “Local Event or Occurrence” Exception Is Jurisdictional and Turns on the Injury-Causing Event

Date: Jun 22, 2026

CAFA Mass-Action “Local Event or Occurrence” Exception Is Jurisdictional and Turns on the Injury-Causing Event Case: Tushawn Craig v. City of Richmond, Indiana (7th Cir. June 18, 2026) Court: United...

Email-Initiated Transfer Fraud Exclusion Applies to Fraudulent Instructions Sent to the Insured, Even When Sent Internally from a Compromised Employee Account

Date: Jun 22, 2026

Email-Initiated Transfer Fraud Exclusion Applies to Fraudulent Instructions Sent to the Insured, Even When Sent Internally from a Compromised Employee Account Introduction Office of the Special...

Hensley “Results Obtained” Allows Across-the-Board Lodestar Cuts Even for Interrelated Claims When Success Is Limited

Date: Jun 22, 2026

Hensley “Results Obtained” Allows Across-the-Board Lodestar Cuts Even for Interrelated Claims When Success Is Limited Immanuel Baptist Church v. City of Chicago (7th Cir. June 18, 2026)...

AIR 21 Petitions Must Be Received Within 60 Days: Mailing, E-Filing Rules, and the Limits of Equitable Tolling

Date: Jun 22, 2026

AIR 21 Petitions Must Be Received Within 60 Days: Mailing, E-Filing Rules, and the Limits of Equitable Tolling 1. Introduction Soma G. Priddle v. LABR is a Seventh Circuit petition-for-review case...

FHA Claims Falter When Housing Is Offered and Withdrawn: Disparate-Impact Requires Statistical Causation; Retaliation Requires Adverse Interference; Standing Requires Concrete Denial, Not Stigma

Date: Jun 22, 2026

FHA Claims Falter When Housing Is Offered and Withdrawn: Disparate-Impact Requires Statistical Causation; Retaliation Requires Adverse Interference; Standing Requires Concrete Denial, Not Stigma 1....

Essential-Term Certainty and Proof of Reliance: Limits on Contract, Fraud, and “Advisory” Misrepresentation Claims in Pre-Contract Collaborations

Date: Jun 22, 2026

Essential-Term Certainty and Proof of Reliance: Limits on Contract, Fraud, and “Advisory” Misrepresentation Claims in Pre-Contract Collaborations Case: Peters Broadcast Engineering, Inc. v. PEM...

Proportionality Limits on Sweeping Prison-Video Discovery and the Bad-Faith Threshold for Spoliation Sanctions (Seventh Circuit)

Date: Jun 17, 2026

Proportionality Limits on Sweeping Prison-Video Discovery and the Bad-Faith Threshold for Spoliation Sanctions (Seventh Circuit) Case: Littleton Jackson v. David Yang, et al. (No. 25-1973) Court:...