2d Circuit Case Commentaries

Misaligned Debtor–Trustee Interests Preclude Res Judicata Against Chapter 7 Trustees; Claim Objections Under Rule 3007 Are Timely Absent Court-Set Deadlines

Date: Oct 10, 2025

Misaligned Debtor–Trustee Interests Preclude Res Judicata Against Chapter 7 Trustees; Claim Objections Under Rule 3007 Are Timely Absent Court-Set Deadlines Commentary on Myer's Lawn Care Services,...

Second Circuit Confirms Special-Needs Authority to Search a Parolee’s Cellphone, Distinguishing Riley When the Device Is Unauthorized

Date: Oct 10, 2025

Second Circuit Confirms Special-Needs Authority to Search a Parolee’s Cellphone, Distinguishing Riley When the Device Is Unauthorized Introduction In United States v. Smurphat (No. 24-1707, 2d Cir....

Deed-in-Lieu with Deficiency Waiver Fixes the Year of COD Income; No “Later-Discovery” Exception to the Variance Doctrine — Commentary on Salta v. United States (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Oct 10, 2025

Deed-in-Lieu with Deficiency Waiver Fixes the Year of COD Income; No “Later-Discovery” Exception to the Variance Doctrine — Commentary on Salta v. United States (2d Cir. 2025) Court: U.S. Court of...

No Reversible Error from Unexplained “Associate Search” Reference: Second Circuit Affirms Under Harmless and Plain Error Frameworks in United States v. Morrison (Summary Order)

Date: Oct 10, 2025

No Reversible Error from Unexplained “Associate Search” Reference: Second Circuit Affirms Under Harmless and Plain Error Frameworks in United States v. Morrison (Summary Order) Introduction This...

“Life Minus Months Still Equals Life”: Second Circuit Reaffirms § 3583(h) Supervised-Release Calculus for § 2252A Revocations and Enforces Oral-Pronouncement Rule

Date: Oct 10, 2025

“Life Minus Months Still Equals Life”: Second Circuit Reaffirms § 3583(h) Supervised-Release Calculus for § 2252A Revocations and Enforces Oral-Pronouncement Rule Note on precedential status: This...

No FTCA Waiver When Vermont Workers’ Compensation Covers Multi‑Employer Injuries: Coverage by Any Employer Preserves Exclusive-Remedy Immunity for Federal “Statutory Employers”

Date: Oct 10, 2025

No FTCA Waiver When Vermont Workers’ Compensation Covers Multi‑Employer Injuries: Coverage by Any Employer Preserves Exclusive-Remedy Immunity for Federal “Statutory Employers” Case: Williams v....

Clark v. Valletta: Second Circuit Holds No Clearly Established Right to Specific Gender-Dysphoria Treatments; Qualified Immunity Applies and Objective Reasonableness Remains Distinct

Date: Oct 10, 2025

Clark v. Valletta: No Clearly Established Right to Specific Gender-Dysphoria Treatments; Objective Reasonableness Remains Distinct in Eighth Amendment Qualified Immunity Introduction In Clark v....

Fair Use Shields Satirical Broadcasts of Commissioned Cameo Videos; No Bad-Faith Bar, and Platform Terms Not Enforceable by Creators Absent Express Third-Party-Beneficiary Status

Date: Oct 10, 2025

Fair Use Shields Satirical Broadcasts of Commissioned Cameo Videos; No Bad-Faith Bar, and Platform Terms Not Enforceable by Creators Absent Express Third-Party-Beneficiary Status Case: Santos v....

Pleading Across Proceedings: Second Circuit Endorses Use of Other-Case Allegations (Rule 11–Limited) and Narrows “Storm Warnings” for Securities Act Timeliness — Commentary on Sherman v. Abengoa, S.A. (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Oct 10, 2025

Pleading Across Proceedings: Second Circuit Endorses Use of Other-Case Allegations (Rule 11–Limited) and Narrows “Storm Warnings” for Securities Act Timeliness — Commentary on Sherman v. Abengoa,...

Independent Warrant Analysis Required for Ride‑Hail App Searches During Traffic Stops: Second Circuit’s Nonprecedential Reminder in Etere v. Nassau County

Date: Oct 9, 2025

Independent Warrant Analysis Required for Ride‑Hail App Searches During Traffic Stops: Second Circuit’s Nonprecedential Reminder in Etere v. Nassau County Introduction In Etere v. Nassau County (No....

No Clearly Established Right to Proximity-Based Religious Accommodation in Prison Laundry: Tripathy v. Lockwood (2d Cir. 2025 Summary Order)

Date: Oct 9, 2025

No Clearly Established Right to Proximity-Based Religious Accommodation in Prison Laundry: Tripathy v. Lockwood (2d Cir. 2025 Summary Order) Introduction This commentary analyzes the Second Circuit’s...

Reaffirming Individualized Justifications Yet Affirming via Plain-Error Narrow Constructions: The Second Circuit’s Approach to Special Supervised Release Conditions in United States v. Schloss

Date: Oct 9, 2025

Reaffirming Individualized Justifications Yet Affirming via Plain-Error Narrow Constructions: The Second Circuit’s Approach to Special Supervised Release Conditions in United States v. Schloss...

Fee-Shifting After Remand: Second Circuit Confirms § 1447(c) Awards in “Unusual Circumstances” and Permits Post-Precedent Reasonableness Assessment

Date: Oct 9, 2025

Fee-Shifting After Remand: Second Circuit Confirms § 1447(c) Awards in “Unusual Circumstances” and Permits Post-Precedent Reasonableness Assessment Introduction In City of New York v. Exxon Mobil...

“#1 Brand” Claims Under the Lanham Act: The Second Circuit Clarifies That Literal Falsity Requires an Unambiguous Consumer Meaning When “Brand” May Refer to Parent or Product Lines

Date: Oct 9, 2025

“#1 Brand” Claims Under the Lanham Act: The Second Circuit Clarifies That Literal Falsity Requires an Unambiguous Consumer Meaning When “Brand” May Refer to Parent or Product Lines Introduction In...

Non‑Precedential Guidance on Inconclusive DNA Evidence, Constructive Possession, and the § 2K2.1(b)(6)(B) “In-Connection-With” Enhancement: Commentary on United States v. Fable (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Oct 9, 2025

Non‑Precedential Guidance on Inconclusive DNA Evidence, Constructive Possession, and the § 2K2.1(b)(6)(B) “In-Connection-With” Enhancement: Commentary on United States v. Fable (2d Cir. 2025)...

United States v. Halls: A Generic Reference to “Standard Conditions” Is Not a Valid Pronouncement of Non‑Mandatory Supervised Release Terms

Date: Oct 2, 2025

United States v. Halls: A Generic Reference to “Standard Conditions” Is Not a Valid Pronouncement of Non‑Mandatory Supervised Release Terms Second Circuit, Summary Order (Oct. 1, 2025). Panel: Judges...

Borelli v. Bisignano: When Treating Sources Refuse, No Further Duty to Develop; Step-Four Denial May Rest on Ability to Perform the “Previous Specific Job”; Later Favorable Decisions Don’t Compel Remand

Date: Oct 2, 2025

Borelli v. Bisignano: When Treating Sources Refuse, No Further Duty to Develop; Step-Four Denial May Rest on Ability to Perform the “Previous Specific Job”; Later Favorable Decisions Don’t Compel...

No Cognizable PSG for Generic Police Informants and No Political-Opinion Nexus; CAT Requires Particularized Risk: Second Circuit’s Summary Order in Velecela Rojas v. Bondi

Date: Oct 1, 2025

No Cognizable PSG for Generic Police Informants and No Political-Opinion Nexus; CAT Requires Particularized Risk: Second Circuit’s Summary Order in Velecela Rojas v. Bondi Court: United States Court...

Futility Requires Evidence and CAT Demands Official Acquiescence: Guidance from Masaquiza‑Masaquiza v. Bondi (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Futility Requires Evidence and CAT Demands Official Acquiescence: Guidance from Masaquiza‑Masaquiza v. Bondi (2d Cir. 2025) Note: This decision is a Summary Order of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the...

Second Circuit Reaffirms Permissibility of §2L1.2 “Double Counting” and Deferential Substantive-Reasonableness Review in Illegal-Reentry Sentencing

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Second Circuit Reaffirms Permissibility of §2L1.2 “Double Counting” and Deferential Substantive-Reasonableness Review in Illegal-Reentry Sentencing Introduction In United States v. Garcia-Gonzalez,...