2d Circuit Case Commentaries

Compliance with New York’s Health‑Care Vaccine Rule Defeats Title VII Religious-Accommodation Claims Absent a Proposed Duty Change; Short-Term Leave Alone Does Not Plead an ADA Disability

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Compliance with New York’s Health‑Care Vaccine Rule Defeats Title VII Religious-Accommodation Claims Absent a Proposed Duty Change; Short-Term Leave Alone Does Not Plead an ADA Disability Case: Cagle...

Physical Menace in Vermont Assault-and-Robbery Is a Crime of Violence Under the Guidelines’ Force Clause (Second Circuit Summary Order)

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Physical Menace in Vermont Assault-and-Robbery Is a Crime of Violence Under the Guidelines’ Force Clause (Second Circuit Summary Order) Case: United States v. Williams, No. 24-2696-cr (2d Cir. Sept....

Reaffirming a Particularly Deferential Substantive Reasonableness Review: Second Circuit Upholds High-End Guidelines Sentence Despite Lower Recommendations and Aggregate Disparity Data

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Reaffirming a Particularly Deferential Substantive Reasonableness Review: Second Circuit Upholds High-End Guidelines Sentence Despite Lower Recommendations and Aggregate Disparity Data Note: This is...

Reaffirming Pasternack’s Narrow Duty for Drug-Testing Labs: Procedural Irregularities Alone Do Not State Negligence Under New York Law

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Reaffirming Pasternack’s Narrow Duty for Drug-Testing Labs: Procedural Irregularities Alone Do Not State Negligence Under New York Law Introduction In Spencer v. Omega Laboratories, Inc., No....

Second Circuit reaffirms: delayed school-location notice does not deny FAPE absent prejudice; overlapping IEP services can satisfy goals without music, hearing, or vision therapies

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Second Circuit reaffirms: delayed school-location notice does not deny FAPE absent prejudice; overlapping IEP services can satisfy goals without music, hearing, or vision therapies Introduction In...

Unusual Deference to Mandated Reporters Reaffirmed; Consent-Based Home Body Checks Upheld; Qualified Immunity Shields § 1983 “Malicious Prosecution” Theories Based on Article 10 Petitions — Commentary on Stollman v. Williams (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Unusual Deference to Mandated Reporters Reaffirmed; Consent-Based Home Body Checks Upheld; Qualified Immunity Shields § 1983 “Malicious Prosecution” Theories Based on Article 10 Petitions Commentary...

Abandonment Is Fatal: Second Circuit Reaffirms “One Central Reason” Nexus for Withholding and CAT Acquiescence Requirement; Refers Counsel to Grievance Panel (Guerrero-Andachz v. Bondi)

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Abandonment Is Fatal: Second Circuit Reaffirms “One Central Reason” Nexus for Withholding and CAT Acquiescence Requirement; Refers Counsel to Grievance Panel Introduction In Guerrero-Andachz v....

Second Circuit Reinforces Specificity in Software Trade Secrets and Limits NDAs to Information Actually Treated as Confidential — Capricorn Mgmt. Sys., Inc. v. GEICO & CCC (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Second Circuit Reinforces Specificity in Software Trade Secrets and Limits NDAs to Information Actually Treated as Confidential — Capricorn Mgmt. Sys., Inc. v. GEICO & CCC (2d Cir. 2025) Court: U.S....

No Interlocutory Appeal of Qualified Immunity Denials When Genuine Fact Disputes Persist: Cornelius v. Luna (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Sep 30, 2025

No Interlocutory Appeal of Qualified Immunity Denials When Genuine Fact Disputes Persist: Cornelius v. Luna (2d Cir. 2025) Court: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit (Summary Order,...

No Constructive Amendment Where §1344 Indictment Language Subsumes Both Prongs; Second Circuit Reaffirms Deference to “Intended Loss” Commentary and Jointly Undertaken Activity at Sentencing (United States v. Rahmankulov)

Date: Sep 30, 2025

No Constructive Amendment Where §1344 Indictment Language Subsumes Both Prongs; Second Circuit Reaffirms Deference to “Intended Loss” Commentary and Jointly Undertaken Activity at Sentencing Case:...

“Move Over” Means Move Over: Second Circuit (Nonprecedential) Clarification That N.Y. VTL § 1144-a(b) Mandates a Lane Change (When Safe), Supporting Reasonable Suspicion for a Traffic Stop

Date: Sep 30, 2025

“Move Over” Means Move Over: Second Circuit (Nonprecedential) Clarification That N.Y. VTL § 1144-a(b) Mandates a Lane Change (When Safe), Supporting Reasonable Suspicion for a Traffic Stop...

Reaffirming Deference to Sentencing Courts: Above-Guidelines Variance Upheld for Aggravated NFA Possession Involving Discharge and Protective-Order Violations

Date: Sep 30, 2025

Reaffirming Deference to Sentencing Courts: Above-Guidelines Variance Upheld for Aggravated NFA Possession Involving Discharge and Protective-Order Violations Introduction In United States v....

Channel Stuffing as a Half-Truth: The Second Circuit Confirms 10b-5(b) Liability and Clarifies Scienter and “Truth-on-the-Market” at the Pleading Stage

Date: Sep 30, 2025

Channel Stuffing as a Half-Truth: The Second Circuit Confirms 10b-5(b) Liability and Clarifies Scienter and “Truth-on-the-Market” at the Pleading Stage Introduction In Gimpel v. Hain Celestial Group,...

After Delligatti, VICAR Attempted Murder Categorically Supports §924(c) “Crime of Violence”; Stipulated §2K2.1(b)(6)(B) Enhancements Are Effectively Unreviewable

Date: Sep 30, 2025

After Delligatti, VICAR Attempted Murder Categorically Supports §924(c) “Crime of Violence”; Stipulated §2K2.1(b)(6)(B) Enhancements Are Effectively Unreviewable Introduction In United States v....

Second Circuit Reaffirms Sloley I: Visual Body Cavity Searches Require Reasonable Suspicion of Concealment Inside a Body Cavity; Erroneous “in or on” Jury Instruction Warrants New Trial

Date: Sep 27, 2025

Second Circuit Reaffirms Sloley I: Visual Body Cavity Searches Require Reasonable Suspicion of Concealment Inside a Body Cavity; Erroneous “in or on” Jury Instruction Warrants New Trial Case: Sloley...

Ambiguity in Pro Se Filing Timing and Accrual of False Imprisonment Precludes 12(b)(6) Time-Bar Dismissal: Corley v. Rantab Enterprises, Inc. (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Sep 27, 2025

Ambiguity in Pro Se Filing Timing and Accrual of False Imprisonment Precludes 12(b)(6) Time-Bar Dismissal Introduction In a nonprecedential but instructive summary order, the United States Court of...

No “In-for-One, In-for-All” Duty for Non‑Insurer Indemnitors Under Illinois Law: Second Circuit’s Predictive Ruling in BP Products North America Inc. v. ExxonMobil Corp. (Summary Order)

Date: Sep 27, 2025

No “In-for-One, In-for-All” Duty for Non‑Insurer Indemnitors Under Illinois Law: Second Circuit’s Predictive Ruling in BP Products North America Inc. v. ExxonMobil Corp. (Summary Order) Introduction...

Second Circuit reaffirms: Gang defection is not “political opinion” and CAT relief demands individualized proof and government acquiescence

Date: Sep 26, 2025

Second Circuit reaffirms: Gang defection is not “political opinion” and CAT relief demands individualized proof and government acquiescence Introduction In Ramirez Alvarado v. Bondi (No. 21-6603,...

Umarov v. Bondi: Second Circuit Reaffirms Nonreviewability of BIA’s Sua Sponte Reopening and Declines to Treat Pereira/Niz‑Chavez Eligibility as Exceptional

Date: Sep 26, 2025

Umarov v. Bondi: Second Circuit Reaffirms Nonreviewability of BIA’s Sua Sponte Reopening and Declines to Treat Pereira/Niz‑Chavez Eligibility as Exceptional Introduction In a nonprecedential summary...

Moslem (2d Cir. 2025): Harmless Ciminelli Instruction Error, Intended-Loss Sentencing, and Dubin’s “Who” Standard for Aggravated Identity Theft

Date: Sep 26, 2025

Moslem (2d Cir. 2025): Harmless Ciminelli Instruction Error, Intended-Loss Sentencing, and Dubin’s “Who” Standard for Aggravated Identity Theft Note on precedential status: The court labeled this a...