Reserved-Rights Plea Agreements Permit Government Advocacy for Additional Enhancements; Sadism Enhancement Applies to Morphed Images; Obstruction Adjustment Reaches Overlapping Investigations Note:...
Conscious Avoidance Limited to Conspiracy Knowledge and MVRA Attorneys’ Fees May Be Awarded Without Detailed Billing: United States v. Rains (2d Cir. 2025, Summary Order) Court: U.S. Court of Appeals...
Clearing the 340B Antitrust Path: Second Circuit Confirms Astra/Illinois Brick Do Not Bar Section 1 Claims and Endorses a Flexible Parallel-Conduct Pleading Standard Introduction In Mosaic Health,...
No Step-Two Without a “Meaningful Constraint”: Second Circuit Upholds New York’s Ammunition Background Check Regime at Bruen’s Threshold Introduction In N.Y. State Firearms Ass'n v. James, No....
Second Circuit Reaffirms No-Legitimacy-Inquiry Rule under FOIA Exemption 7 and Treats Unit Identifiers as Protected “Guidelines” under Exemption 7(E); Strict Showing Required for Catalyst-Fees Claims...
Clear-Error Review of “Exceptional and Extremely Unusual Hardship” and Continued Reliance on Monreal-Aguinaga Post-Loper Bright: Flores-Rueda v. Bondi Introduction This commentary examines the Second...
Second Circuit reaffirms that vague internal complaints are not “protected activity” under Title VII and that comparators sharing the same protected traits undermine an inference of discriminatory...
Second Circuit Reaffirms: Documented Financial Restructuring and Outsourcing Can Defeat ADEA Pretext at Summary Judgment Case: Tillman v. Grenadier Realty Corp., No. 24-2325-cv (2d Cir. Oct. 14,...
Clarifying IDEA Remand Scope and Procedural Violations: Second Circuit Summary Order on Bilingual Services, IEP Gaps, and Compensatory Education Timing Introduction Case: Y.S. v. New York City...
Second Circuit (Non-Precedential) Guidance on Successive Summary Judgment Motions and Relation-Forward Appellate Jurisdiction in Pro Se Prisoner Litigation Note on precedential weight: This is a...
Drug Identity Is Not an Element of N.J. Stat. § 2C:35-5(b)(1): Second Circuit Bars the Modified Categorical Approach in Aggravated-Felony Removal Case: Amaro Luna v. Bondi, No. 22-6399 (2d Cir. Oct....
Harmless-Error Controls § 1324 “Reckless Disregard” Instruction Disputes: United States v. Adames-Ramos (2d Cir. 2025) Note: This is a Second Circuit Summary Order. Under FRAP 32.1 and Local Rule...
Errato v. Seder (2d Cir. 2025): No Federal Do‑Over of Divorce Judgments; Independent Fraud Claims May Evade the Domestic Relations Exception but Are Precluded After Prior Litigation Court: U.S. Court...
Second Circuit confirms: Seven-figure emotional distress awards in attempted workplace rape need no medical proof; amounts exceeding the Title VII cap properly ride on NYCHRL/NYSHRL Introduction In...
Reaffirming Broad District Court Discretion in § 3582(c)(2) Motions After Amendment 821: Emphasis on Unchanged Criminal History Is Permissible Introduction In United States v. Ahmed (No. 24-2629),...
Reaffirming the SSI Application Prerequisite and SSR 18‑01p’s Threshold: Anthony v. Saul (2d Cir. 2025) Note on precedential status: This is a Second Circuit Summary Order, which does not have...
Chapter 7 Trustee Not Bound by Debtor‑Only Adversary Judgments; Rule 3007 Objections Are Timely Absent Court Deadlines; Fraud-Based Veil Piercing Requires Intent at Contract Formation Commentary on...
Enforcing Appeal Waivers Absent Government Breach: Government May Characterize Offense Conduct and Argue § 3553(a) Factors Within a Stipulated Guidelines Range Case: United States v. Handler (2d...
Second Circuit Extends Honeycutt to § 981(a)(1)(C): Criminal Forfeiture Requires Personal Acquisition of Proceeds Introduction In United States v. Elias, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second...
Demanding Cogent Reasons for BIA Clear-Error Reversals of CAT Grants: Villalta Martinez v. Bondi (2d Cir. 2025) Introduction In Villalta Martinez v. Bondi, the United States Court of Appeals for the...