2d Circuit Case Commentaries

Harmless Guidelines Error under a Rule 11(c)(1)(C) Plea and “Self‑Evident” Justification for Alcohol‑Abstinence Conditions: United States v. Goins (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Oct 25, 2025

Harmless Guidelines Error under a Rule 11(c)(1)(C) Plea and “Self‑Evident” Justification for Alcohol‑Abstinence Conditions: United States v. Goins (2d Cir. 2025) Note on precedential status: This is...

Second Circuit Narrows “Misappropriation” Exclusion: Client‑Authorized Fund Transfers Do Not Defeat Duty to Defend Under New York Law

Date: Oct 25, 2025

Second Circuit Narrows “Misappropriation” Exclusion: Client‑Authorized Fund Transfers Do Not Defeat Duty to Defend Under New York Law Introduction In Marcus & Cinelli, LLP v. Aspen American Insurance...

Material Omissions and Conflicting Residence Evidence Sustain Adverse Credibility Under the REAL ID Act: Chen v. Bondi (2d Cir. 2025) [Summary Order]

Date: Oct 24, 2025

Material Omissions and Conflicting Residence Evidence Sustain Adverse Credibility Under the REAL ID Act: Chen v. Bondi (2d Cir. 2025) [Summary Order] Court: United States Court of Appeals for the...

Circumstance-Specific Proof of Protection-Order Violations May Rely on PSIs and Conviction Elements; Indictment Time Ranges Can Fix CIMT “Commission” Date for Stop-Time Purposes

Date: Oct 24, 2025

Circumstance-Specific Proof of Protection-Order Violations May Rely on PSIs and Conviction Elements; Indictment Time Ranges Can Fix CIMT “Commission” Date for Stop-Time Purposes Case: Moco v. Bondi,...

Second Circuit Clarifies Pro Se Estate Representation and Upholds Qualified Immunity for Warrantless Code‑Enforcement Entry Under Claimed Exigent Circumstances: Simmons v. Incorporated Village of Rockville Centre

Date: Oct 24, 2025

Second Circuit Clarifies Pro Se Estate Representation and Upholds Qualified Immunity for Warrantless Code‑Enforcement Entry Under Claimed Exigent Circumstances Case: Simmons v. Incorporated Village...

No §3C1.1 Obstruction Enhancement on a Bare “Perjury” Label: Second Circuit Requires Discernable Dunnigan Findings in United States v. Onah

Date: Oct 24, 2025

No §3C1.1 Obstruction Enhancement on a Bare “Perjury” Label: Second Circuit Requires Discernable Dunnigan Findings in United States v. Onah Introduction In a summary order issued on October 21, 2025,...

Second Circuit: No Property Right to Continue as a Medicaid Fiscal Intermediary; CDPAP Consolidation Survives Takings, Contracts, and Due Process Challenges

Date: Oct 24, 2025

Second Circuit: No Property Right to Continue as a Medicaid Fiscal Intermediary; CDPAP Consolidation Survives Takings, Contracts, and Due Process Challenges Introduction In Principle Homecare, LLC v....

(Nonprecedential) Second Circuit Clarifies That Home Health Care Benefits Require Either a Licensed Agency or a Certified/Licensed Aide: Jackling v. Brighthouse Life Insurance Co.

Date: Oct 22, 2025

(Nonprecedential) Second Circuit Clarifies That Home Health Care Benefits Require Either a Licensed Agency or a Certified/Licensed Aide: Jackling v. Brighthouse Life Insurance Co. Introduction In an...

Express Incorporation of “Standard Conditions 1–12” Satisfies Maiorana; Delegation of Treatment Details and Third‑Party Search Notifications Upheld

Date: Oct 22, 2025

Express Incorporation of “Standard Conditions 1–12” Satisfies Maiorana; Delegation of Treatment Details and Third‑Party Search Notifications Upheld Introduction In United States v. Randolph, No....

Clear-Error Review of Hardship Mixed Questions and Strict Ineffective-Assistance Prerequisites in Non-LPR Cancellation: Ramirez Lopez v. Bondi (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Oct 19, 2025

Clear-Error Review of Hardship Mixed Questions and Strict Ineffective-Assistance Prerequisites in Non-LPR Cancellation: Ramirez Lopez v. Bondi (2d Cir. 2025) Introduction In Ramirez Lopez v. Bondi,...

Removal Waives Eleventh Amendment Immunity, Not General Sovereign Immunity; Equal Protection § 1983 Claims Require Specific Comparators and Impermissible Motive — Commentary on Bell v. University of the State of N.Y. (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Oct 18, 2025

Removal Waives Eleventh Amendment Immunity, Not General Sovereign Immunity; Equal Protection § 1983 Claims Require Specific Comparators and Impermissible Motive Case: Bell v. University of the State...

“Notice + Barricades” Suffice: Second Circuit Affirms No Jones Act Negligence or Unseaworthiness for a Temporarily Open Hatch, and Rejects Case-Dispositive Spoliation Sanctions

Date: Oct 18, 2025

“Notice + Barricades” Suffice: Second Circuit Affirms No Jones Act Negligence or Unseaworthiness for a Temporarily Open Hatch, and Rejects Case-Dispositive Spoliation Sanctions Court: U.S. Court of...

Second Circuit Reaffirms Three-Year Limitations and Narrow Continuing-Violation Doctrine for Title IX Claims; Upholds Early Conversion to Summary Judgment in Pund v. St. Francis College

Date: Oct 18, 2025

Second Circuit Reaffirms Three-Year Limitations and Narrow Continuing-Violation Doctrine for Title IX Claims; Upholds Early Conversion to Summary Judgment in Pund v. St. Francis College Court: U.S....

No Habeas-by-Compassionate-Release: Second Circuit Affirms Denial Based on § 3553(a) and Individualized Circumstances in United States v. Andrews

Date: Oct 18, 2025

No Habeas-by-Compassionate-Release: Second Circuit Affirms Denial Based on § 3553(a) and Individualized Circumstances in United States v. Andrews Court: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit...

Baseless Damages Theories and Bad-Faith Settlement Tactics Can Render a Lanham Act Case “Exceptional” and Support § 1927 Sanctions: Second Circuit Affirms Fee Award and Joint-and-Several Liability Without a Hearing

Date: Oct 17, 2025

Baseless Damages Theories and Bad-Faith Settlement Tactics Can Render a Lanham Act Case “Exceptional” and Support § 1927 Sanctions: Second Circuit Affirms Fee Award and Joint-and-Several Liability...

Basra v. Bondi: Reaffirming Strict Limits on Untimely, Number‑Barred Motions to Reopen—No Changed‑Conditions Reopening Without Credibility Rehabilitation; Equitable Tolling Requires Diligence

Date: Oct 17, 2025

Basra v. Bondi: Reaffirming Strict Limits on Untimely, Number‑Barred Motions to Reopen—No Changed‑Conditions Reopening Without Credibility Rehabilitation; Equitable Tolling Requires Diligence...

Unlicensed Home Health Aides Are Not Covered: Second Circuit’s Nonprecedential Clarification of Brighthouse’s Home Health Care Benefits

Date: Oct 17, 2025

Unlicensed Home Health Aides Are Not Covered: Second Circuit’s Nonprecedential Clarification of Brighthouse’s Home Health Care Benefits Case: Jackling v. Brighthouse Life Insurance Company (No....

Misconduct Is Not Disability Discrimination: Second Circuit Reaffirms that the ADA Does Not Require Excusing Disruptive Conduct and Demands Plausible Causation for Discrimination, Accommodation, and Retaliation Claims in Youth Sports Settings

Date: Oct 17, 2025

Misconduct Is Not Disability Discrimination: Second Circuit Reaffirms that the ADA Does Not Require Excusing Disruptive Conduct and Demands Plausible Causation for Discrimination, Accommodation, and...

Foreseeability and Realistic Opportunity to Intervene: Second Circuit Reaffirms Deliberate Indifference Pleading Standards and Duplicative Official-Capacity Claims in Montgomery v. Orange County

Date: Oct 17, 2025

Foreseeability and Realistic Opportunity to Intervene: Second Circuit Reaffirms Deliberate Indifference Pleading Standards and Duplicative Official-Capacity Claims in Montgomery v. Orange County...

United States v. Hild: No Actual-Loss Requirement, No Brady Duty to Highlight, and No Automatic Recusal for Spouse’s Law Firm Ties (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Oct 17, 2025

United States v. Hild: No Actual-Loss Requirement, No Brady Duty to Highlight, and No Automatic Recusal for Spouse’s Law Firm Ties Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit Date:...