2d Circuit Case Commentaries

Chen v. Rubio: Second Circuit Limits “Mandel” Review to Cases Burdening a U.S. Citizen’s Constitutional Rights and Extends Muñoz Beyond Spouses to Parents and Siblings

Date: Nov 1, 2025

Chen v. Rubio: Second Circuit Limits “Mandel” Review to Cases Burdening a U.S. Citizen’s Constitutional Rights and Extends Muñoz Beyond Spouses to Parents and Siblings Introduction In Chen v. Rubio,...

Authority to Withdraw Funds Equals Pecuniary Interest: Second Circuit Affirms §16(b) Disgorgement and Endorses IRS Underpayment Rate for Prejudgment Interest

Date: Oct 30, 2025

Authority to Withdraw Funds Equals Pecuniary Interest: Second Circuit Affirms §16(b) Disgorgement and Endorses IRS Underpayment Rate for Prejudgment Interest Case: Avalon Holdings Corp. v. Gentile,...

Second Circuit Reaffirms Strict Rule 8 Enforcement and Accepts COVID-19 Testing as Reasonable Religious Accommodation (Nonprecedential)

Date: Oct 30, 2025

Second Circuit Reaffirms Strict Rule 8 Enforcement and Accepts COVID-19 Testing as Reasonable Religious Accommodation (Nonprecedential) Case: Johnson v. Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide, LLC...

Second Circuit Clarifies Revocation Sentencing: Undisputed Probation Facts and Similarity to Prior Offense Can Support an Upward Variance; Retribution for the Underlying Conviction Remains Off-Limits Post‑Esteras

Date: Oct 30, 2025

Second Circuit Clarifies Revocation Sentencing: Undisputed Probation Facts and Similarity to Prior Offense Can Support an Upward Variance; Retribution for the Underlying Conviction Remains Off-Limits...

Insurrection Under War-Risk Policies Includes Acts by a De Facto Regime Against the U.S.-Recognized Government; “Arising From” Requires But-For Causation

Date: Oct 30, 2025

Insurrection Under War-Risk Policies Includes Acts by a De Facto Regime Against the U.S.-Recognized Government; “Arising From” Requires But-For Causation Introduction In CITGO Petroleum Corp. v....

Reiterated Objections Require De Novo Review: The Second Circuit Clarifies “Proper Objections” to Magistrate Judge R&Rs in Nambiar v. The Central Orthopedic Group, LLP

Date: Oct 30, 2025

Reiterated Objections Require De Novo Review: The Second Circuit Clarifies “Proper Objections” to Magistrate Judge R&Rs in Nambiar v. The Central Orthopedic Group, LLP Introduction In this...

Evidence, Not Assumptions: Second Circuit’s Summary Order Clarifies “Least Intrusive Means” Proof Under the TCA and Upholds Coexistence of Vermont’s “Substantial Deference” with Federal “Substantial Evidence”

Date: Oct 30, 2025

Evidence, Not Assumptions: Second Circuit’s Summary Order Clarifies “Least Intrusive Means” Proof Under the TCA and Upholds Coexistence of Vermont’s “Substantial Deference” with Federal “Substantial...

Second Circuit Clarifies Probable Cause Across Undifferentiated Multi-Unit Homes and Upholds Brief Continued Presence During Search: Medina v. Stevens (Summary Order)

Date: Oct 30, 2025

Second Circuit Clarifies Probable Cause Across Undifferentiated Multi-Unit Homes and Upholds Brief Continued Presence During Search Case: Medina v. Stevens, No. 24-2968 (2d Cir. Oct. 27, 2025)...

Second Circuit Reaffirms No “Prevailing Party” Status After Forum Non Conveniens Dismissal; Rule 41(d) Cost Awards Are Discretionary and Unresolved as to Foreign Dismissals

Date: Oct 30, 2025

Second Circuit Reaffirms No “Prevailing Party” Status After Forum Non Conveniens Dismissal; Rule 41(d) Cost Awards Are Discretionary and Unresolved as to Foreign Dismissals Introduction In Paulo v....

United States v. Raniere: Second Circuit Reaffirms Strict Standards for Rule 33 “Newly Discovered Evidence,” No Freestanding Post‑Judgment Discovery Right, and the High Bar for Judicial Recusal

Date: Oct 30, 2025

United States v. Raniere: Second Circuit Reaffirms Strict Standards for Rule 33 “Newly Discovered Evidence,” No Freestanding Post‑Judgment Discovery Right, and the High Bar for Judicial Recusal...

When a Conspiracy Acquittal Necessarily Rejects the Core Factual Theory, Double Jeopardy Bars Retrial on Substantive Counts — United States v. Cole (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Oct 30, 2025

When a Conspiracy Acquittal Necessarily Rejects the Core Factual Theory, Double Jeopardy Bars Retrial on Substantive Counts — United States v. Cole (2d Cir. 2025) Introduction In United States v....

Ceccarelli v. Morgan Stanley: Second Circuit reiterates the Rooker-Feldman/Res Judicata divide in post-foreclosure TILA suits and requires without-prejudice jurisdictional dismissals

Date: Oct 28, 2025

Ceccarelli v. Morgan Stanley: Second Circuit reiterates the Rooker-Feldman/Res Judicata divide in post-foreclosure TILA suits and requires without-prejudice jurisdictional dismissals Introduction In...

Non‑Reserved Acceptance Triggers Inter‑Insurer Estoppel: Second Circuit Affirms Standing, Reliance, and Prejudice in Penn‑Star v. Dongbu

Date: Oct 28, 2025

Non‑Reserved Acceptance Triggers Inter‑Insurer Estoppel: Second Circuit Affirms Standing, Reliance, and Prejudice in Penn‑Star v. Dongbu Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit...

Residential Storage Triggers the §2D1.1(b)(12) “Stash House” Enhancement; DWAI Always Counts in Criminal History Under Amended §4A1.2 cmt. n.5; Appeal Waiver Bars Fine Challenge — United States v. Luizzi (2d Cir. 2025 Summary Order)

Date: Oct 28, 2025

Residential Storage Triggers the §2D1.1(b)(12) “Stash House” Enhancement; DWAI Always Counts in Criminal History Under Amended §4A1.2 cmt. n.5; Appeal Waiver Bars Fine Challenge — United States v....

Second Circuit Reaffirms PLRA 150% Fee Cap and Declines “Mini En Banc” Reconsideration in Webb v. Trombley

Date: Oct 28, 2025

Second Circuit Reaffirms PLRA 150% Fee Cap and Declines “Mini En Banc” Reconsideration in Webb v. Trombley Introduction In Webb v. Trombley, No. 24-2582-pr (2d Cir. Oct. 24, 2025) (Summary Order),...

Second Circuit Confirms Constitutional Limit on Mandatory § 1226(c) Detention: Bond Hearing Required Once Detention Becomes Unreasonably Prolonged, With Government’s Clear-and-Convincing Burden

Date: Oct 28, 2025

Second Circuit Confirms Constitutional Limit on Mandatory § 1226(c) Detention: Bond Hearing Required Once Detention Becomes Unreasonably Prolonged, With Government’s Clear-and-Convincing Burden...

Qualifying-Child Status for Non–LPR Cancellation Is Measured at Adjudication, Not Filing: Yupangui‑Yunga v. Bondi (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Oct 28, 2025

Qualifying-Child Status for Non–LPR Cancellation Is Measured at Adjudication, Not Filing Commentary on Yupangui‑Yunga v. Bondi, No. 23‑6522 (2d Cir. Oct. 24, 2025) Introduction In this precedential...

Minimal Inference Reaffirmed: Coworker Allegations and Facially Neutral Acts May Form the “Mosaic” Supporting Title VII/NYSHRL Pleadings

Date: Oct 25, 2025

Minimal Inference Reaffirmed: Coworker Allegations and Facially Neutral Acts May Form the “Mosaic” Supporting Title VII/NYSHRL Pleadings Case: Brown v. Montefiore Health System, Inc., No. 24-3078-cv...

“Something More” Still Means More: Second Circuit Reaffirms Narrow Defamation Jurisdiction Under CPLR 302(a)(1) and Rejects Property-Based Hook Under 302(a)(4) for Third-Party USPS “Known Office of Publication”

Date: Oct 25, 2025

“Something More” Still Means More: Second Circuit Reaffirms Narrow Defamation Jurisdiction Under CPLR 302(a)(1) and Rejects Property-Based Hook Under 302(a)(4) for Third-Party USPS “Known Office of...

“Outside the Heartland” in §924(c) Sentencing: Second Circuit Affirms Significant Upward Variances When Firearm Use Results in Homicide

Date: Oct 25, 2025

“Outside the Heartland” in §924(c) Sentencing: Second Circuit Affirms Significant Upward Variances When Firearm Use Results in Homicide Introduction In United States v. Ben-Jochannan (consolidated...