2d Circuit Case Commentaries

Citigroup Review Governs EEOC Title VII Consent Decrees Replacing Long-Running Injunctions; Missing Court-Ordered Data Can Defeat “Fair and Reasonable” Findings

Date: Feb 15, 2026

Citigroup Review Governs EEOC Title VII Consent Decrees Replacing Long-Running Injunctions; Missing Court-Ordered Data Can Defeat “Fair and Reasonable” Findings I. Introduction United States Equal...

CAT Protection Requires Particularized Evidence of Future Torture When Past Harm Was Tied to Abandoned Property

Date: Feb 15, 2026

CAT Protection Requires Particularized Evidence of Future Torture When Past Harm Was Tied to Abandoned Property Introduction In Ramirez Gastiaburo v. Bondi (2d Cir. Feb. 13, 2026) (summary order),...

Reidy Contracting Group, LLC v. Mt. Hawley Insurance Company — Nested-List Interpretation of Additional-Insured Grants and Ambiguity in Employers’ Liability Exclusions Under Separation-of-Insureds Clauses

Date: Feb 15, 2026

Nested-List Interpretation of Additional-Insured Grants and Ambiguity in Employers’ Liability Exclusions Under Separation-of-Insureds Clauses Reidy Contracting Group, LLC v. Mt. Hawley Insurance...

Standing Limits for LLC Owners Seeking Coverage and the Mandatory “Without Prejudice” Rule for Jurisdictional Dismissals

Date: Feb 15, 2026

Standing Limits for LLC Owners Seeking Coverage and the Mandatory “Without Prejudice” Rule for Jurisdictional Dismissals 1. Introduction In Griffin v. Travelers Prop. Cas. Co. of Am. (2d Cir. Feb....

Judicial Review Limits in Good-Faith Marriage Waiver Denials: Evidence-Weighing Is Unreviewable and Hardship Theories Must Be Exhausted

Date: Feb 15, 2026

Judicial Review Limits in Good-Faith Marriage Waiver Denials: Evidence-Weighing Is Unreviewable and Hardship Theories Must Be Exhausted 1. Introduction In Sheraz v. Bondi (2d Cir. Feb. 12, 2026)...

Within-Guidelines Sentences and § 3553(a)(6): Statistical “Powder Cocaine” Comparators and Co-Defendant Comparisons Do Not Show Substantive Unreasonableness When Additional Fentanyl Risk Is Present (United States v. Fausel)

Date: Feb 15, 2026

Within-Guidelines Sentences and § 3553(a)(6): Statistical “Powder Cocaine” Comparators and Co-Defendant Comparisons Do Not Show Substantive Unreasonableness When Additional Fentanyl Risk Is Present...

Safe-Deposit Box Exculpatory Clauses Bar Cash-Loss Claims Absent Plausibly Pleaded Gross Negligence (Wright v. TD Bank N.A.)

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Safe-Deposit Box Exculpatory Clauses Bar Cash-Loss Claims Absent Plausibly Pleaded Gross Negligence (Wright v. TD Bank N.A., 2d Cir. Feb. 11, 2026) Introduction Parties: Yvonne Wright...

Delaney v. HC2, Inc.: Section 487 Claims May Fail Without Particularized, Plausible Allegations of Intentional Deceit—Even If Federal-Court Applicability Remains Unresolved

Date: Feb 12, 2026

Delaney v. HC2, Inc.: Section 487 Claims May Fail Without Particularized, Plausible Allegations of Intentional Deceit—Even If Federal-Court Applicability Remains Unresolved 1. Introduction In Delaney...

FDIC Receiver Shield: No Non‑Customer Bank Duty Absent a Recorded Fiduciary Account Agreement

Date: Feb 12, 2026

FDIC Receiver Shield: No Non‑Customer Bank Duty Absent a Recorded Fiduciary Account Agreement Case: Q3 Investments Recovery Vehicle, LLC v. FDIC (2d Cir. Feb. 10, 2026) (Summary Order)...

Second Circuit Limits DMCA § 512(c) Safe Harbor When Platforms Manually and Discretionarily Curate User Uploads

Date: Feb 12, 2026

Second Circuit Limits DMCA § 512(c) Safe Harbor When Platforms Manually and Discretionarily Curate User Uploads Introduction McGucken v. Shutterstock, Inc. (2d Cir. Feb. 10, 2026) addresses the scope...

Moses v. The New York Times Company (2d Cir. Feb. 10, 2026) — “Practice Changes” that Merely Memorialize Past Conduct Are Not Injunctive Relief for Article III Purposes in Class Settlements

Date: Feb 12, 2026

“Practice Changes” that Merely Memorialize Past Conduct Are Not Injunctive Relief for Article III Purposes in Class Settlements Case: Moses v. The New York Times Company, No. 24-2979 (2d Cir. Feb....

Gang Extortion and the Nexus Requirement: Single-Mother Status, Without Evidence of Motive, Does Not Establish Asylum Eligibility

Date: Feb 12, 2026

Gang Extortion and the Nexus Requirement: Single-Mother Status, Without Evidence of Motive, Does Not Establish Asylum Eligibility 1. Introduction Saldana-Guaman v. Bondi (2d Cir. Feb. 10, 2026) is a...

Second Circuit Reaffirms Deferential Review of Trial Management: No Plain-Error “Judicial Bias,” Rule 403 Limits on Anonymous-Complaint Impeachment, Summation Inference Latitude, and §3C1.1 Perjury Enhancement for Categorical Bribe Denials

Date: Feb 12, 2026

Second Circuit Reaffirms Deferential Review of Trial Management: No Plain-Error “Judicial Bias,” Rule 403 Limits on Anonymous-Complaint Impeachment, Summation Inference Latitude, and §3C1.1 Perjury...

Alcohol-Related Components of a “Substance Abuse” Supervised-Release Condition May Be Upheld on Plain-Error Review Based on General Sobriety Monitoring and a Defendant’s Drug-Use History

Date: Feb 12, 2026

Alcohol-Related Components of a “Substance Abuse” Supervised-Release Condition May Be Upheld on Plain-Error Review Based on General Sobriety Monitoring and a Defendant’s Drug-Use History 1....

Untimely Reconsideration Motions Do Not Toll Appellate Deadlines; Late Rule 59(e) Motions Are Treated as Rule 60(b)

Date: Feb 11, 2026

Untimely Reconsideration Motions Do Not Toll Appellate Deadlines; Late Rule 59(e) Motions Are Treated as Rule 60(b) 1. Introduction Reid v. Mello, No. 24-1551-cv (2d Cir. Feb. 9, 2026) (summary...

Dispositive-Finding Waiver and Mandatory Issue Exhaustion in Second Circuit Immigration Petitions; Ineffective-Assistance Remedy via Lozada Motion to Reopen

Date: Feb 10, 2026

Dispositive-Finding Waiver and Mandatory Issue Exhaustion in Second Circuit Immigration Petitions; Ineffective-Assistance Remedy via Lozada Motion to Reopen 1. Introduction In Chicaiza-Lluay v. Bondi...

Bankruptcy Plan Language and Rule 155 Cannot Preclude or Re-Litigate IRS Shareholder-Ownership Tax Deficiencies

Date: Feb 10, 2026

Bankruptcy Plan Language and Rule 155 Cannot Preclude or Re-Litigate IRS Shareholder-Ownership Tax Deficiencies 1. Introduction In Veeraswamy v. Comm'r of Internal Revenue (2d Cir. Feb. 9, 2026)...

Record-Based Justification Required for Employer-Notification Conditions Imposed at Supervised-Release Revocation

Date: Feb 8, 2026

Record-Based Justification Required for Employer-Notification Conditions Imposed at Supervised-Release Revocation Introduction United States v. Baker (2d Cir. Feb. 6, 2026) is a nonprecedential...

Lower Out-of-Network Reimbursement and “Repricing” Vendor Arrangements Do Not Plead Antitrust Injury Absent Exclusion or a Plausible Horizontal Agreement

Date: Feb 8, 2026

Lower Out-of-Network Reimbursement and “Repricing” Vendor Arrangements Do Not Plead Antitrust Injury Absent Exclusion or a Plausible Horizontal Agreement 1. Introduction In Long Island...

Arbitral Final Awards Preclude “Protective” Federal Suits Absent a Showing the Arbitrators Could Not Grant the Relief Sought

Date: Feb 8, 2026

Arbitral Final Awards Preclude “Protective” Federal Suits Absent a Showing the Arbitrators Could Not Grant the Relief Sought Introduction Shasha v. Malkin (2d Cir. Feb. 6, 2026) is a Second Circuit...