A Prescriptive Right of Way Requires an Identifiable Path and Proven Use

Tara Chand v. Devinder (deceased) through LRs & ors. | Himachal Pradesh High Court | RSA No. 590 of 2008 | 1 September 2026 | 2026:HHC:36910

Introduction

Tara Chand sought a declaration that he could use a path across land held by the defendants and an injunction preventing them from blocking it. He claimed that he and his ancestors had used the path without interruption and that he had acquired a right of way by prescription. The defendants denied that such a path existed; they said the claim arose after land was exchanged in 2004 and construction began on it.

The trial court accepted Tara Chand’s claim. On an appeal by one defendant, the first appellate court set aside the decree. The High Court’s second appeal raised two principal questions: whether the evidence established the claimed right of way, and whether the first appellate court could reverse the decree when the other defendant had not appealed.

Summary of the Judgment

The High Court dismissed the second appeal. It held that the plaintiff had not adequately identified or proved the alleged path. His description of its starting point did not accord with the evidence concerning the nearby motorable road; a plaintiff’s witness acknowledged an existing public path beside his own land; the person relied upon to prove the tatima did not know the position on the ground; and the claimed path was absent from the revenue record despite a recent settlement. These were material shortcomings that the trial court had not properly addressed.

The Court also held that, under Order XLI Rule 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), one defendant could appeal a decree founded on a ground common to both defendants. The first appellate court was therefore entitled to reverse the decree notwithstanding the other defendant’s failure to appeal. Finally, Tara Chand could not obtain relief on the basis that the first appellate court had left an additional-evidence application undecided: the application had been filed by the respondents, and his memorandum of second appeal had not raised the point.

Analysis

Proving the particular right of way claimed

The decisive issue was not simply whether Tara Chand had walked through the area for many years. A prescriptive claim concerns a sufficiently identifiable route used as a right over another’s land for the required period. The trial court had accepted evidence of 20–25 years’ use and a tatima showing a path. The High Court agreed with the first appellate court that this did not resolve the difficulties with the location and proof of the route actually pleaded.

In particular, witnesses placed a motorable road beside the relevant land, while a witness called by the plaintiff acknowledged a separate public path adjoining his own land. The witness who produced the tatima could not verify the position at the site, and the alleged path did not appear in the revenue record although, according to the plaintiff, passages had been recorded during settlement. Taken together, these matters justified the first appellate court’s conclusion that the alleged path had not been established.

The existence of another route does not, by itself, defeat every claim based on prescription: prescription and a right of way arising from necessity are different concepts. Here, evidence about the public path mattered because it cast doubt on the identity and existence of the specific route Tara Chand claimed across the defendants’ land. The first appellate court also noted that the trial court had not specified what portion of the construction was to be demolished.

Precedents cited

  • Savitri Devi v. Gauri Dutt, 2000(1) S.L.J.404: The High Court applied this decision’s insistence on adequate pleadings and identification of a claimed prescriptive passage, including its points of entry and exit, direction and width. It supported the conclusion that an inadequately described path cannot sustain the claimed declaration.
  • Ratan Lal Shah v. Lalmandas Chhadammalal, (1969) 2 SCC 70: This Supreme Court decision explained the purpose of Order XLI Rule 4 CPC: a party may appeal a decree resting on a ground common to parties with the same interest, and the appellate court may grant relief extending to them. The High Court relied on it to reject the argument that both defendants had to appeal.
  • Karan Singh Sobti v. Pratap Chand, (1964) 4 SCR 647: Discussed in the passage quoted from Ratan Lal Shah v. Lalmandas Chhadammalal, this decision illustrates that one party’s decision not to appeal does not extinguish another party’s right to challenge a joint decree.
  • Chandramohan Ramchandra Patil v. Bapu Koyappa Patil, (2003) 3 SCC 552: The Court cited it for reading Order XLI Rule 4 with Rule 33, which permits an appellate court to make an appropriate decree affecting parties who did not themselves appeal where the circumstances justify it. The quoted discussion also referred to Ratan Lal Shah v. Firm Lalmandas Chhadammalal and Mahabir Prasad v. Jage Ram as supporting authorities.
  • Murthy and others Vs. C. Saradambal and ors., (2022) 3 SCC 209; Somakka (deceased) through LRs Vs. K.P. Basavaraj (deceased) through LRS, (2022) 8 SCC 261; V. Prabhakara Vs. Basavaraj K. (deceased) through LRs and anr., (2022) 1 SCC 115; and Santosh Hazari Vs. Purshottam Tiwari (deceased) through LRs, (2001) 3 SCC 179: Tara Chand invoked these decisions concerning a first appellate court’s duties. The High Court found them unhelpful to him because the first appellate court had identified substantive flaws in the trial court’s assessment before reversing it.
  • Rajinder Kaur v. Smt. Yashoda, decided on 19.10.2023: The High Court relied on this decision when refusing to entertain the complaint about the undecided additional-evidence application. No corresponding ground had been taken in Tara Chand’s memorandum of second appeal.
  • Balbir Singh v. Sanjeev Kumar, RSA No. 405 of 2019, decided on 25.8.2023: The appellant relied on this authority regarding the additional-evidence application. The High Court distinguished it because the respondents, not the appellant, had filed that application, and the appellant had not raised its non-disposal in his appeal.

Legal reasoning and scope of the ruling

The judgment brings together three procedural and evidentiary points. First, a court must be able to determine the route over which a prescriptive right is asserted; evidence of long use cannot cure material uncertainty about that route. Second, a first appellate court may reverse a trial decree after identifying errors in the trial court’s treatment of the evidence. Third, where a decree rests on a ground common to multiple defendants, Order XLI Rule 4 can allow one defendant’s successful appeal to benefit the others.

The ruling on additional evidence is narrower. The Court did not hold that failure to decide an Order XLI Rule 27 CPC application can never matter. It held that Tara Chand could not rely on this respondents’ application as a new objection in a second appeal that had neither pleaded the objection nor framed a substantial question of law on it.

Impact

Future claimants seeking a prescriptive right of way will need to describe the claimed route precisely and connect their evidence to that route. A sketch or revenue-related document may be of limited assistance if its relationship to the position on the ground is not established. The decision also confirms that a non-appealing party does not necessarily preserve a joint decree where another party successfully challenges a ground common to them.

Complex Concepts Simplified

  • Easement by prescription: A claimed right to use someone else’s land, such as for passage, based on qualifying long-term use as a right—not merely on permission.
  • Tatima: A sketch or extract used to depict land features or boundaries. Its value in a dispute depends on whether it reliably proves the feature and location in question.
  • Ingress and egress: The points where a claimed passage is entered and exited.
  • Substantial question of law: A legal question that permits consideration in a second appeal; a second appeal is not ordinarily a fresh trial of every factual dispute.
  • Order XLI Rules 4 and 33 CPC: Provisions governing an appellate court’s power to grant appropriate relief where an appeal by one party has consequences for others affected by the decree.

Conclusion

The significant principle of Tara Chand is that a prescriptive right of way must be proved over an identifiable path: a general assertion of longstanding passage is insufficient when the pleaded route and supporting evidence do not align. The judgment also affirms the appellate court’s power to reverse a decree on a common ground at the instance of just one defendant, while underscoring the need to preserve objections properly in a second appeal.