Date of Decision:25.08.2023
Balbir Singh ....Appellant Versus
Sanjeev Kumar & others ...Respondents. Coram
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Rakesh Kainthla, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1 Yes For the appellant : Mr. C.N. Singh, Advocate. For the Respondents: Mr. N.K. Thakur, Senior Advocate, with Mr. Karan
Veer Singh, Advocate.
Rakesh Kainthla, Judge
The present appeal is directed against the judgment & decree dated 18.02.2019, passed by the learned Additional District Judge-II, District Una, H.P. vide which the appeal filed by the appellant (plaintiff before learned trial Court) was dismissed.
1
2
2. It appears from the perusal of the record that an application for leading the additional evidence was filed on 18.01.2018 before the learned First Appellate Court. The application was opposed by filing a reply; however, the application was disposed of on 18.02.2019, after holding that the same had become infructuous due to the pronouncement of judgment.
3. A similar situation arose in Harbans Lal
v. Kundan, 2008 SCC OnLine HP 138 = 2008 (2) Shim. LC. 143, wherein, an application for additional evidence was filed, which was disposed of on the ground that since the main appeal was disposed of, the application was not maintainable. It was held that the application was required to be disposed of before disposing of the appeal. It was observed:
"7. Since the matter was pending before the first Appellate Court on 3.1.2008, the date when the application was moved, it was incumbent upon the Judge to have
3
passed an order on merits rather than dismissing the same on the ground that the application was not maintainable. The fact of the matter is that on 3.1.2008, the matter was still pending and the judgment had not been pronounced by the Court below. Further, the findings are contradictory to the record. The appeal was not adjourned for 7.1.2008 for final arguments as observed by the Court but the same was fixed for pronouncement of judgment. The application had to be considered and disposed of prior to the decision of the appeal.
xxxxx
10. In this view of the matter, the impugned judgment and decree dated 7.1.2008 need to be set aside and is ordered accordingly. The appeal is restored to its original position. The matter is remanded back to the first Appellate Court for consideration of the application and respective contention of the parties. It is clarified that the matter has not been decided on merits of the appeal before the Court below."
4. This judgment was followed by this Court in Sarla Devi versus Leela Devi in RSA no.46 of 2000 decided on 27.08.2009 (neutral citation:
2009:HHC:4100) and it was held:
4
"7. In Harbans Lal and another vs. Kundan Latest HLJ 2008 (HP) 1362, an application for additional evidence was filed on 3.1.2008 but was dismissed on 7.1.2008 on the ground that since the main appeal stood disposed of on 7.1.2008, therefore, no order was required to be passed on the same and the application was not maintainable. On those facts, it has been held that the court has committed serious error by passing erroneous order and therefore, the judgement, decree dated 7.1.2008 were set-aside and the case was remanded to lower appellate court. In the present case also, the main appeal was dismissed and thereafter the amendment application was decided after the decision of the main appeal even though the amendment application was filed much earlier on 21.9.1998 when the appeal was pending before the lower appellate court. On this ground alone, the impugned judgement and decree are not sustainable. The substantial questions of law No. 1 and 2 are decided in favour of the appellant."
5. Similarly, it was held by this Court in
United India Insurance Company Limited versus Charanjit Kaur in FAO(MVA) No.341 of 2019, (decided on 06.05.2022), that where applications under Section 134(c) and 170 of the Motor
5
Vehicles Act were filed before the MACT, but they were disposed of as having been rendered infructuous, the award is bad and liable to quashed on this ground alone.
6. The Hon'ble Supreme Court also held in
Namdeo versus Tukaram Civil Appeal No. 5185 of 2008 decided on 18.08.2008, that where an application under Order 41 Rule 27 of CPC was not properly disposed of, the judgment passed by the First Appellate Court is bad. It was observed:
"We find that the first appellate Court did not reject the application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC, nor did it assign any reasons while recording that only production of the documents was allowed. We are of the view that the procedure adopted was incorrect. The first appellate Court ought to have passed an order in respect of the application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC, either allowing or rejecting the application. The first appellate Court has considered the application as if it was one under Order 13 Rule 1 CPC and not under Order
41 Rule 27 CPC. The High Court ought to have therefore interfered in the matter by raising an appropriate question of
6
law. It failed to do so. The judgments, therefore, call for interference."
7. Similarly, it was held in Jatinder Singh
v. Mehar Singh, (2009) 17 SCC 465= 2008 SCC OnLine SC 1425 that where the High Court had failed to decide the application for leading additional evidence, the matter is required to be remitted to the High Court. It was observed:
"4. While deciding the second appeal, however, the High Court had failed to take notice of the application under Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure and decide whether additional evidence could be permitted to be admitted into evidence. In our view, when an application for acceptance of additional evidence under Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure was filed by the appellants, it was the duty of the High Court to deal with the same on merits. That being the admitted position, we have no other alternative but to set aside the judgment of the High Court and remit the appeal back to it for a decision afresh in the second appeal along with the application for acceptance of additional evidence in accordance with the law."
8. Similar view was taken by this Court in
Mani Devi v. Suresh Chand, 2021 SCC OnLine HP
7
7126= (2021) 2 Latest HLJ 874, wherein it was observed:
"12. A perusal of the "zimni" order dated 31.05.2007 revealed that the plaintiff on the said date had filed an application under Order 41 Rule 27 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure for adducing additional evidence. On 20.06.2007, a reply on behalf of the respondents was filed to the said application and the main appeal was ordered to be listed for arguments along with the application under Order
41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Thereafter, the appeal came to be adjourned on various occasions due to one or other reasons. Finally, the appeal came to be decided on 05.11.2007. The record further reveals that the application under Order 41 Rule 27 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure filed by the plaintiff before the lower Appellate Court remained pending throughout and was not decided either separately or along with the appeal.
13. There is no absolute right granted by the Code of Civil Procedure to adduce additional evidence at the appellate stage. Nonetheless, the Court hearing appeal has the power to allow a party to adduce additional evidence subject, however, to the interdict provided in Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The allowance of the prayer
8
to adduce additional evidence, in the given circumstances of the case, may have the effect of changing the outcome of the case.
14. Undisputedly, the plaintiff had the right to invite a decision, on her prayer to adduce additional evidence, from Lower Appellate Court. The absence of adjudication on application under Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure amounts to the refusal of the exercise of jurisdiction vested in the Lower Appellate Court, which has the potential to cause prejudice to the plaintiff."
9. This position was reiterated in Satish Chand Surana versus Raj Kumar Meshram [(2022) 3 CivCC 191 = (2022) 1 RCR(Civil) 598, wherein it was observed:
"7. Learned counsel for the appellant-plaintiff submits that the High Court has dismissed the first appeal of the plaintiff without deciding the application filed by him under Order XLI Rule 27 of the CPC, seeking permission to adduce the additional evidence. Learned Counsel further submits that the appellant has a good case on merits.
8. It is well-settled that, ordinarily, the Appellate Court should not travel beyond the record of the lower court. Section 107 of
9
the CPC carves out an exception to this general rule, enabling the Appellate Court to take additional evidence subject to the conditions prescribed in Order 41 Rule 27 of the CPC. Thus, grant or refusal of the opportunity for the production of additional evidence at the appellate stage is within the discretion of the appellate court. Dismissal of the main appeal without deciding the application for additional evidence would result in a miscarriage of justice. The First Appellate Court, being the last court of facts and evidence, should permit the production of additional evidence where the explanation furnished by the party is satisfactory and the documents in question are vital to establish the case.
9. It is also necessary to observe here that the application for permission to file additional evidence should contain the list of documents giving full particulars thereof and copies sought to be filed as additional evidence should be served on the other side. However, the High Court cannot completely ignore the application filed by the appellant and pronounce the judgment. If the appellant makes out a case for allowing the application, the material produced along with the application has to be considered at
10
the time of final disposal of the appeal in accordance with law.
10. In the instant appeal, it is clear that the High Court has proceeded to dismiss the appeal without considering the application filed by the appellant-plaintiff. In our view, the High Court has to consider the matter afresh in the light of the observations made above."
10. Therefore, the judgment and decree pronounced by the learned First Appellate Court are bad and are set aside. The matter is remitted to learned First Appellate Court with a direction to consider the application under Order 41 Rule 27 of CPC for leading the additional evidence and thereafter, dispose of the matter as per law. It is expressly made clear that nothing expressed hereinabove is related to the merits of the appeal/application and the learned First Appellate Court shall dispose of the appeal/application without in any manner influenced by whatever has been stated by this Court.
11. The parties are directed to appear before the learned First Appellate Court on 27.09.2023.
11
12. The record be sent forthwith to reach the learned First Appellate Court well before the date fixed.
(Rakesh Kainthla) Judge
25thAugust 2023 (pathania)