All High Courts Case Commentaries

Procedural Safeguards for Insurer’s “Pay and Recover” and Proper Salary Deductions in Section 166 MV Act Claims

Date: Feb 20, 2026

Procedural Safeguards for Insurer’s “Pay and Recover” and Proper Salary Deductions in Section 166 MV Act Claims 1. Introduction This decision of the Calcutta High Court (Biswaroop Chowdhury, J.)...

Minimal Interference under Articles 226/227 in Labour Court Awards Upholding Domestic Enquiries Governed by Private Service Rules

Date: Feb 20, 2026

Minimal Interference under Articles 226/227 in Labour Court Awards Upholding Domestic Enquiries Governed by Private Service Rules Case: Prayagnarayan v. Principal Scindia School Fort Gwalior...

No Vested Right to Exchange Shamilat (Kahcharaie) Land After Substitution of Section 133(2): Pending Requests Cannot Compel Collector Action

Date: Feb 20, 2026

No Vested Right to Exchange Shamilat (Kahcharaie) Land After Substitution of Section 133(2): Pending Requests Cannot Compel Collector Action 1. Introduction This intra-court appeal (LPA No. 21/2023)...

Cancellation of an Advanced Recruitment Process Solely for a Proposed Procedural Shift (Manual-to-Online) Is Arbitrary; Courts May Direct Appointment by Accommodation Against Existing Vacancies

Date: Feb 20, 2026

Cancellation of an Advanced Recruitment Process Solely for a Proposed Procedural Shift (Manual-to-Online) Is Arbitrary; Courts May Direct Appointment by Accommodation Against Existing Vacancies Case:...

Averaging Comparable Sale Deeds (Pre- and Post-Acquisition) to Fix Market Value; Distance from District HQ Immaterial Where Municipal/Commercial Potential Exists

Date: Feb 20, 2026

Averaging Comparable Sale Deeds (Pre- and Post-Acquisition) to Fix Market Value; Distance from District HQ Immaterial Where Municipal/Commercial Potential Exists Case: MUMTAZ AHMED AND ORS. v....

Stamp Duty on Mining Leases: Computation on Average Annual Royalty as on Date of Execution; No Addition of Dead Rent/Upkar; No Term-Multiplication or Penalty for Bona Fide Presentation

Date: Feb 20, 2026

Stamp Duty on Mining Leases: Computation on Average Annual Royalty as on Date of Execution; No Addition of Dead Rent/Upkar; No Term-Multiplication or Penalty for Bona Fide Presentation 1....

Article 226 Cannot Be Used to Expand Executive Welfare Schemes Beyond Their Eligibility Criteria

Date: Feb 20, 2026

Article 226 Cannot Be Used to Expand Executive Welfare Schemes Beyond Their Eligibility Criteria 1. Introduction This intra-court appeal (WA No.3866 of 2025) before the Madras High Court arose from...

Delivery of Postal Articles Addressed to Deceased Addressees: Legal Heirs at the Residence Must Receive Delivery Unless No Proper Recipient Exists

Date: Feb 20, 2026

Delivery of Postal Articles Addressed to Deceased Addressees: Legal Heirs at the Residence Must Receive Delivery Unless No Proper Recipient Exists 1. Introduction In MOHANA RAMASWAMI v. The Secretary...

Contractual Loan-Foreclosure Disputes and RBI Guideline Violations Do Not, Without Mens Rea/Entrustment, Sustain IPC 406/420 Prosecution

Date: Feb 19, 2026

Contractual Loan-Foreclosure Disputes and RBI Guideline Violations Do Not, Without Mens Rea/Entrustment, Sustain IPC 406/420 Prosecution 1. Introduction In M/S. TATA CAPITAL FINANCE LTD. & ORS. v....

Look Out Circular in SFIO Economic-Offence Probes: Sustained Where Overseas Settlement and Non-Responsiveness Show Real Risk of Trial Evasion

Date: Feb 19, 2026

Look Out Circular in SFIO Economic-Offence Probes: Sustained Where Overseas Settlement and Non-Responsiveness Show Real Risk of Trial Evasion Case: Debanjan Hazra v. The Serious Fraud Investigation...

Deemed-Decree Land Acquisition Awards under the WB 1948 Act: Section 38 CPC Inapplicable; Execution Maintainable on High Court Original Side Without Transfer, and Multiple Executions Permitted Until Satisfaction

Date: Feb 19, 2026

Deemed-Decree Land Acquisition Awards under the WB 1948 Act: Section 38 CPC Inapplicable; Execution Maintainable on High Court Original Side Without Transfer, and Multiple Executions Permitted Until...

False “Nil” Statutory Dues and Non-Disclosure of Business Sources in Form 26 Amount to “Undue Influence” (Section 123(2)) Warranting Voidance of Election

Date: Feb 19, 2026

False “Nil” Statutory Dues and Non-Disclosure of Business Sources in Form 26 Amount to “Undue Influence” (Section 123(2)) Warranting Voidance of Election Case: SRI C MUNIRAJU v. SRI S N SUBBAREDDY...

Pension Payable Under Employer Superannuation Trust Is “Wages” and Enforceable via Form-N Even After Resignation

Date: Feb 19, 2026

Pension Payable Under Employer Superannuation Trust Is “Wages” and Enforceable via Form-N Even After Resignation Court: Calcutta High Court (Division Bench) Coram: Lanusungkum Jamir, J. & Rai...

Stipendiary Graduate Trainees as “Apprentices” Under Model Standing Orders Are Excluded from EPF Coverage; Directly Paid Contractual Security/Fire Staff Remain Coverable

Date: Feb 19, 2026

Stipendiary Graduate Trainees as “Apprentices” Under Model Standing Orders Are Excluded from EPF Coverage; Directly Paid Contractual Security/Fire Staff Remain Coverable 1. Introduction This writ...

Orders of NCDRC Between Private Parties: Article 227 Is the Proper Route; Impleading NCDRC Does Not Cure an Article 226 Defect

Date: Feb 19, 2026

Orders of NCDRC Between Private Parties: Article 227 Is the Proper Route; Impleading NCDRC Does Not Cure an Article 226 Defect Case: TRIPTI DAS AND ANR. v. DR. PHANI BHUSAN MANDAL AND ORS. Court:...

IBC Liquidation Overrides Municipal Retrospective Revaluation: Pre-liquidation Property Tax Cannot Be Recovered from IBC Auction Purchasers

Date: Feb 19, 2026

IBC Liquidation Overrides Municipal Retrospective Revaluation: Pre-liquidation Property Tax Cannot Be Recovered from IBC Auction Purchasers 1. Introduction Mamta Binani & Anr. v. Kolkata Municipal...

Unauthorized Possession Alone Is Not “Act Prejudicial to the Interest of the Bank” Under Clause 19.5(j): Reinstatement with Full Back Wages, Subject to Set-off

Date: Feb 19, 2026

Unauthorized Possession Alone Is Not “Act Prejudicial to the Interest of the Bank” Under Clause 19.5(j): Reinstatement with Full Back Wages, Subject to Set-off Case: THE CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING...

Criminal Process Cannot Be Used to Enforce Failed Real‑Estate Development MOUs Absent “Inception Mens Rea” or “Entrustment”: Calcutta High Court Quashes 406/420 IPC Complaint

Date: Feb 19, 2026

Criminal Process Cannot Be Used to Enforce Failed Real‑Estate Development MOUs Absent “Inception Mens Rea” or “Entrustment”: Calcutta High Court Quashes 406/420 IPC Complaint 1. Introduction In...

Conviction Set Aside for Unreliable Related-Witness Testimony, Unnatural Conduct, and FIR/Investigation Infirmities

Date: Feb 19, 2026

Conviction Set Aside for Unreliable Related-Witness Testimony, Unnatural Conduct, and FIR/Investigation Infirmities 1. Introduction Case: Bishnupada Choudhury & Ors. v. The State of West Bengal...

Refusal to Accept a Resignation (Especially of a Statutory Company Secretary) Can Amount to Bonded Labour Under Article 23

Date: Feb 19, 2026

Refusal to Accept a Resignation (Especially of a Statutory Company Secretary) Can Amount to Bonded Labour Under Article 23 Case: GREEVAS JOB PANAKKAL v. TRACO CABLE COMPANY LIMITED Citation: 2026 KER...