All High Courts Case Commentaries

Post-bail detention of a foreign national in an authorized detention centre pending trial is not “illegal detention” for Habeas Corpus; High Court may instead direct time-bound trial

Date: Feb 24, 2026

Post-bail detention of a foreign national in an authorized detention centre pending trial is not “illegal detention” for Habeas Corpus; High Court may instead direct time-bound trial 1. Introduction...

Article 21 Right to Periodic Medical Check-ups in Prison & Mandatory Reasonable Accommodation for Disabled/Amputee Prisoners

Date: Feb 24, 2026

Article 21 Right to Periodic Medical Check-ups in Prison & Mandatory Reasonable Accommodation for Disabled/Amputee Prisoners 1. Introduction The Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court in M.Kalaiselvi...

“Intentional” Inverted-Flag Display Requires Proof of Mens Rea; Non-Speaking (“Rubber-Stamped”) Cognizance Orders Are Vulnerable to Quashing Under Section 528 BNSS

Date: Feb 24, 2026

“Intentional” Inverted-Flag Display Requires Proof of Mens Rea; Non-Speaking (“Rubber-Stamped”) Cognizance Orders Are Vulnerable to Quashing Under Section 528 BNSS Case: V K NARAYANAN v. STATE OF...

Quashing of Forgery/Cheating FIR in Land Agreements Where a Registered Instrument Shows No Apparent Alteration and the Dispute Is Essentially Civil

Date: Feb 24, 2026

Quashing of Forgery/Cheating FIR in Land Agreements Where a Registered Instrument Shows No Apparent Alteration and the Dispute Is Essentially Civil 1. Introduction In PARVEEN NAIN AND OTHERS v. STATE...

Strict Enforcement of Rule 16 (MP Conditions of Practice Rules, 2012): Appearance Bar for Advocates Convicted of Criminal Contempt Unless Contempt is Purged

Date: Feb 24, 2026

Strict Enforcement of Rule 16 (MP Conditions of Practice Rules, 2012): Appearance Bar for Advocates Convicted of Criminal Contempt Unless Contempt is Purged 1) Introduction Case: Munendra Singh v....

Order XI Rule 1(5) CPC (Commercial Suits): No Absolute Bar on Late Document Disclosure—Leave May Be Granted Even at Argument Stage on “Reasonable Cause”

Date: Feb 24, 2026

Order XI Rule 1(5) CPC (Commercial Suits): No Absolute Bar on Late Document Disclosure—Leave May Be Granted Even at Argument Stage on “Reasonable Cause” 1. Introduction The Calcutta High Court...

Demand-and-Acceptance as Twin Essentials for Section 7A PC Act: FIR Quashed Where No Trap, No Recovery, No Proof of Acceptance

Date: Feb 22, 2026

Demand-and-Acceptance as Twin Essentials for Section 7A PC Act: FIR Quashed Where No Trap, No Recovery, No Proof of Acceptance PRABHUGOWDA PATIL, v. STATE OF KARNATAKA, Karnataka High Court (M....

Maintenance-Driven Requests Cannot Access Spouse’s Income-Tax Returns via RTI; Proper Route Is Court Summons with Confidentiality Safeguards

Date: Feb 22, 2026

Maintenance-Driven Requests Cannot Access Spouse’s Income-Tax Returns via RTI; Proper Route Is Court Summons with Confidentiality Safeguards Case: INCOME TAX OFFICER v. SMT GULSANOBER Court:...

Intent as the Threshold for Section 2, Prevention of Insults to National Honour Act: Edited/Digital Depictions Cannot Sustain Prosecution Without Mens Rea

Date: Feb 22, 2026

Intent as the Threshold for Section 2, Prevention of Insults to National Honour Act: Edited/Digital Depictions Cannot Sustain Prosecution Without Mens Rea Case: SRI VENUGOPAL B C v. THE STATE OF...

Status quo ante and non-delegable statutory satisfaction in migrant-property evictions

Date: Feb 21, 2026

Interim Status Quo Ante (Including Restoration of Possession) in Migrant-Property Evictions: Estoppel Not to Defeat Writ Interim Relief, and District Magistrate’s “Persona Designata” Duty of...

Administrative Lethargy Is Not “Sufficient Cause”: Strict Refusal to Condoned Inordinate Government Delay and Mandatory Institutional Scrutiny

Date: Feb 21, 2026

Administrative Lethargy Is Not “Sufficient Cause”: Strict Refusal to Condoned Inordinate Government Delay and Mandatory Institutional Scrutiny 1. Introduction The Madras High Court (Chief Justice...

Tenancy Survives Demolition, but Eviction under MRC Act Still Adjudicable on Bona Fide Need and Non-User

Date: Feb 21, 2026

Tenancy Survives Demolition, but Eviction under the Maharashtra Rent Control Act Can Still Be Granted on Bona Fide Requirement and Non-User 1) Introduction This decision of the Bombay High Court...

Family Pension to Widow: Unregistered Nikahnama/Absence of Nomination Cannot Defeat a Proven (and Admitted) Marriage

Date: Feb 21, 2026

Family Pension to Widow: Unregistered Nikahnama/Absence of Nomination Cannot Defeat a Proven (and Admitted) Marriage Case: FARZANABANU MOHAMMADHANIF SHAIKH WD/O MOHAMMADHANIF ABDULSAMAD SHAIKH v....

Dealership Eligibility: “Pendency” Does Not Disqualify Absent Framing of Charges; Advertisement Prevails Over Application Form

Date: Feb 21, 2026

Dealership Eligibility: “Pendency” Does Not Disqualify Absent Framing of Charges; Advertisement Prevails Over Application Form Case: Binod Kumar Mishra v. The Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. Regd. Office...

Section 482 “Filter Theory” in 498A Prosecutions: Quashing Omnibus Allegations Against In‑Laws While Sending Specific “Overt Act” Allegations Against Husband to Trial

Date: Feb 21, 2026

Section 482 “Filter Theory” in 498A Prosecutions: Quashing Omnibus Allegations Against In‑Laws While Sending Specific “Overt Act” Allegations Against Husband to Trial Case: ASHIS KUMAR DUTTA AND ANR...

Trainees as “Apprentices” under Model Standing Orders: No EPF Coverage When Training Confers No Right to Employment

Date: Feb 21, 2026

Trainees as “Apprentices” under Model Standing Orders: No EPF Coverage When Training Confers No Right to Employment 1. Introduction Case: Regional Provident Fund Commissioner & Anr v. E.P.F. & Ors,...

Omission to Certify Is Not Misappropriation: “Nexus of Designation” Cannot Substitute “Nexus of Deed” for Section 409 IPC

Date: Feb 21, 2026

Omission to Certify Is Not Misappropriation: “Nexus of Designation” Cannot Substitute “Nexus of Deed” for Section 409 IPC 1. Introduction In ARKO DEEP SAHA @ARKADEEP SAHA v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND...

NSA Detention Invalid if Detenu Not Informed of Right to Represent to Detaining Authority; Unexplained Delay in Representation Disposal Vitiates Detention

Date: Feb 21, 2026

NSA Detention Invalid if Detenu Not Informed of Right to Represent to Detaining Authority; Unexplained Delay in Representation Disposal Vitiates Detention Case: VICTOR DAS v. THE UNION OF INDIA AND 4...

Transferred Commercial Suits: Counter-claim After Earlier Written Statement Permissible With Leave Under Order VIII Rule 9 CPC (No De Novo Re-start)

Date: Feb 20, 2026

Transferred Commercial Suits: Counter-claim After Earlier Written Statement Permissible With Leave Under Order VIII Rule 9 CPC (No De Novo Re-start) 1. Introduction In BATLIBOI ENVIRONMENTAL...

State Election Commission as Primary Forum for Complaints on Statutory Oath Deviations by Local Body Elected Representatives

Date: Feb 20, 2026

State Election Commission as Primary Forum for Complaints on Statutory Oath Deviations by Local Body Elected Representatives 1. Introduction Case: Sabu Steephen v. State Election Commission (2026 KER...