All High Courts Case Commentaries

Police-Custody Excesses as “Purported Official Duty”: Prior Sanction under Section 197 CrPC as a Precondition to Cognizance

Date: Apr 9, 2026

Police-Custody Excesses as “Purported Official Duty”: Prior Sanction under Section 197 CrPC as a Precondition to Cognizance Case: RAJESHWAR SINGH v. STATE TH.2ND ADDL.COURT AND ORS. (CRMC No....

RTI Finality Clauses Do Not Bar Article 226 Review of CIC Orders; “No Policy Number” Requests Require Reasonable Identifiers

Date: Apr 9, 2026

RTI Finality Clauses Do Not Bar Article 226 Review of CIC Orders; “No Policy Number” Requests Require Reasonable Identifiers 1. Introduction The Delhi High Court (Division Bench) in AMBIKA GUPTA v....

Registry Cannot Refuse Numbering on “Maintainability”: Mandatory Numbering “Subject to Maintainability” and Listing Before the Roster Judge

Date: Apr 9, 2026

Registry Cannot Refuse Numbering on “Maintainability”: Mandatory Numbering “Subject to Maintainability” and Listing Before the Roster Judge 1. Introduction In M.RAJKUMAR v. THE DIRECTOR (Madras High...

PMLA Bail: Evasive Conduct and Accused-Attributed Delay Defeat Article 21 Plea; Section 45 Rigour Not Diluted by Parity

Date: Apr 9, 2026

PMLA Bail: Evasive Conduct and Accused-Attributed Delay Defeat Article 21 Plea; Section 45 Rigour Not Diluted by Parity Case: Dharam Singh Chhoker v. Directorate of Enforcement (Punjab & Haryana High...

Acquittal Where Injured Witness Is Not a “Sterling Witness”: Conviction Under Sections 307/324/34 IPC Cannot Rest on Inconsistent Ocular Evidence Amid Investigative Lapses

Date: Apr 9, 2026

Acquittal Where Injured Witness Is Not a “Sterling Witness”: Conviction Under Sections 307/324/34 IPC Cannot Rest on Inconsistent Ocular Evidence Amid Investigative Lapses Case: NABA KUMAR KOLEY v....

Limited Writ Review of Industrial Awards: Documentary Proof & Employee Admissions Sustain Dismissal for Misappropriation and “Loss of Confidence”

Date: Apr 9, 2026

Limited Writ Review of Industrial Awards: Documentary Proof & Employee Admissions Sustain Dismissal for Misappropriation and “Loss of Confidence” Case: UMA SHANKAR SHARMA v. STATE (GOVT. OF NCT) &...

Mere delayed reporting to a COVID quarantine centre, without specific disobedience or infection-spreading act, does not attract IPC Ss. 188/269/270—FIR liable to be quashed under Bhajan Lal

Date: Apr 9, 2026

Mere delayed reporting to a COVID quarantine centre, without specific disobedience or infection-spreading act, does not attract IPC Ss. 188/269/270—FIR liable to be quashed under Bhajan Lal 1)...

Deletion of Father’s Name from a Minor’s Passport Where Court-Approved Settlement Grants Sole Custody and Father Renounces All Rights

Date: Apr 8, 2026

Deletion of Father’s Name from a Minor’s Passport Where Court-Approved Settlement Grants Sole Custody and Father Renounces All Rights 1. Introduction The Delhi High Court in Ms. Parul Daware & Anr....

Saved 1991 Police Appeal Rules Cannot Impose Limitation Where Uttarakhand Police Act, 2007 Prescribes None

Date: Apr 8, 2026

Saved 1991 Police Appeal Rules Cannot Impose Limitation Where Uttarakhand Police Act, 2007 Prescribes None Introduction In Pradeep Singh Bhauryal Constable No. 3554 v. Deputy Inspector of P.A.C....

RERA Refund Orders: Finality Bars Belated Writ Challenges; Newtech Does Not Nullify Adjudicating Officer Refunds Where Section 81 Delegation Is Possible

Date: Apr 8, 2026

RERA Refund Orders: Finality Bars Belated Writ Challenges; Newtech Does Not Nullify Adjudicating Officer Refunds Where Section 81 Delegation Is Possible Case: MARVEL LANDMARKS PVT. LTD. v. THE STATE...

FSSAI Cannot Regulate Animal Feed Under the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006; BIS Certification Cannot Be Mandated Without Central Government Order Under the BIS Act, 2016

Date: Apr 8, 2026

FSSAI Cannot Regulate Animal Feed Under the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006; BIS Certification Cannot Be Mandated Without Central Government Order Under the BIS Act, 2016 Case: GODREJ AGROVET LTD...

Conviction Sustainable on Credible Child Eye‑Witness Testimony Despite Delay, Hostile Witnesses, and Minor Section 313 CrPC Irregularities

Date: Apr 8, 2026

Conviction Sustainable on Credible Child Eye‑Witness Testimony Despite Delay, Hostile Witnesses, and Minor Section 313 CrPC Irregularities Case: Tarsem Singh v. State Of U.P. Court: Allahabad High...

Judicial Mandate for Performance Audit of Under-Utilised Statutory Tribunals as a Rule-of-Law Obligation

Date: Apr 8, 2026

Judicial Mandate for Performance Audit of Under-Utilised Statutory Tribunals as a Rule-of-Law Obligation Case: K.B.SOMAN, v. STATE OF KERALA (Kerala High Court) Citation: 2026 KER 31431 | Date:...

Deemed Inclusion in Municipal Electoral Roll When Assembly-Roll Inclusion Is Already Ordered (Despite Pending Publication and Rule 6(4) Freeze)

Date: Apr 8, 2026

Deemed Inclusion in Municipal Electoral Roll When Assembly-Roll Inclusion Is Already Ordered (Despite Pending Publication and Rule 6(4) Freeze) 1. Introduction In JAYESH BATUKBHAI PATEL(VANANI) v....

Fire-Safety Setback/Driveway Norms Override Modified Sanction Plans: Courts May Keep Plans in Abeyance and Order Demolition Where High-Rise Rescue Access Is Compromised

Date: Apr 8, 2026

Fire-Safety Setback/Driveway Norms Override Modified Sanction Plans: Courts May Keep Plans in Abeyance and Order Demolition Where High-Rise Rescue Access Is Compromised 1. Introduction M/S VISHNU SRI...

Continuity and Centrality of the High Power Committee Chair in Time-Bound, Ecologically Compliant Implementation of the Sabarimala Master Plan

Date: Apr 8, 2026

Continuity and Centrality of the High Power Committee Chair in Time-Bound, Ecologically Compliant Implementation of the Sabarimala Master Plan 1. Introduction Case: THE HIGH POWER COMMITTEE FOR THE...

Registrar’s Binding Jurisdiction Under Section 49(2)(l) to Decide Chief Executive/Secretary–Board Removal Disputes (Assam Co-operative Societies Act, 2007)

Date: Apr 8, 2026

Registrar’s Binding Jurisdiction Under Section 49(2)(l) to Decide Chief Executive/Secretary–Board Removal Disputes (Assam Co-operative Societies Act, 2007) 1. Introduction This Division Bench...

Section 107 Cr.PC Confined to Imminent Threat to Public Tranquility: Misuse for Alleged Substantive Offences/Private Fear is Without Jurisdiction and Actionable in Writ

Date: Apr 8, 2026

Section 107 Cr.PC Confined to Imminent Threat to Public Tranquility: Misuse for Alleged Substantive Offences/Private Fear is Without Jurisdiction and Actionable in Writ Case: LALAN PRASAD SINGH v....

Procedural Dismissal of an Election Petition Consequent to Allowing an Interlocutory Application (IA)

Date: Apr 8, 2026

Procedural Dismissal of an Election Petition Consequent to Allowing an Interlocutory Application (IA) 1. Introduction Joshi Villadom v. Suresh Gopi (2026 KER 30677) was decided by the Kerala High...

Implied Statutory Power of ESIC to Enforce Medical Education Service Bonds (and Recover Subsidy in Lieu)

Date: Apr 7, 2026

Implied Statutory Power of ESIC to Enforce Medical Education Service Bonds (and Recover Subsidy in Lieu) 1. Introduction Case: EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE CORPORATION v. SRI ABHISHEK CHOUDHARI Court:...