All High Courts Case Commentaries

Res Judicata Bars Re-litigation of Territorial Jurisdiction in the Same Suit Despite Subsequent Supreme Court Interpretation

Date: Apr 7, 2026

Res Judicata Bars Re-litigation of Territorial Jurisdiction in the Same Suit Despite Subsequent Supreme Court Interpretation 1) Introduction The Bombay High Court (Nagpur Bench) in HDFC Bank Ltd.,...

Revisional Restraint in Section 125 Cr.P.C. Maintenance: Deference to Family Court’s Income Assessment, One‑Third Benchmark, and Remedy via Section 127 on Changed Circumstances

Date: Apr 7, 2026

Revisional Restraint in Section 125 Cr.P.C. Maintenance: Deference to Family Court’s Income Assessment, One‑Third Benchmark, and Remedy via Section 127 on Changed Circumstances 1. Introduction The...

Rental Compensation for Pre-Acquisition Possession: 8% p.a. on Open-Land Value (GR 26-12-2003) Irrespective of Public Purpose, with 6% Interest for Delay

Date: Apr 7, 2026

Rental Compensation for Pre-Acquisition Possession: 8% p.a. on Open-Land Value (GR 26-12-2003) Irrespective of Public Purpose, with 6% Interest for Delay Court: Bombay High Court (Civil Appellate...

Private Scheduled Banks Amenable to Writ Jurisdiction to Enforce RBI “Zero-Liability” Refunds in Unauthorised E‑Banking (SIM‑Swap) Frauds

Date: Apr 7, 2026

Private Scheduled Banks Amenable to Writ Jurisdiction to Enforce RBI “Zero-Liability” Refunds in Unauthorised E‑Banking (SIM‑Swap) Frauds Case: SUBODH C KORDE v. UNION OF INDIA THR MINISTRY OF...

Charge-Sheet Supersedes Section 156(3) Affidavit Lapse; “Public View” Turns on Visibility of the Act, Not Private Title

Date: Apr 7, 2026

Charge-Sheet Supersedes Section 156(3) Affidavit Lapse; “Public View” Turns on Visibility of the Act, Not Private Title Court: Calcutta High Court (Criminal Revisional Jurisdiction, Appellate Side)...

Lokpal’s Section 20(3) Investigation Directions Must Be Reasoned, Material-Based, and Person-Specific

Date: Apr 7, 2026

Lokpal’s Section 20(3) Investigation Directions Must Be Reasoned, Material-Based, and Person-Specific 1. Introduction The Delhi High Court in SHRI SHASHI SHEKHAR PRASAD v. LOKPAL OF INDIA AND ORS...

Irretrievable Breakdown as “Cruelty” Under Section 13(1)(ia) HMA (Post–Rakesh Raman) and the Necessity of a Section 25 HMA Application for Permanent Alimony

Date: Apr 7, 2026

Irretrievable Breakdown as “Cruelty” Under Section 13(1)(ia) HMA (Post–Rakesh Raman) and the Necessity of a Section 25 HMA Application for Permanent Alimony Case: SARANJIT KAUR (HURA) v. INDER SINGH...

Newly Created Higher Judicial Service Posts Cannot Be Filled by Clubbing with an Ongoing Recruitment: “Future Vacancy” Bar and Fresh Quota Calibration Post–All India Judges Association

Date: Apr 7, 2026

Newly Created Higher Judicial Service Posts Cannot Be Filled by Clubbing with an Ongoing Recruitment: “Future Vacancy” Bar and Fresh Quota Calibration Post–All India Judges Association 1....

Constructive Res Judicata in Repetitive Selection Litigation: Finality and Time-Bound Administrative Determination of Marks and Appointment

Date: Apr 7, 2026

Constructive Res Judicata in Repetitive Selection Litigation: Finality and Time-Bound Administrative Determination of Marks and Appointment Case: SRI SAJAL KAMAL DAS v. THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ORS...

Section 12 JJ Act Bail Primacy: CrPC Bail Standards Excluded; Denial Requires Recorded Reasons and Consideration of Child-Specific Reports (Under-16 CCL)

Date: Apr 7, 2026

Section 12 JJ Act Bail Primacy: CrPC Bail Standards Excluded; Denial Requires Recorded Reasons and Consideration of Child-Specific Reports (Under-16 CCL) Case: RIYASAT MUSTAKIM KHAN v. STATE OF...

Section 482 CrPC Must Be Invoked Within a Reasonable Time: “Legal Research” and Bona Fide Belief About No Limitation Do Not Excuse Inordinate Delay

Date: Apr 5, 2026

Section 482 CrPC Must Be Invoked Within a Reasonable Time: “Legal Research” and Bona Fide Belief About No Limitation Do Not Excuse Inordinate Delay 1) Introduction In AJIT KUMAR GOLA v. STATE (GNCTD)...

Tenant’s Continuing Juridical Possession and Liability Despite Estranged Spouse’s Lock: Decree on Admissions Under Order XII Rule 6 CPC

Date: Apr 3, 2026

Tenant’s Continuing Juridical Possession and Liability Despite Estranged Spouse’s Lock: Decree on Admissions Under Order XII Rule 6 CPC Case: RAJAT VERMA v. HP SUMAN Citation: 2026 DHC 2561 Court:...

Disciplinary Authority Cannot Reopen Concluded Misconduct Proceedings Without Statutory Review Power; Repeated Enquiries on Same Allegations Barred

Date: Apr 3, 2026

Disciplinary Authority Cannot Reopen Concluded Misconduct Proceedings Without Statutory Review Power; Repeated Enquiries on Same Allegations Barred Case: ISHFAQ AHMAD WANI v. CHAIRMAN LEGISLATIVE...

Platform-Edge Knockdown (and Fall from Train) Treated as “Untoward Incident”: Contradictory Official Reports Resolved in Favour of Victims under the Railways Act, 1989

Date: Apr 3, 2026

Platform-Edge Knockdown (and Fall from Train) Treated as “Untoward Incident”: Contradictory Official Reports Resolved in Favour of Victims under the Railways Act, 1989 Case: SMT. ASHRAPPA YELLAPPA...

MPT Act Authorities Cannot Direct Change of a Trust’s Name; Emblems Act Remedies Lie with Competent Authorities (Section 70A Time-Limit: Reasonable Period ~ 3 Years)

Date: Apr 3, 2026

MPT Act Authorities Cannot Direct Change of a Trust’s Name; Emblems Act Remedies Lie with Competent Authorities (Section 70A Time-Limit: Reasonable Period ~ 3 Years) Case: NATIONAL EGG CO-ORDINATION...

Election Petition Dismissal for Non-Personal Presentation: Strict Compliance with Section 81(1) RP Act and Filing Before Stamp Reporter

Date: Apr 3, 2026

Election Petition Dismissal for Non-Personal Presentation: Strict Compliance with Section 81(1) RP Act and Filing Before Stamp Reporter Case: TITOSSTAR WELL CHYNE v. GAVIN MIGUEL MYLLIEM AND 5 ORS....

Merit-cum-Seniority Requires a Real Comparative Merit Assessment; Seniority Is Only a Tiebreaker After Such Assessment

Date: Apr 3, 2026

Merit-cum-Seniority Requires a Real Comparative Merit Assessment; Seniority Is Only a Tiebreaker After Such Assessment Case: S. S. TIGGA v. STATE OF CHHATTISGARH Citation: 2026 CGHC 15280-DB Court:...

Drug & Cosmetics Act—Section 34 Nomination as the Primary Anchor of Vicarious Liability; “Bald” Director Averments Insufficient for Prosecution

Date: Apr 3, 2026

Drug & Cosmetics Act—Section 34 Nomination as the Primary Anchor of Vicarious Liability; “Bald” Director Averments Insufficient for Prosecution Case: Amit Kumar Bansal and Ors. v. Sanjeev Kumar Gupta...

Bail in Murder Trials: Prolonged Undertrial Incarceration and Trial Delay as Article 21 Grounds Despite Gravity of Offence

Date: Apr 3, 2026

Bail in Murder Trials: Prolonged Undertrial Incarceration and Trial Delay as Article 21 Grounds Despite Gravity of Offence 1. Introduction The decision in Bhopinder Singh v. UT of J and K through...

Anticipatory Bail under SC/ST Act Bar: Courts May Scrutinize Available Electronic Evidence to Test Prima Facie Caste-Humiliation Allegations

Date: Apr 3, 2026

Anticipatory Bail under SC/ST Act Bar: Courts May Scrutinize Available Electronic Evidence to Test Prima Facie Caste-Humiliation Allegations Case: SANTOSHA DEVI v. UT OF J AND K TH DY SP HEADQUARTER...