All High Courts Case Commentaries

Ultra Vires Sub-Delegation: Registrar-Made 1997 Cooperative Service Rules Cannot Be Enforced to Claim Retiral Benefits

Date: Mar 6, 2026

Ultra Vires Sub-Delegation: Registrar-Made 1997 Cooperative Service Rules Cannot Be Enforced to Claim Retiral Benefits Case: SAMARJIT SINGH v. STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS (with connected CWPs) Court:...

Vague Allegations, Material Omissions and an Unproved Post-Mortem Report: Acquittal Standards for Sections 498A and 306 IPC

Date: Mar 6, 2026

Vague Allegations, Material Omissions and an Unproved Post-Mortem Report: Acquittal Standards for Sections 498A and 306 IPC Case: PURNA CHANDRA RAUL v. THE STATE OF W.B Court: Calcutta High Court...

Limitation for Section 18 Reference Cannot Be Defeated by State’s Failure to Notify Award and Tender Compensation

Date: Mar 5, 2026

Limitation for Section 18 Reference Cannot Be Defeated by State’s Failure to Notify Award and Tender Compensation Case: GHULAM MOHAMMAD RAH AND ORS. v. UNION TERRITORY OF J AND K AND ORS. (REVENUE...

Digital Gold Schemes Can Trigger the BUDS Act: “Deposit” Examined by Economic Substance; FIR Quashment Under Section 528 BNSS Remains Exceptional

Date: Mar 5, 2026

Digital Gold Schemes Can Trigger the BUDS Act: “Deposit” Examined by Economic Substance; FIR Quashment Under Section 528 BNSS Remains Exceptional Case: NISHCHAY BABU ARKALGUD v. STATE OF KARNATAKA...

Section 106 Evidence Act Cannot Substitute Proof of “Last Seen Together” in Spousal Homicides

Date: Mar 5, 2026

Section 106 Evidence Act Cannot Substitute Proof of “Last Seen Together” in Spousal Homicides 1) Introduction Selvi v. The Inspector of Police (2026 MHC 961) is a decision of the Madurai Bench of the...

Registrar’s Supervisory Power Under Section 68(2) Does Not Include Cancellation of Registered Sale Deeds; Civil Court is the Proper Forum for Alleged Fraud

Date: Mar 5, 2026

Registrar’s Supervisory Power Under Section 68(2) Does Not Include Cancellation of Registered Sale Deeds; Civil Court is the Proper Forum for Alleged Fraud 1. Introduction Case: Gurumurthi v. THE...

Competency of Intellectually Disabled Sexual Assault Victims: Voir Dire as the Touchstone; Investigative Omission Not Fatal (S.118 Evidence Act / S.124 BSA)

Date: Mar 4, 2026

Competency of Intellectually Disabled Sexual Assault Victims: Voir Dire as the Touchstone; Investigative Omission Not Fatal (S.118 Evidence Act / S.124 BSA) Introduction Case: Appukuttan v. State of...

Section 494 IPC: Only the “Erring Spouse” Can Be Prosecuted; Mere “Illegal Relationship/Live-in” Allegations Do Not Make Out Bigamy

Date: Mar 4, 2026

Section 494 IPC: Only the “Erring Spouse” Can Be Prosecuted; Mere “Illegal Relationship/Live-in” Allegations Do Not Make Out Bigamy 1) Introduction This decision of the Karnataka High Court (R....

Standard Rent Applications as “Pleadings” Amenable to Order VII Rule 11 CPC; Post‑2001 Construction Exemption Bars Section 11(3) Remedies (Gujarat)

Date: Mar 4, 2026

Standard Rent Applications as “Pleadings” Amenable to Order VII Rule 11 CPC; Post‑2001 Construction Exemption Bars Section 11(3) Remedies (Gujarat) 1. Introduction The Gujarat High Court (J.C. Doshi,...

Advocate’s Privilege in Defamation Complaints: No Criminal Prosecution for Client-Instructed Statements Absent Specific Overt Acts

Date: Mar 3, 2026

Advocate’s Privilege in Defamation Complaints: No Criminal Prosecution for Client-Instructed Statements Absent Specific Overt Acts Case: J.N.Naresh Kumar v. Jayakaran Vasudevan Court: Madras High...

Compassionate Appointees Must Be Considered for Eligible Higher Posts Under G.O.Ms.No.612; Promotion Circulars Cannot Defeat the Scheme

Date: Mar 3, 2026

Compassionate Appointees Must Be Considered for Eligible Higher Posts Under G.O.Ms.No.612; Promotion Circulars Cannot Defeat the Scheme 1. Introduction This judgment of the Andhra Pradesh High Court...

Quashing Post-Charge-Sheet Proceedings Where Materials Create Only “Suspicion” (Not “Grave/Strong Suspicion”): Reaffirming the Criminal Court’s Filtering Role

Date: Mar 3, 2026

Quashing Post-Charge-Sheet Proceedings Where Materials Create Only “Suspicion” (Not “Grave/Strong Suspicion”): Reaffirming the Criminal Court’s Filtering Role 1) Introduction Case: SWAPAN KUMAR GHOSH...

Ministers Cannot Publicly Purport to Nullify Sub Judice Court Orders; Impleadment in Contempt Not Founded on Unverified Media Reports

Date: Mar 3, 2026

Ministers Cannot Publicly Purport to Nullify Sub Judice Court Orders; Impleadment in Contempt Not Founded on Unverified Media Reports 1. Introduction Case: S.Paramasivam v. K.J.Praveen Kumar Court:...

Reclassifying Section 326 to Section 325 IPC: Bamboo Stick/Rod Causing Fracture Not Per Se a “Weapon Likely to Cause Death”

Date: Mar 3, 2026

Reclassifying Section 326 to Section 325 IPC: Bamboo Stick/Rod Causing Fracture Not Per Se a “Weapon Likely to Cause Death” 1. Introduction In GOUTAM SAHA & ORS v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ANR...

Removal-of-Difficulties Orders Cannot Bypass the Act’s Fee-Fixation Scheme: Interim Abeyance of Delhi’s 2026 School Fee Timelines

Date: Mar 1, 2026

Removal-of-Difficulties Orders Cannot Bypass the Act’s Fee-Fixation Scheme: Interim Abeyance of Delhi’s 2026 School Fee Timelines 1) Introduction This Delhi High Court decision (Devendra Kumar...

Expert Report Not Cited as Witness Is Not Fatal at Discharge Stage; Forgery Allegations Based on Post-Signature Alteration Must Go to Trial

Date: Feb 28, 2026

Expert Report Not Cited as Witness Is Not Fatal at Discharge Stage; Forgery Allegations Based on Post-Signature Alteration Must Go to Trial Court: Calcutta High Court (Criminal Revisional...

Interim Maintenance under Section 125 Cr.P.C. Ordinarily Payable from Date of Application; Any Deviation Requires Cogent Reasons

Date: Feb 28, 2026

Interim Maintenance under Section 125 Cr.P.C. Ordinarily Payable from Date of Application; Any Deviation Requires Cogent Reasons Case: SANYOGITA GUPTA & ORS. v. ASHOK KUMAR GUPTA Citation: 2026 DHC...

Judicial Restraint in Election-Tech Tenders: Upholding Counting-Centre CCTV Experience as a Rational Eligibility شرط

Date: Feb 28, 2026

Judicial Restraint in Election-Tech Tenders: Upholding Counting-Centre CCTV Experience as a Rational Eligibility Requirement 1. Introduction This decision of the Calcutta High Court (Krishna Rao, J.)...

Bail where Vendor-Dues Dispute is Predominantly Civil: Cheating/Criminal Breach of Trust Require Mens Rea at Inception and Clear Entrustment (Gauhati High Court)

Date: Feb 28, 2026

Bail where Vendor-Dues Dispute is Predominantly Civil: Cheating/Criminal Breach of Trust Require Mens Rea at Inception and Clear Entrustment 1) Introduction In MUKESH JALAN v. THE STATE OF ASSAM...

Delay in FIR Not Fatal in Intra-Family Homicide Where Priority Was Medical Treatment; Close-Relative Eyewitness Testimony Sustained

Date: Feb 28, 2026

Delay in FIR Not Fatal in Intra-Family Homicide Where Priority Was Medical Treatment; Close-Relative Eyewitness Testimony Sustained 1. Introduction In MANJAPPA v. STATE OF KARNATAKA (Karnataka High...