All High Courts Case Commentaries

Ballot-Tampering During Bar Council Counting: No Automatic Re-Poll; “Doubtful Ballots” to be Segregated and Decided by ASG with Enhanced Transparency Safeguards

Date: Jun 9, 2026

Ballot-Tampering During Bar Council Counting: No Automatic Re-Poll; “Doubtful Ballots” to be Segregated and Decided by ASG with Enhanced Transparency Safeguards 1. Introduction This batch decision of...

Interim Orders Are Executable Under Section 36 CPC (Order XXXIX Rule 2-A Not Exclusive) and Mandatory Verification of AI/Digital Citations in Judicial Orders

Date: Jun 9, 2026

Interim Orders Are Executable Under Section 36 CPC (Order XXXIX Rule 2-A Not Exclusive) and Mandatory Verification of AI/Digital Citations in Judicial Orders 1. Introduction In PRINCIPAL WOODLAND...

Article 21 Public Law Compensation for Death in State Mental Hospital: Adoption of Motor Accident Multiplier Method and Need-Based Top-Up

Date: Jun 9, 2026

Article 21 Public Law Compensation for Death in State Mental Hospital: Adoption of Motor Accident Multiplier Method and Need-Based Top-Up Case: SMT. NOORJAN SAMSHUDDIN BHANVADIYA AND ORS. v. THE...

Defective Rule 94A Affidavit in Panchayat Election Petitions is Curable; Order 7 Rule 11 Rejection Not Warranted on Technical Non-Compliance

Date: Jun 9, 2026

Defective Rule 94A Affidavit in Panchayat Election Petitions is Curable; Order 7 Rule 11 Rejection Not Warranted on Technical Non-Compliance 1. Introduction In SANTOSH KUMARI v. RISHU SAINICitation...

Religious References, Dua/Amen, and “Dead Voters” Allegations: Strict Pleading Threshold for Corrupt Practice and Void-Vote Grounds in Election Petitions

Date: Jun 9, 2026

Religious References, Dua/Amen, and “Dead Voters” Allegations: Strict Pleading Threshold for Corrupt Practice and Void-Vote Grounds in Election Petitions 1) Introduction The decision in MUFTI...

Judicial Restraint in Academic Admission Policy: Kerala HC Upholds Board-wise Normalisation (Highest-Mark-as-100) and Dismisses Challenge to Prospectus 2026

Date: Jun 9, 2026

Judicial Restraint in Academic Admission Policy: Kerala HC Upholds Board-wise Normalisation (Highest-Mark-as-100) and Dismisses Challenge to Prospectus 2026 1. Introduction The decision in JOMON...

Tenure “D” (Rule 43) Lands Are Class-I and Freely Transferable: No 75% Transfer Premium; Only NA Change-of-User Charge Sustainably Recoverable

Date: Jun 9, 2026

Tenure “D” (Rule 43) Lands Are Class-I and Freely Transferable: No 75% Transfer Premium; Only NA Change-of-User Charge Sustainably Recoverable 1) Introduction The Bombay High Court (Milind N. Jadhav,...

Quashing Election-Duty FIRs for Want of Foundational Ingredients: Proof of Force, Obscenity, Intimidation, and the 100‑Metre Zone

Date: Jun 8, 2026

Quashing Election-Duty FIRs for Want of Foundational Ingredients: Proof of Force, Obscenity, Intimidation, and the 100‑Metre Zone Case: Pitchai v. State Of Tamilnadu Rep By In (Madras High Court,...

Suppression of Failed Bail-Cancellation Efforts Vitiates “Subjective Satisfaction” under the PIT NDPS Act

Date: Jun 8, 2026

Suppression of Failed Bail-Cancellation Efforts Vitiates “Subjective Satisfaction” under the PIT NDPS Act Case: MAKHAN DIN v. PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT HOME DEPARTMENT, JAMMU AND OTHERS...

Compensation Claims for Public Works Require Proof of Proprietary Encroachment; Individuals Cannot Claim Compensation for Kahcharai Land

Date: Jun 8, 2026

Compensation Claims for Public Works Require Proof of Proprietary Encroachment; Individuals Cannot Claim Compensation for Kahcharai Land Case: MOHAMMAD SULTAN DAR AND OTHERS v. UNION TERRITORY OF J...

Manual Verification in AIBE Where OMR Set-Code Bubbling Error Causes Wrongful Failure (Non-Precedential, Case-Specific Relief)

Date: Jun 8, 2026

Manual Verification in AIBE Where OMR Set-Code Bubbling Error Causes Wrongful Failure (Non-Precedential, Case-Specific Relief) 1. Introduction Case: Love Yadav v. Bar Council Of India Thru. Chairman...

Article 226 Power to Add Father’s Name and Correct Child’s Name in Birth Register to Protect a Child’s Article 21 Identity

Date: Jun 8, 2026

Article 226 Power to Add Father’s Name and Correct Child’s Name in Birth Register to Protect a Child’s Article 21 Identity 1. Introduction Case: ANJU KRISHNA v. STATE OF KERALA (2026 KER 37687),...

Relegation to PMLA Appellate Tribunal for ED Search Challenges Once Attachment Proceedings Mature

Date: Jun 8, 2026

Relegation to PMLA Appellate Tribunal for ED Search Challenges Once Attachment Proceedings Mature Case: AKASH BASKARAN v. The Joint Director (Madras High Court) Date: 02-06-2026 | Coram: Sushrut...

Postal Ballot Attestation by Middle School Headmasters Treated as Gazetted-Officer Attestation; Recount-Based Declaration of the True Winner Despite Expired Term

Date: Jun 8, 2026

Postal Ballot Attestation by Middle School Headmasters Treated as Gazetted-Officer Attestation; Recount-Based Declaration of the True Winner Despite Expired Term Case: M.APPAVU v. I.S.INBADURAI...

Employees as “Aggrieved Persons” to Seek Mandamus for Vigilance Enquiry into Institutional Fraud

Date: Jun 8, 2026

Employees as “Aggrieved Persons” to Seek Mandamus for Vigilance Enquiry into Institutional Fraud Case: Murugesan.S v. The Additional Chief Secreta (2026 MHC 1860) — Madras High Court (Madurai Bench)...

Right to Travel Abroad vs. Ensuring Presence at Trial: Successive Foreign-Travel Requests Rejected for Absconding Conduct

Date: Jun 8, 2026

Right to Travel Abroad vs. Ensuring Presence at Trial: Successive Foreign-Travel Requests Rejected for Absconding Conduct Case: D.Sathishkumar v. State Rep. by The Inspector of Police Citation: 2026...

PEG Godown Contracts: Estoppel by Undertaking and Validity of Cost-Saving Recoveries for Delayed Black-Topping

Date: Jun 7, 2026

PEG Godown Contracts: Estoppel by Undertaking and Validity of Cost-Saving Recoveries for Delayed Black-Topping Case: M/S ALPINE AGRO SERVICES v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS. (CONSUMER AFFAIRS AND PUBLIC...

Contractual ECHS Termination for Unsatisfactory Performance Is Not “Punitive” or “Stigmatic” So as to Require a Formal Enquiry (Article 311 Inapplicable)

Date: Jun 7, 2026

Contractual ECHS Termination for Unsatisfactory Performance Is Not “Punitive” or “Stigmatic” So as to Require a Formal Enquiry (Article 311 Inapplicable) Case: Manzoor Ahmad Bhat v. UNION OF INDIA...

Affiliation Binds: Board’s Power to “Prescribe Textbooks” Includes Mandating Exclusive Use of Board-Published Textbooks in Affiliated Schools

Date: Jun 7, 2026

Affiliation Binds: Board’s Power to “Prescribe Textbooks” Includes Mandating Exclusive Use of Board-Published Textbooks in Affiliated Schools 1. Introduction This Letters Patent Appeal (LPA No. 241...

Section 143A NI Act: Interim Compensation Must Follow Reasoned, Case-Specific Discretion

Date: Jun 7, 2026

Section 143A NI Act: Interim Compensation Must Follow Reasoned, Case-Specific Discretion (and Will Not Be Quashed if Reasons Are Discernible) 1. Introduction In MOHAMMAD ASHRAF MIR v. WAZIRA RESHI...