All High Courts Case Commentaries

Direct Judicial Grant of Remission (Without Remand) Where Record Shows Reformation: Reformative Primacy Even in TADA Life Convictions

Date: Jun 6, 2026

Direct Judicial Grant of Remission (Without Remand) Where Record Shows Reformation: Reformative Primacy Even in TADA Life Convictions 1) Introduction Case: MD. RASHID KHAN v. Union of INDIA & ANR....

Second Appeal Gatekeeping under Section 100 CPC: Unregistered “Tahrirnama” Cannot Prove Transfer/Possession in Kashmir, Nor Dislodge Presumption of Revenue Entries

Date: Jun 6, 2026

Second Appeal Gatekeeping under Section 100 CPC: Unregistered “Tahrirnama” Cannot Prove Transfer/Possession in Kashmir, Nor Dislodge Presumption of Revenue Entries Case: ABDUL AZIZ MIR v. TARIQ AHMAD...

No Compassionate Regularisation or Redeployment for Post-Retirement Death; Consolidated JKCL Workers Limited to Unpaid Wages (with Interest)

Date: Jun 6, 2026

No Compassionate Regularisation or Redeployment for Post-Retirement Death; Consolidated JKCL Workers Limited to Unpaid Wages (with Interest) Case: SHAHID MEHRAJ v. UNION TERRITORY OF J AND K AND ANR....

Permissive Occupation Through Husband Does Not Create “Shared Household” Rights Against Sister-in-Law Owner; DV Act Section 26 May Be Considered in Civil Suits, But Relief Lies Against Husband

Date: Jun 6, 2026

Permissive Occupation Through Husband Does Not Create “Shared Household” Rights Against Sister-in-Law Owner; DV Act Section 26 May Be Considered in Civil Suits, But Relief Lies Against Husband 1....

Terminal Benefits Cannot Be Withheld on a Mere Pending Investigation: Article 168-A J&K CSR Requires Determination of Loss in Judicial/Departmental Proceedings

Date: Jun 6, 2026

Terminal Benefits Cannot Be Withheld on a Mere Pending Investigation: Article 168-A J&K CSR Requires Determination of Loss in Judicial/Departmental Proceedings 1. Introduction In VIKAR MUSTAFA...

Cadre Restructuring Appointment Is Not “Promotion” for MACP When the Original Post Is Abolished and Pay-Scales Are Merged

Date: Jun 6, 2026

Cadre Restructuring Appointment Is Not “Promotion” for MACP When the Original Post Is Abolished and Pay-Scales Are Merged 1. Introduction In THE UNION OF INDIA AND 2 ORS. v. SMTI VEENA DHOUNDIYAL...

Editorial-Control Broadcaster Liability for Televised Defamation: Due Diligence, Evidentiary Sufficiency, and the Inefficacy of Off-Platform Apologies

Date: Jun 6, 2026

Editorial-Control Broadcaster Liability for Televised Defamation: Due Diligence, Evidentiary Sufficiency, and the Inefficacy of Off-Platform Apologies 1. Introduction In SUN TV NETWORK LIMITED v. MS....

Disclosure Statements Cannot Substitute Proof: Section 27 Evidence Act Limited to Discovery; Circumstantial Chain Must Be Complete

Date: Jun 5, 2026

Disclosure Statements Cannot Substitute Proof: Section 27 Evidence Act Limited to Discovery; Circumstantial Chain Must Be Complete Case: ALI MOHAMMAD DAR v. UNION TERRITORY THORUGH POLICE STATION...

Section 528 BNSS Quashment: Vague Final Reports Cannot Sustain IPC 294(b), 341, 353, 506(ii)

Date: Jun 5, 2026

Section 528 BNSS Quashment at Final-Report Stage: Vague Allegations Cannot Sustain Prosecution under IPC Sections 294(b), 341, 353 and 506(ii) 1. Introduction In Thomas @ Dhamas v. The State of...

Down Syndrome as “Mental Retardation/Intellectual Disability” Under the National Trust Act: Guardianship Applications Must Follow Statutory Procedure

Date: Jun 5, 2026

Down Syndrome as “Mental Retardation/Intellectual Disability” Under the National Trust Act: Guardianship Applications Must Follow Statutory Procedure 1. Introduction Case: V K SATHEESH KUMAR v. THE...

Order XLI Rule 33 CPC: High Court’s Power to Enhance Motor Accident Compensation Without Cross-Objection in Catastrophic Injury Cases

Date: Jun 5, 2026

Order XLI Rule 33 CPC: High Court’s Power to Enhance Motor Accident Compensation Without Cross-Objection in Catastrophic Injury Cases 1. Introduction Case: THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER, v. KATHIRESAN (with...

Delay in FIR Caused by Police Inaction Is Not a Ground for Anticipatory Bail in Dowry-Death Allegations; Early Grief-Stage Statements Need Not Be Exhaustively Detailed

Date: Jun 4, 2026

Delay in FIR Caused by Police Inaction Is Not a Ground for Anticipatory Bail in Dowry-Death Allegations; Early Grief-Stage Statements Need Not Be Exhaustively Detailed 1. Introduction The Delhi High...

Dispensing with Departmental Enquiry on “Security of the State” Grounds: Reasons Need Not Appear in the Dismissal Order if Contemporaneous Record Supports the Governor’s Satisfaction

Date: Jun 4, 2026

Dispensing with Departmental Enquiry on “Security of the State” Grounds: Reasons Need Not Appear in the Dismissal Order if Contemporaneous Record Supports the Governor’s Satisfaction 1) Introduction...

Waiver of the One-Year Bar under Section 29 SMA for Mutual-Consent Divorce in “Notional” Marriages Causing Exceptional Hardship

Date: Jun 4, 2026

Waiver of the One-Year Bar under Section 29 SMA for Mutual-Consent Divorce in “Notional” Marriages Causing Exceptional Hardship 1. Introduction In SHAHBAZ KHAN v. KOMAL SHRESTH (Delhi High Court,...

Parity and Prolonged Incarceration as Decisive Factors for Bail under UAPA Section 43D(5) in NIA Cases

Date: Jun 4, 2026

Parity and Prolonged Incarceration as Decisive Factors for Bail under UAPA Section 43D(5) in NIA Cases 1. Introduction The decision in MR FAIROZ PASHA v. NATIONAL INVESTIGATION AGENCY (Karnataka High...

Material Improvements in Protest-Complaint Proceedings and the Magistrate’s Heightened Duty Before Summoning for Murder

Date: Jun 4, 2026

Material Improvements in Protest-Complaint Proceedings and the Magistrate’s Heightened Duty Before Summoning for Murder Case: Lala And Another v. State of U.P. and Another (Allahabad High Court)...

Vacillating Pleadings and Inordinate Delay Defeat Writ Claims for University Medals

Date: Jun 4, 2026

Vacillating Pleadings and Inordinate Delay Defeat Writ Claims for University Medals Case: IBRAR BASHIR SHIRAZI v. UNIVERSITY OF KASHMIR Court: High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh, Srinagar...

Release of Licensed Firearms as Muddamal Pending Trial: Expeditious Interim Custody Under Section 497 BNSS with Evidentiary Safeguards

Date: Jun 4, 2026

Release of Licensed Firearms as Muddamal Pending Trial: Expeditious Interim Custody Under Section 497 BNSS with Evidentiary Safeguards Case: JAIPAL SINGH v. STATE OF RAJASTHAN | Citation: 2026 RJ-JD...

Long Separation, Defamatory Complaints to Employer, and Removal of Thali as “Mental Cruelty” under Section 13(1)(ia) HMA

Date: Jun 3, 2026

Long Separation, Defamatory Complaints to Employer, and Removal of Thali as “Mental Cruelty” under Section 13(1)(ia) HMA 1) Introduction Case: VALLIAMMAL v. A. CHELLADURAI (2026 MHC 1807), Madras...

Forum Non Conveniens in Criminal PIL: High Court Declines Jurisdiction Absent Territorial Nexus

Date: Jun 3, 2026

Forum Non Conveniens in Criminal PIL: High Court Declines Jurisdiction Absent Territorial Nexus 1. Introduction In S.Vignesh Shishir v. Union Of India Thru. Secy. Ministry Of Home Affairs New Delhi...