state Case Commentaries

Community-Wide Landfill Impacts Do Not Warrant Premature Dismissal of Private Nuisance Claims

Date: Oct 31, 2026

Community-Wide Landfill Impacts Do Not Warrant Premature Dismissal of Private Nuisance Claims Constitutional limits on environmental enforcement claims and the continuing role of private nuisance...

Foreclosure Finality: Unsupported Law-Office Failure Cannot Reopen Liability or Defeat a Supported Referee’s Report

Date: Oct 31, 2026

Foreclosure Finality: Unsupported Law-Office Failure Cannot Reopen Liability or Defeat a Supported Referee’s Report Case: Wilmington Sav. Fund Socy., FSB v Laurino, 2026 NY Slip Op 06371 Court:...

Pre-Suit Payment Bars Stand-Alone WPCL Liquidated-Damages Claims: Justice Wecht’s Dissent

Date: Oct 31, 2026

Pre-Suit Payment Bars Stand-Alone WPCL Liquidated-Damages Claims: Justice Wecht’s Dissent Case: Aita, M. v. NCB Mgmt. Ser., Aplt. Court: Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Docket: No. 25 MAP 2025 Decision...

Act 111 Arbitration Review: Retaining Narrow Certiorari and Proposing a Limited Public Policy Exception

Date: Oct 31, 2026

Act 111 Arbitration Review: Retaining Narrow Certiorari and Proposing a Limited Public Policy Exception Case: City of Phila., Aplt. v. FOP, Lodge No. 5 Court: Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Date:...

Municipal-Authority Service-Area Disputes as Questions of Service: Exclusive Common-Pleas Jurisdiction and the Brobson Dissent

Date: Oct 31, 2026

Municipal-Authority Service-Area Disputes as Questions of Service: Exclusive Common-Pleas Jurisdiction and the Brobson Dissent Case: Conyngham Township v. PUC, Aplt. Court: Supreme Court of...

Increased-Risk Causation: An Oncologist’s Failure to Question a Conflicting Diagnosis May Require Jury Review

Date: Oct 31, 2026

Increased-Risk Causation: An Oncologist’s Failure to Question a Conflicting Diagnosis May Require Jury Review Case: Estate of Smith v. Kannarkatt, A., M.D., Aplts. Court: Supreme Court of...

A Timely MDJ Complaint Tolls Limitations for Factually Related Claims Throughout Appeal

Date: Oct 31, 2026

A Timely MDJ Complaint Tolls Limitations for Factually Related Claims Throughout Appeal Case: Whittington v. Daniels, No. 47 MAP 2025 Court: Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Decided: October 29, 2026...

Post-Emergency Written Eyewitness Accounts: Confrontation Protection and Harmless-Error Review

Date: Oct 31, 2026

Post-Emergency Written Eyewitness Accounts: Confrontation Protection and Harmless-Error Review Case: Cooper Wesley v. State of Arkansas, 2026 Ark. 159 Court: Supreme Court of Arkansas Opinion...

Ministerial Ballot Duties Do Not Override Ohio’s Constitutional Timing Requirements for Charter Amendments

Date: Oct 31, 2026

Ministerial Ballot Duties Do Not Override Ohio’s Constitutional Timing Requirements for Charter Amendments Case: State ex rel. Avon Lake Commt. for the Citizens & Electors Right to Vote on City...

Non-Truth Use of Testimonial Protective-Order Allegations: No Plain Confrontation Error

Date: Oct 31, 2026

Non-Truth Use of Testimonial Protective-Order Allegations: No Plain Confrontation Error Case: MARDELL v. State, No. S26A0674 Court: Supreme Court of Georgia Decided: October 27, 2026 Opinion: Justice...

RUCKER v. State: Post-Trial Leniency Does Not Alone Establish a Pretrial Witness Agreement

Date: Oct 31, 2026

RUCKER v. State: Post-Trial Leniency Does Not Alone Establish a Pretrial Witness Agreement Court: Supreme Court of Georgia Case: No. S26A0894 Decided: October 27, 2026 Opinion: Justice Colvin; all...

Inaccurate Appointed-Counsel Fee Certifications: Strong Mitigation Can Justify a Fully Stayed Suspension

Date: Oct 31, 2026

Inaccurate Appointed-Counsel Fee Certifications: Strong Mitigation Can Justify a Fully Stayed Suspension Case: Disciplinary Counsel v. Robertson, Slip Opinion No. 2026-Ohio-4231 Court: Supreme Court...

Trial Courts, Not Prosecutors, Select Among Alternative Firearm Specifications for a Single Felony

Date: Oct 31, 2026

Trial Courts, Not Prosecutors, Select Among Alternative Firearm Specifications for a Single Felony Case: State v. Holliman, Slip Opinion No. 2026-Ohio-4232 Court: Supreme Court of Ohio Decided:...

CPL 30.30(6) Preserves Review After a Guilty Plea but Does Not Override an Appeal Waiver

Date: Oct 31, 2026

CPL 30.30(6) Preserves Review After a Guilty Plea but Does Not Override an Appeal Waiver People v Ekukpe, 2026 NY Slip Op 06378 New York Court of Appeals | October 29, 2026 This commentary addresses...

CPL 30.30(6) Applies to Pending Appeals Despite Pre-2020 Guilty Pleas

Date: Oct 31, 2026

CPL 30.30(6) Applies to Pending Appeals Despite Pre-2020 Guilty Pleas Case: People v Nantan, 2026 NY Slip Op 06379 Court: New York Court of Appeals Decided: October 29, 2026 Opinion: Judge Rivera;...

Anderson v. State: Reasonable Reliance on Existing Collision Evidence Can Defeat an Expert-Witness Ineffectiveness Claim

Date: Oct 31, 2026

Anderson v. State: Reasonable Reliance on Existing Collision Evidence Can Defeat an Expert-Witness Ineffectiveness Claim Supreme Court of Georgia · No. S26A1774 · October 27, 2026 Opinion by Justice...

Georgia County Parties Cannot Require Independent Approval for Primary-Ballot Access

Date: Oct 31, 2026

Georgia County Parties Cannot Require Independent Approval for Primary-Ballot Access CATOOSA COUNTY REPUBLICAN PARTY v. HENRY (two cases) Supreme Court of Georgia · October 27, 2026 Case Nos....

Inconsistent Jail Calls May Impeach Self-Defense; Evidence-Based Argument Does Not Require a Mistrial

Date: Oct 31, 2026

Inconsistent Jail Calls May Impeach Self-Defense; Evidence-Based Argument Does Not Require a Mistrial Case: COLLIER v. State Court: Supreme Court of Georgia Decision date: October 27, 2026 Opinion:...

No Automatic Admission of a Victim’s Criminal History in a Self-Defense Case: HOWARD v. State

Date: Oct 31, 2026

No Automatic Admission of a Victim’s Criminal History in a Self-Defense Case: HOWARD v. State Court: Supreme Court of Georgia Case: HOWARD v. State, No. S26A1087 Decision date: October 27, 2026...

Later-Acquired Familiarity Can Support Lay Photographic Identification Under Georgia Rule 701

Date: Oct 31, 2026

Later-Acquired Familiarity Can Support Lay Photographic Identification Under Georgia Rule 701 Case: MORELAND v. State, No. S26A1135 Court: Supreme Court of Georgia Decided: October 27, 2026 Opinion:...