Vermont Case Commentaries

Vermont Supreme Court Upholds Waiver of Predicate Convictions in Habitual Offender Sentencing

Date: Dec 9, 2024

Vermont Supreme Court Upholds Waiver of Predicate Convictions in Habitual Offender Sentencing Introduction The case of In re Thomas Velde, Jr. (State of Vermont, Appellant) resolved by the Vermont...

Supreme Court of Vermont Upholds Religious Property Protections Under 24 V.S.A. § 4413(a)(1)(C)

Date: Dec 9, 2024

Supreme Court of Vermont Upholds Religious Property Protections Under 24 V.S.A. § 4413(a)(1)(C) Introduction The case of In re Cathedral of the Immaculate Parish Charitable Trust Appeal (2024 Vt. 77)...

Reformed Deeds Relate Back: Slander of Title Protects Existing Ownership and Allows Recovery of Title-Clearing Costs

Date: Nov 28, 2024

Reformed Deeds Relate Back: Slander of Title Protects Existing Ownership and Allows Recovery of Title-Clearing Costs Case: Sarah Massucco v. James M. Kolodziej and Barbara H. Kolodziej, et al....

Unread Promissory Notes: Clear Attorney’s-Fees Terms Remain Enforceable Without Prior Discussion

Date: Nov 28, 2024

Unread Promissory Notes: Clear Attorney’s-Fees Terms Remain Enforceable Without Prior Discussion Case: Joan Falcao v. Mitchel Richardson Citation: 2024 Vt. 78 Court: Supreme Court of Vermont Decided:...

Standards for Structural and Plain Errors in Criminal Appeals: Insights from State of Vermont v. Rodney L. L'Esperance

Date: Nov 26, 2024

Standards for Structural and Plain Errors in Criminal Appeals: Insights from State of Vermont v. Rodney L. L'Esperance Introduction In the landmark case of State of Vermont v. Rodney L. L'Esperance...

Enforcement of Mutual Wills Contracts Requires Mutual Consent for Revocation: Inouye v. Estate of Patricia McHugo Analysis

Date: Nov 26, 2024

Enforcement of Mutual Wills Contracts Requires Mutual Consent for Revocation: Inouye v. Estate of Patricia McHugo Introduction In the landmark case of Susan Inouye v. Estate of Patricia McHugo et al....

Clarification of Bail Denial Procedures under Vermont § 7553a: State v. LaFountain

Date: Nov 24, 2024

Clarification of Bail Denial Procedures under Vermont § 7553a: State v. LaFountain Introduction In the landmark case State of Vermont v. Christopher LaFountain, the Supreme Court of Vermont addressed...

Looser Interpretation of "Contiguous Tract" Facilitates Priority Housing Exemption from Act 250 Review

Date: Nov 19, 2024

Looser Interpretation of "Contiguous Tract" Facilitates Priority Housing Exemption from Act 250 Review Introduction The Supreme Court of Vermont, in the landmark case In re Windham Windsor Housing...

Judicial Ethics Rules Do Not Govern Executive Agencies: Separate Prosecutorial and Adjudicative Roles Can Satisfy Due Process

Date: Nov 9, 2024

Judicial Ethics Rules Do Not Govern Executive Agencies: Separate Prosecutorial and Adjudicative Roles Can Satisfy Due Process In re John Grismore, 2024 VT 70 Supreme Court of Vermont | November 8,...

Vermont’s Savings Statute: Overall Diligence for “Unavoidable Accident” and Relief Within Statutory Limits

Date: Nov 9, 2024

Vermont’s Savings Statute: Overall Diligence for “Unavoidable Accident” and Relief Within Statutory Limits Case: Jane Doe v. Victoria Camacho, 2024 Vt. 72 Court: Supreme Court of Vermont Decided:...

Zoning Finality Does Not Bar Commission Fair-Housing Claims Seeking Relief That Leaves the Permit Decision Intact

Date: Nov 9, 2024

Zoning Finality Does Not Bar Commission Fair-Housing Claims Seeking Relief That Leaves the Permit Decision Intact Case: Vermont Human Rights Commission v. Town of St. Johnsbury, 2024 Vt. 71 Court:...

Affirmation of Strict Party Status Requirements in Environmental Permit Abandonment: In re Burchard Road Case

Date: Aug 10, 2024

Affirmation of Strict Party Status Requirements in Environmental Permit Abandonment: In re Burchard Road Case Introduction The In re Burchard Road Petition to Abandon Land Use Permit Denial is a...

Vermont Supreme Court Strengthens Jurisdictional Boundaries in Environmental Takings: In re DJK, LLC WW & WS Permit

Date: Jun 15, 2024

Vermont Supreme Court Strengthens Jurisdictional Boundaries in Environmental Takings: In re DJK, LLC WW & WS Permit (2024 Vt. 34) Introduction The case of Ralph Crowley and Joanne Crowley vs. DJK,...

Comprehensive Commentary on State of Vermont v. Jason Roberts: Abrogation of the Year-and-a-Day Rule

Date: Jun 8, 2024

Comprehensive Commentary on State of Vermont v. Jason Roberts: Abrogation of the Year-and-a-Day Rule Introduction State of Vermont v. Jason Roberts, 2024 Vt. 32, adjudicated by the Supreme Court of...

Vermont Supreme Court Establishes Resale Exclusion for Business Consumers under VCPA in RSD Leasing, Inc. v. Navistar International Corp.

Date: Jun 8, 2024

Vermont Supreme Court Establishes Resale Exclusion for Business Consumers under VCPA in RSD Leasing, Inc. v. Navistar International Corp. Introduction The Supreme Court of Vermont addressed a pivotal...

Mootness Doctrine Affirmed in Juvenile Proceedings: Insights from In re M.M., Juvenile (2024 Vt. 28)

Date: May 11, 2024

Mootness Doctrine Affirmed in Juvenile Proceedings: Insights from In re M.M., Juvenile (2024 Vt. 28) Introduction The Supreme Court of Vermont, in In re M.M., Juvenile (2024 Vt. 28), addressed...

Vermont Supreme Court Clarifies 'Last Occurrence' in Statutes of Repose for Latent Diseases

Date: May 11, 2024

Vermont Supreme Court Clarifies 'Last Occurrence' in Statutes of Repose for Latent Diseases Introduction In the landmark case of Shirley Ann Carpin v. Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corporation et al.,...

Affirmation of Bail Denial Based on Corpus Delicti Corroboration in Sexual Assault Cases: State of Vermont v. Winter Holland-Levine

Date: May 1, 2024

Affirmation of Bail Denial Based on Corpus Delicti Corroboration in Sexual Assault Cases: State of Vermont v. Winter Holland-Levine Introduction In the landmark case of State of Vermont v. Winter...

Vermont Supreme Court Establishes Clarification on Sex Offender Registry Requirements in Concurrent Sentencing Cases

Date: Apr 20, 2024

Vermont Supreme Court Establishes Clarification on Sex Offender Registry Requirements in Concurrent Sentencing Cases Introduction The Vermont Supreme Court, in the case of Andrew Wood v. Jeffrey...

Establishing the Duty of Cooperation: In re Eva P. Vekos, Esq. Sets New Precedent in Attorney Disciplinary Proceedings

Date: Mar 28, 2024

Establishing the Duty of Cooperation: In re Eva P. Vekos, Esq. Sets New Precedent in Attorney Disciplinary Proceedings Introduction The Supreme Court of Vermont's recent decision in In re Eva P....