Vermont Case Commentaries

Clarification of § 7553a Applicability to Accessory After the Fact – State v. Bulson

Date: Feb 27, 2024

Clarification of § 7553a Applicability to Accessory After the Fact – State v. Bulson Introduction In the landmark case of State of Vermont v. Shawn Bulson, the Supreme Court of Vermont addressed the...

Partial Voidance of Testamentary Bequests Under Undue Influence: In re Estate of Donald Crofut

Date: Feb 24, 2024

Partial Voidance of Testamentary Bequests Under Undue Influence: In re Estate of Donald Crofut Introduction In the case of In re Estate of Donald Crofut (Sean Hammond, Appellant), decided on February...

Expansion of 'Threat' under Vermont's Civil Stalking Statute and Rejection of Property Defense – _Gail Haupt v. John Langlois_

Date: Jan 13, 2024

Expansion of 'Threat' under Vermont's Civil Stalking Statute and Rejection of Property Defense – Gail Haupt v. John Langlois Introduction Gail Haupt v. John Langlois (2024 Vt. 3) is a landmark case...

Affirmation of Renewable Natural Gas Procurement under Vermont's Global Warming Solutions Act: Integrating Social Cost of Carbon into Least-Cost Planning

Date: Jan 13, 2024

Affirmation of Renewable Natural Gas Procurement under Vermont's Global Warming Solutions Act: Integrating Social Cost of Carbon into Least-Cost Planning Introduction The case of In re Petition of...

Limiting Postconviction Evidence in Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Claims: In re Rein Kolts

Date: Jan 6, 2024

Limiting Postconviction Evidence in Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Claims: In re Rein Kolts Introduction The case of In re Rein Kolts (2024 Vt. 1) presents a pivotal moment in Vermont...

Direct Physical Damage under Insurance Policies: Insights from Huntington Ingalls Industries v. Ace American Insurance Company

Date: Sep 24, 2022

Direct Physical Damage under Insurance Policies: Insights from Huntington Ingalls Industries v. Ace American Insurance Company Introduction The case of Huntington Ingalls Industries, Inc. et al. v....

Extending Relief-From-Abuse Orders Post-Expiration: Insights from Meghan Forrett v. Orion Stone

Date: Mar 20, 2021

Extending Relief-From-Abuse Orders Post-Expiration: Insights from Meghan Forrett v. Orion Stone (2021 Vt. 17) Introduction The case of Meghan Forrett v. Orion Stone (2021 Vt. 17) adjudicated by the...

Vermont Supreme Court Establishes Scope of Claim Preclusion in Vehicle Access Over Municipal Trails

Date: Feb 27, 2021

Vermont Supreme Court Establishes Scope of Claim Preclusion in Vehicle Access Over Municipal Trails Introduction In Demarest v. Town of Underhill (2021 VT 14), the Vermont Supreme Court addressed...

Vermont Supreme Court Upholds Consent Exception for Warrantless Breath Tests in DUI-3 Cases

Date: Oct 17, 2020

Vermont Supreme Court Upholds Consent Exception for Warrantless Breath Tests in DUI-3 Cases Introduction The State of Vermont v. Peter John Williams and State of Vermont v. Peter J. Boissoneault...

Standing of Complainants in Professional Discipline Proceedings: Insights from Kirk Wool v. Office of Professional Regulation

Date: Jun 13, 2020

Standing of Complainants in Professional Discipline Proceedings: Insights from Kirk Wool v. Office of Professional Regulation Introduction In Kirk Wool v. Office of Professional Regulation, the...

Vermont Supreme Court Establishes Nuanced Interpretation of Bail Under §§ 40 and 7553b in State v. Lohr

Date: Jun 6, 2020

Vermont Supreme Court Establishes Nuanced Interpretation of Bail Under §§ 40 and 7553b in State v. Lohr Introduction State of Vermont v. James C. Lohr (236 A.3d 1277), adjudicated by the Supreme...

Affirmation of No Bail Decision under 13 V.S.A. §7553 in State v. Auclair

Date: Mar 11, 2020

Affirmation of No Bail Decision under 13 V.S.A. §7553 in State of Vermont v. Angela M. Auclair Introduction In the landmark case of State of Vermont v. Angela M. Auclair, 229 A.3d 1019 (Vt. 2020),...

Affirming Finality of CHINS Adjudications in Termination of Parental Rights: In re C.L.S., Juvenile

Date: Jan 11, 2020

Affirming Finality of CHINS Adjudications in Termination of Parental Rights: In re C.L.S., Juvenile Introduction In re C.L.S., Juvenile, 225 A.3d 644 (Supreme Court of Vermont, 2020), presents a...

Reaffirming Reasonable Suspicion Standards and Limits on Evidence Preservation Duties in Vehicle Stop Cases: State v. Lenore Hayes

Date: Sep 10, 2016

Reaffirming Reasonable Suspicion Standards and Limits on Evidence Preservation Duties in Vehicle Stop Cases: State v. Lenore Hayes Introduction In the landmark case of State of Vermont v. Lenore...

Qualified Official Immunity Affirmed in Negligence and IIED Claims: Baptie v. McNeil

Date: Dec 7, 2013

Qualified Official Immunity Affirmed in Negligence and IIED Claims: Baptie v. McNeil Introduction In the landmark case of Thomas R. Baptie and Mary L. Baptie, Ind., v. Aron McNeil (88 A.3d 1212), the...

Res Judicata Upholds Finality in Divorce Property Settlements: Analysis of Iannarone v. Limoggio

Date: Aug 13, 2011

Res Judicata Upholds Finality in Divorce Property Settlements: Analysis of Iannarone v. Limoggio Introduction Iannarone v. Limoggio is a landmark decision by the Supreme Court of Vermont, rendered on...

Vermont Supreme Court Reinterprets Primary Agricultural Soils Definition under Act 250

Date: Jun 19, 2010

Vermont Supreme Court Reinterprets Primary Agricultural Soils Definition under Act 250 Introduction The case of In re Village Associates Act 250 Land Use Permit (2010 Vt. 42) addresses the...

Vermont Supreme Court Establishes Economic Substance Doctrine in Tax Avoidance Cases

Date: Sep 20, 2008

Vermont Supreme Court Establishes Economic Substance Doctrine in Tax Avoidance Cases Introduction The case of TD Banknorth, N.A. v. Department of Taxes (185 Vt. 45) addressed significant issues...

Clarifying the Nonbusiness-Pursuits Exception to the Business-Pursuits Exclusion in Insurance Policies: Towns v. Northern Security Insurance Company

Date: Aug 2, 2008

Clarifying the Nonbusiness-Pursuits Exception to the Business-Pursuits Exclusion in Insurance Policies: Towns v. Northern Security Insurance Company Introduction Richard Towns v. Northern Security...

Supreme Court of Vermont Establishes Taxable Real Estate Classification for Leased Buildings: Gordon v. Board of Civil Authority (2006)

Date: Sep 2, 2006

Supreme Court of Vermont Establishes Taxable Real Estate Classification for Leased Buildings: Gordon v. Board of Civil Authority (2006) Introduction The case of William Gordon v. Board of Civil...