Puerto Rico Case Commentaries

Objective-Reasonableness Standard Governs Civil Detainee Diet Claims; Qualified Immunity Applies Where Kosher Request Appears Insincere and Officials Lack Personal Involvement

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Objective-Reasonableness Standard Governs Civil Detainee Diet Claims; Qualified Immunity Applies Where Kosher Request Appears Insincere and Officials Lack Personal Involvement Introduction In Logan...

Striking the Entire Defense Closing Argument Is a Prejudicial Abuse of Discretion Even When Parts Are Improper

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Striking the Entire Defense Closing Argument Is a Prejudicial Abuse of Discretion Even When Parts Are Improper I. Introduction In United States v. Cristian Ariel Arevalo Arias, United States v....

NRCP 65(b)(2)’s 14-Day Limit Applies to TROs Issued With Notice: Indefinite TROs Automatically Expire Absent Proper Extension or Consent

Date: Sep 4, 2026

NRCP 65(b)(2)’s 14-Day Limit Applies to TROs Issued With Notice: Indefinite TROs Automatically Expire Absent Proper Extension or Consent 1. Introduction Havens v. Dist. Ct. (CarWil, LLC) (Civil), 142...

Constructive “Application for Admission” After Unlawful Entry Validates Expedited Removal as a § 1326 Predicate (Fifth Circuit)

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Constructive “Application for Admission” After Unlawful Entry Validates Expedited Removal as a § 1326 Predicate (Fifth Circuit) 1. Introduction In United States v. Escobedo-Gomez (5th Cir. Sept. 3,...

FLSA Salary-Basis Rule: Comp-Time and Hypothetical Docking Do Not Defeat Exempt Status Absent an Actual Pay-Reduction Practice

Date: Sep 4, 2026

FLSA Salary-Basis Rule: Comp-Time and Hypothetical Docking Do Not Defeat Exempt Status Absent an Actual Pay-Reduction Practice Moreau v. Harris County (5th Cir. Sept. 3, 2026) — No. 25-20045 1....

Separate-Contract Endorsements Bar Convention Arbitration Against Domestic Insurers, but Related Domestic Litigation May Be Stayed Pending Foreign-Insurer Arbitration

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Separate-Contract Endorsements Bar Convention Arbitration Against Domestic Insurers, but Related Domestic Litigation May Be Stayed Pending Foreign-Insurer Arbitration Case: Transportation...

Conflict Waivers in Retainer Agreements Require Fact-Proven “Informed Consent” to Bar Malpractice Claims (and Substantial-Factor Causation Can Reach Divorce-Related Financial Harm)

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Conflict Waivers in Retainer Agreements Require Fact-Proven “Informed Consent” to Bar Malpractice Claims (and Substantial-Factor Causation Can Reach Divorce-Related Financial Harm) Case: Lisa Grattan...

Broad “In Furtherance” Standard for Co‑Conspirator Statements and Permissible Conditional Admission Under Rule 801(d)(2)(E)

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Broad “In Furtherance” Standard for Co‑Conspirator Statements and Permissible Conditional Admission Under Rule 801(d)(2)(E) 1. Introduction In United States v. Emerson Pavilus (3d Cir. Sept. 3, 2026)...

“Gainful Occupation” Is Unambiguous in “Total Disability” Clauses That Bar Any Other Work, Confirming a General (Not Occupational) Disability Standard

Date: Sep 4, 2026

“Gainful Occupation” Is Unambiguous in “Total Disability” Clauses That Bar Any Other Work, Confirming a General (Not Occupational) Disability Standard 1) Introduction In Brian Caraba, D.D.S. v. Paul...

Upward Variance Above a Mandatory Minimum Is Substantively Reasonable When Anchored in § 3553(a) Risk, Treatment Noncompliance, and Case-Specific Destruction

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Upward Variance Above a Mandatory Minimum Is Substantively Reasonable When Anchored in § 3553(a) Risk, Treatment Noncompliance, and Case-Specific Destruction I. Introduction In United States v. Gomez...

ERISA LTD Benefits May Be Terminated for Failure to Provide Requested Financial Proof Under a Discretionary Plan

Date: Sep 4, 2026

ERISA LTD Benefits May Be Terminated for Failure to Provide Requested Financial Proof Under a Discretionary Plan Case: Judson Pankey v. Aetna Life Insurance Company (11th Cir. Sept. 3, 2026) (per...

Appointments-Clause Remedies Are Limited to Actions Taken Under Unconstitutionally Delegated “Veto” Authority (Magnuson-Stevens Councils)

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Appointments-Clause Remedies Are Limited to Actions Taken Under Unconstitutionally Delegated “Veto” Authority (Magnuson-Stevens Councils) I. Introduction Case: Dominick Russo v. Secretary, U.S....

Rule 39(b) “Strong and Compelling Reasons” Standard: Eleventh-Hour Conversion of a Scheduled Jury Trial to a Bench Trial Is an Abuse of Discretion When the Parties Had Clear Notice of a Jury Request

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Rule 39(b) “Strong and Compelling Reasons” Standard: Eleventh-Hour Conversion of a Scheduled Jury Trial to a Bench Trial Is an Abuse of Discretion When the Parties Had Clear Notice of a Jury Request...

Rule 41(b) Dismissals for Violating Filing Injunctions Must Be Without Prejudice When Defendants Are Unserved

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Rule 41(b) Dismissals for Violating Filing Injunctions Must Be Without Prejudice When Defendants Are Unserved 1. Introduction In Waseem Daker v. Gregory Dozier (11th Cir. Sept. 3, 2026)...

Non-Medical Prison Officials Are Not Deliberately Indifferent Absent Notice of Medical Mistreatment; Counsel Illness Can Supply Rule 16 Good Cause

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Non-Medical Prison Officials Are Not Deliberately Indifferent Absent Notice of Medical Mistreatment; Counsel Illness Can Supply Rule 16 Good Cause Introduction In Stanley Boclair v. Anthony Wills, et...

Indefinite Remote Work Is Not a Reasonable ADA Accommodation When It Eliminates an Essential In-Person Student-Supervision Function

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Indefinite Remote Work Is Not a Reasonable ADA Accommodation When It Eliminates an Essential In-Person Student-Supervision Function Case: Nilsa Agrait v. Hillsborough County Public Schools (11th Cir....

Channeling Coast Guard S&R Challenges to the NTSB Review Scheme While Treating Raise-of-Grade Denials as Independently Reviewable Final Agency Action

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Channeling Coast Guard S&R Challenges to the NTSB Review Scheme While Treating Raise-of-Grade Denials as Independently Reviewable Final Agency Action 1. Introduction Mullen v. Mullin (5th Cir. Sept....

Objective-Reasonableness Review for Civil Detainee Diet Claims and Qualified Immunity Where Kosher-Diet Sincerity Is Unclear

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Objective-Reasonableness Review for Civil Detainee Diet Claims and Qualified Immunity Where Kosher-Diet Sincerity Is Unclear 1. Introduction In Logan Dyjak v. Melanie Kluzek, et al. (7th Cir. Sept....

Hollers v. Baker: Sua Sponte Immunity and Younger Abstention at § 1915 Screening in Pro Se § 1983 Actions

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Hollers v. Baker: Sua Sponte Immunity and Younger Abstention at § 1915 Screening in Pro Se § 1983 Actions 1. Introduction In Hollers v. Baker (10th Cir. Sept. 3, 2026) (nonprecedential order and...

Fourth Circuit: A Trial Court Abuses Its Discretion by Striking a Defendant’s Entire Closing Argument, Thereby Effectively Denying the Constitutional Right to Summation

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Fourth Circuit: A Trial Court Abuses Its Discretion by Striking a Defendant’s Entire Closing Argument, Thereby Effectively Denying the Constitutional Right to Summation 1. Introduction United States...