Pennsylvania Case Commentaries

Commonwealth v. Walker (2025): Re-defining the Limits of Voir Dire Questions on Legal Principles in Pennsylvania

Date: Aug 25, 2025

Commonwealth v. Walker (Pa. 2025): Re-defining the Limits of Voir Dire Questions on Legal Principles Introduction In Commonwealth v. Walker, the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania—Western...

“No Unity Destroyed, No Severance Achieved” – The Pennsylvania Supreme Court Rejects Self-Conveyance as a Means of Terminating Joint Tenancy

Date: Aug 25, 2025

“No Unity Destroyed, No Severance Achieved” – The Pennsylvania Supreme Court Rejects Self-Conveyance as a Means of Terminating Joint Tenancy 1. Introduction Grant v. Grant (Pa. 2025) tackles a...

Defining Agency Records in the Social-Media Age: The “Penncrest Factors” under Pennsylvania’s Right-to-Know Law

Date: Aug 25, 2025

Defining Agency Records in the Social-Media Age: The “Penncrest Factors” under Pennsylvania’s Right-to-Know Law 1. Introduction Penncrest School District v. Cagle is the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s...

Supreme Court Clarifies Due-Process Safeguards in Administrative Attorney Suspensions Under Pa.R.D.E. 219

Date: Aug 18, 2025

Supreme Court Clarifies Due-Process Safeguards in Administrative Attorney Suspensions Under Pa.R.D.E. 219 1. Introduction On 13 August 2025 the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania issued an order entitled...

Registration Alone Does Not Defeat Privacy – A Commentary on Commonwealth v. Anderson (Pa. 2025)

Date: Jul 24, 2025

Registration Alone Does Not Defeat Privacy The Pennsylvania Supreme Court Clarifies the Commonwealth’s Initial Burden in Vehicle-Search Suppression Hearings Introduction In Commonwealth v. Anderson,...

“ARD Counts, Conviction Doesn’t”: Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Upholds Use of ARD as a “Prior Offense” for Civil License Suspensions

Date: Jul 23, 2025

“ARD Counts, Conviction Doesn’t” – Commentary on Ferguson v. PennDOT, Bureau of Driver Licensing (Pa. 2025) 1. Introduction This commentary examines the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania’s decision in...

Automatic Administrative Suspension for CLE Non-Compliance – A New Phase in Pa.R.C.L.E. 111(b) Enforcement

Date: Jul 23, 2025

Automatic Administrative Suspension for CLE Non-Compliance: Supreme Court of Pennsylvania’s July 2025 Order under Pa.R.C.L.E. 111(b) 1. Introduction On 16 July 2025 the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania...

Reaffirming the Narrow Application of Permanent Disbarment: The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Clarifies the Keller Threshold in In re Cappuccio

Date: Jul 4, 2025

Reaffirming the Narrow Application of Permanent Disbarment: The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Clarifies the Keller Threshold in In re Cappuccio 1. Introduction On 2 July 2025, the Supreme Court of...

Commonwealth v. Hardy: Reaffirming Timeliness & Refining the “Actual Innocence” Standard in Pennsylvania Post-Conviction DNA Litigation

Date: Jun 20, 2025

Commonwealth v. Hardy: Reaffirming Timeliness & Refining the “Actual Innocence” Standard in Pennsylvania Post-Conviction DNA Litigation Introduction In Commonwealth v. Hardy (Pa. 2025) the Supreme...

The “Totality-of-Circumstances Reasonableness Test” for Pedalcyclists: A Commentary on Commonwealth v. Linton (Pa. 2025)

Date: Jun 20, 2025

The “Totality-of-Circumstances Reasonableness Test” for Pedalcyclists: Comprehensive Commentary on Commonwealth v. Linton, 11 WAP 2024 (Pa. 2025) 1. Introduction Commonwealth v. Linton marks the...

Estate Entitlement to Pending Specific‐Loss Benefits Under Section 410

Date: May 31, 2025

Estate Entitlement to Pending Specific‐Loss Benefits Under Section 410 Introduction This case arises from the appeal in Steets, K., Aplt. v. Celebration Fireworks, Inc. (Workers’ Compensation Appeal...

Profit-Linked Compensation and Related-Entity Transfers Disqualify Purely Public Charities from Property Tax Exemption

Date: May 31, 2025

Profit-Linked Compensation and Related-Entity Transfers Disqualify Purely Public Charities from Property Tax Exemption Introduction This commentary examines Justice Mundy’s dissent in Pottstown...

Redemptive Tax Sale and Duty to Pay: Powell Rule Protects Subsurface Rights

Date: May 31, 2025

Redemptive Tax Sale and Duty to Pay: Powell Rule Protects Subsurface Rights Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Pennsylvania Game Commission (“Appellant”) v. Thomas E. Proctor Heirs Trust...

Facial Unconstitutionality of §3806: Apprendi Protections for ARD-Based Sentencing Enhancements

Date: May 31, 2025

Facial Unconstitutionality of §3806: Apprendi Protections for ARD-Based Sentencing Enhancements Introduction Commonwealth v. Shifflett, G., Aplt. (No. 26 MAP 2024), decided May 30, 2025 by the...

Mandating Expeditious Administration of Pennsylvania’s Instantaneous Firearms Background Checks

Date: May 31, 2025

Mandating Expeditious Administration of Pennsylvania’s Instantaneous Firearms Background Checks Introduction This case arises from a dispute over the Pennsylvania State Police’s (“PSP”) performance...

Extending the Inconsistent Verdicts Doctrine to Special Interrogatories

Date: May 31, 2025

Extending the Inconsistent Verdicts Doctrine to Special Interrogatories Introduction In Commonwealth v. Muhammad, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court considered whether the familiar “inconsistent...

Reaffirming Specific Intent and Mitigation Standards in Capital Cases: Commonwealth v. Johnson

Date: May 20, 2025

Reaffirming Specific Intent and Mitigation Standards in Capital Cases: Commonwealth v. Johnson Introduction Commonwealth v. Johnson is a post-conviction relief appeal decided by the Supreme Court of...

Genetic Testing as the Exclusive Rebuttal to the Presumption of Paternity under 23 Pa.C.S. § 5104

Date: Apr 26, 2025

Genetic Testing as the Exclusive Rebuttal to the Presumption of Paternity under 23 Pa.C.S. § 5104 Introduction Sitler v. Jones, 2025 WL ___ (Pa. Apr. 25, 2025), presented the Supreme Court of...

Mug Shots as Identifiable Descriptions Under CHRIA – County Dissemination Prohibited

Date: Apr 26, 2025

Mug Shots as Identifiable Descriptions Under CHRIA – County Dissemination Prohibited Introduction In Mezzacappa v. Northampton County, 2025 PA 40 MAP and 41 MAP, the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania...

Interdependency Requirement for Aggregating Noncontiguous Parcels Under Section 705 of the Eminent Domain Code

Date: Apr 26, 2025

Interdependency Requirement for Aggregating Noncontiguous Parcels Under Section 705 of the Eminent Domain Code Introduction In Pignetti, G. & J. h/w, Aplts. v. PennDOT, No. 26 & 27 EAP 2023 (Pa. Apr....