Pennsylvania Case Commentaries

“Any Person” Includes High Public Officials: Justice Dougherty’s Dissent on the Waiver of Official Immunity under Pennsylvania’s Wiretap Act

Date: Nov 20, 2025

“Any Person” Includes High Public Officials: Justice Dougherty’s Dissent on the Waiver of Official Immunity under Pennsylvania’s Wiretap Act I. Introduction This commentary examines Justice Kevin...

Commonwealth v. Blakeney: No Public-Record Presumption in PCRA “Unknown Fact” Exception and Reasonable Diligence in Juror-Nondisclosure Claims

Date: Nov 7, 2025

Commonwealth v. Blakeney: No Public-Record Presumption in PCRA “Unknown Fact” Exception and Reasonable Diligence in Juror-Nondisclosure Claims Introduction In Commonwealth v. Blakeney (Pa. Nov. 5,...

Plain Meaning Over “Spirit”: Pennsylvania High Court Bars ARD Revocation for Pre‑Admission Conduct or Implied Conditions

Date: Oct 30, 2025

Plain Meaning Over “Spirit”: Pennsylvania High Court Bars ARD Revocation for Pre‑Admission Conduct or Implied Conditions Introduction In Commonwealth v. Jenkins, the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania...

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Confirms Home Inspection Law’s One‑Year Period Is a Statute of Repose Triggered by Report Delivery (Gidor v. Mangus)

Date: Oct 30, 2025

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Confirms Home Inspection Law’s One‑Year Period Is a Statute of Repose Triggered by Report Delivery Case: Gidor v. Mangus (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, Western District,...

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Broadens MHPA Immunity to All Care During MHPA Admissions; Dissent Would Limit Immunity to Care That Facilitates Recovery from Mental Illness

Date: Oct 30, 2025

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Broadens MHPA Immunity to All Care During MHPA Admissions; Dissent Would Limit Immunity to Care That Facilitates Recovery from Mental Illness Introduction In Wunderly v....

No Precedent Set: Justice Wecht’s Dissent Urges Individualized Suspicion for Flight Plus Proximity to Marijuana Under Article I, Section 8

Date: Oct 16, 2025

No Precedent Set: Justice Wecht’s Dissent Urges Individualized Suspicion for Flight Plus Proximity to Marijuana Under Article I, Section 8 Introduction In Commonwealth v. Coles, E., Aplt., the...

No Agency-Made Privileges: Pennsylvania Supreme Court Holds 37 Pa. Code § 61.2 Does Not Create an Evidentiary Privilege

Date: Oct 10, 2025

No Agency-Made Privileges: Pennsylvania Supreme Court Holds 37 Pa. Code § 61.2 Does Not Create an Evidentiary Privilege Introduction In Toland v. Pennsylvania Board of Probation and Parole (Pa....

Section 9760(1) Requires Credit to the New Sentence for Pre‑Sentence Custody on a Probation Detainer When the Detainer Is Based on the Same Conduct as the New Charge: Commonwealth v. Phillips (Pa. 2025)

Date: Oct 2, 2025

Section 9760(1) Requires Credit to the New Sentence for Pre‑Sentence Custody on a Probation Detainer When the Detainer Is Based on the Same Conduct as the New Charge Commentary on Commonwealth v....

Conduct-Based Time Credit Under 42 Pa.C.S. § 9760(1): Pre‑Sentence Custody on a Probation Detainer Triggered by New‑Charge Conduct Must Be Credited to the New Sentence

Date: Oct 2, 2025

Conduct-Based Time Credit Under 42 Pa.C.S. § 9760(1): Pre‑Sentence Custody on a Probation Detainer Triggered by New‑Charge Conduct Must Be Credited to the New Sentence Case: Commonwealth v. Phillips,...

Commonwealth v. Lewis: Pennsylvania Supreme Court Retains “High‑Crime Area” as a Terry Factor, Offers Non‑Mandatory Guideposts; Justice Wecht Urges Its Abandonment Under Article I, Section 8

Date: Sep 27, 2025

Commonwealth v. Lewis: Pennsylvania Supreme Court Retains “High‑Crime Area” as a Terry Factor, Offers Non‑Mandatory Guideposts; Justice Wecht Urges Its Abandonment Under Article I, Section 8 Court:...

Post-Strunk Application of §6318: Verbal Pre‑Assault Commands as “Communication” — Justice Mundy’s Concurrence/Dissent in Commonwealth v. Smith (Pa. 2025)

Date: Sep 27, 2025

Post-Strunk Application of §6318: Verbal Pre‑Assault Commands as “Communication” — Justice Mundy’s Concurrence/Dissent in Commonwealth v. Smith (Pa. 2025) Introduction This commentary examines...

Post-Strunk Application of 18 Pa.C.S. § 6318: Verbal Commands as “Communication” for Unlawful Contact with a Minor — Justice Mundy’s Concurrence/Dissent in Commonwealth v. Smith

Date: Sep 27, 2025

Post-Strunk Application of 18 Pa.C.S. § 6318: Verbal Commands as “Communication” for Unlawful Contact with a Minor — Justice Mundy’s Concurrence/Dissent in Commonwealth v. Smith Introduction In...

Context Over Text: Pennsylvania Supreme Court Upholds DOH’s Two‑Lab Testing Rule Under the Medical Marijuana Act (Wecht, J., dissenting)

Date: Sep 27, 2025

Context Over Text: Pennsylvania Supreme Court Upholds DOH’s Two‑Lab Testing Rule Under the Medical Marijuana Act (Wecht, J., dissenting) Introduction In Green Analytics North, LLC v. Department of...

Limiting “Other Person Under the Tenant’s Control” to the Initial Invitation Onto the Premises: Justice Wecht’s Dissent in Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh v. Nash

Date: Sep 27, 2025

Limiting “Other Person Under the Tenant’s Control” to the Initial Invitation Onto the Premises: Justice Wecht’s Dissent in Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh v. Nash Introduction This...

On‑Bill Billing and the Limits of Section 1502: Pennsylvania Supreme Court Holds Non‑Electric Add‑Ons Fall Outside “Service”; Scope of “All Electric Services” Reserved

Date: Sep 27, 2025

On‑Bill Billing and the Limits of Section 1502: Pennsylvania Supreme Court Holds Non‑Electric Add‑Ons Fall Outside “Service”; Scope of “All Electric Services” Reserved Introduction In Interstate Gas...

Uniformity in Effect, Not Form: Denial of Local Tax Credits to Nonresidents Renders Pittsburgh’s Facility Fee Unconstitutional under Pennsylvania’s Uniformity Clause

Date: Sep 27, 2025

Uniformity in Effect, Not Form: Denial of Local Tax Credits to Nonresidents Renders Pittsburgh’s Facility Fee Unconstitutional under Pennsylvania’s Uniformity Clause Introduction In National Hockey...

Tranter v. Z&D Tour: Pennsylvania High Court Rejects “Key Witness” Requirement and Articulates a 100‑Mile Benchmark in Forum Non Conveniens Analysis

Date: Sep 27, 2025

Tranter v. Z&D Tour: Pennsylvania High Court Rejects “Key Witness” Requirement and Articulates a 100‑Mile Benchmark in Forum Non Conveniens Analysis Introduction In a set of consolidated appeals...

SURE-Based Email Notifications and Accurate Coding as Pennsylvania’s Minimum Statewide Process for Defective Mail‑In Ballots

Date: Sep 27, 2025

SURE-Based Email Notifications and Accurate Coding as Pennsylvania’s Minimum Statewide Process for Defective Mail‑In Ballots Introduction In Center for Coalfield Justice v. Washington County Board of...

Human Oversight and Secured-Only Systems: Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s Interim Framework for Judicial Use of Generative AI

Date: Sep 10, 2025

Human Oversight and Secured-Only Systems: Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s Interim Framework for Judicial Use of Generative AI Introduction On September 9, 2025, the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania issued...

“Written-Consent Rule” for Reinstated Bail: Commonwealth v. Rondon (Pa. 2025)

Date: Aug 25, 2025

“Written-Consent Rule” for Reinstated Bail Commonwealth v. Rondon, 294 A.3d ___ (Pa. 2025) 1. Introduction Supreme Court of Pennsylvania (Middle District) — Decided 19 Aug 2025 Majority: McCaffery,...