Pennsylvania Case Commentaries

Creating Municipality’s Continuing Power to Compel Project Conveyance Under MAA § 5622(a) Despite § 5610(a.1) Board Expansion (Mundy, J., concurring and dissenting)

Date: Jan 22, 2026

Creating Municipality’s Continuing Power to Compel Project Conveyance Under MAA § 5622(a) Despite § 5610(a.1) Board Expansion (Mundy, J., concurring and dissenting) 1. Introduction This Pennsylvania...

MAA § 5622(a) Conveyance Power Depends on Present Municipal Authority to Operate the “Project,” Not Mere Status as Creating Municipality

Date: Jan 22, 2026

MAA § 5622(a) Conveyance Power Depends on Present Municipal Authority to Operate the “Project,” Not Mere Status as Creating Municipality Introduction This Pennsylvania Supreme Court decision arises...

Section 5622(a) Conveyance Power Turns on Present Municipal Authority After Section 5610(a.1) Board Recomposition

Date: Jan 22, 2026

Section 5622(a) Conveyance Power Turns on Present Municipal Authority After Section 5610(a.1) Board Recomposition Case: In re: Chester Water Authority Trust (appeals consolidated) Court: Supreme...

All Expert Manner-of-Death Opinions Must Be Stated to a Reasonable Degree of Certainty (No “Probable” Exception)

Date: Jan 22, 2026

All Expert Manner-of-Death Opinions Must Be Stated to a Reasonable Degree of Certainty (No “Probable” Exception) 1) Introduction Commonwealth v. Fitzpatrick is a high-profile homicide prosecution...

Section 5622(a) MAA: A Creating Municipality’s Unilateral Conveyance Power Turns on Present Power to Operate the “Project”

Date: Jan 22, 2026

Section 5622(a) MAA: A Creating Municipality’s Unilateral Conveyance Power Turns on Present Power to Operate the “Project” 1. Introduction Parties and setting. These consolidated matters concern...

Dynamic Conveyance Power Under MAA § 5622(a): Creation Alone Does Not Preserve a Municipality’s Unilateral Right to Acquire an Authority’s Projects After Board Reconstitution

Date: Jan 22, 2026

Dynamic Conveyance Power Under MAA § 5622(a): Creation Alone Does Not Preserve a Municipality’s Unilateral Right to Acquire an Authority’s Projects After Board Reconstitution I. Introduction In re:...

MAA § 5622(a) Conveyance Power Turns on Present Municipal Power to Operate—Not Perpetual “Creator” Control After Multi-County Board Expansion

Date: Jan 22, 2026

MAA § 5622(a) Conveyance Power Turns on Present Municipal Power to Operate—Not Perpetual “Creator” Control After Multi-County Board Expansion Introduction This Pennsylvania Supreme Court matter...

PUC Cannot Impose FCC-Style Presumptive “New Telecom Rate” for ILECs Without Pennsylvania Statutory Authority; Complainant Retains Burden Under 66 Pa.C.S. § 332(a)

Date: Jan 10, 2026

PUC Cannot Impose FCC-Style Presumptive “New Telecom Rate” for ILECs Without Pennsylvania Statutory Authority; Complainant Retains Burden Under 66 Pa.C.S. § 332(a) FirstEnergy Pennsylvania Electric...

PUC Lacks Authority to Impose an FCC-Style Presumptive Maximum Pole-Attachment Rate for ILECs; Complainant Bears the Burden to Prove Existing JUA Rates Unreasonable

Date: Jan 10, 2026

PUC Lacks Authority to Impose an FCC-Style Presumptive Maximum Pole-Attachment Rate for ILECs; Complainant Bears the Burden to Prove Existing JUA Rates Unreasonable I. Introduction Case: FirstEnergy...

Pennsylvania’s Procedural Framework for Uniform Family Law Arbitration: Petitions, Forum, Award Review, and Post-Confirmation Enforcement

Date: Jan 3, 2026

Pennsylvania’s Procedural Framework for Uniform Family Law Arbitration: Petitions, Forum, Award Review, and Post-Confirmation Enforcement 1. Introduction On December 31, 2025, the Supreme Court of...

Accrual of Protection-Order Claims Under Pennsylvania’s Sexual Violence and Intimidation Act: Commentary on Weatherholtz v. McKelvey

Date: Dec 19, 2025

Accrual of Protection-Order Claims Under Pennsylvania’s Sexual Violence and Intimidation Act: Commentary on Weatherholtz v. McKelvey Commentary on Justice Dougherty’s Concurring and Dissenting...

Affirmative Public Benefit and Judicial Deference in Section 1329 Utility Acquisitions: Commentary on Consumer Advocate v. PUC (Aqua Pennsylvania Wastewater)

Date: Dec 19, 2025

Affirmative Public Benefit and Judicial Deference in Section 1329 Utility Acquisitions: Commentary on Consumer Advocate v. PUC; Appeal of Aqua Pennsylvania Wastewater, Inc. I. Introduction This...

Consumer Advocate v. PUC (East Whiteland): Reaffirming PUC Discretion and the “Affirmative Public Benefits” Test for Fair Market Value Utility Acquisitions

Date: Dec 19, 2025

Consumer Advocate v. PUC (East Whiteland): Reaffirming PUC Discretion and the “Affirmative Public Benefits” Test for Fair Market Value Utility Acquisitions I. Introduction This consolidated decision...

Affirmative Public Benefits and Deference in Section 1329 Utility Acquisitions: Consumer Advocate v. PUC (Aqua / East Whiteland)

Date: Dec 19, 2025

Affirmative Public Benefits and Deference in Section 1329 Utility Acquisitions: Consumer Advocate v. Pennsylvania PUC (Aqua / East Whiteland) I. Introduction This commentary analyzes the Supreme...

Commonwealth v. Kurtz: Probable Cause and the Validity of Reverse Google Keyword Warrants in Pennsylvania

Date: Dec 19, 2025

Commonwealth v. Kurtz: Probable Cause and the Validity of Reverse Google Keyword Warrants in Pennsylvania I. Introduction The concurring opinion by Chief Justice Todd in Commonwealth v. Kurtz...

Probable Cause and Reverse Keyword Warrants: Chief Justice Todd’s Concurrence in Commonwealth v. Kurtz

Date: Dec 19, 2025

Probable Cause and Reverse Keyword Warrants: Chief Justice Todd’s Concurrence in Commonwealth v. Kurtz I. Introduction This commentary examines the concurring opinion of Chief Justice Debra Todd in...

Probable Cause for Reverse Keyword Warrants Under a Totality-of-the-Circumstances Test: Commentary on Chief Justice Todd’s Concurrence in Commonwealth v. Kurtz

Date: Dec 19, 2025

Probable Cause for Reverse Keyword Warrants Under a Totality-of-the-Circumstances Test: Commentary on Chief Justice Todd’s Concurrence in Commonwealth v. Kurtz I. Introduction The concurring opinion...

Possession as Dominion, Not Exclusivity: Duncan v. Chartiers Nature Conservancy and the Threshold for Quiet Title Actions in Pennsylvania

Date: Dec 19, 2025

Possession as Dominion, Not Exclusivity: Duncan v. Chartiers Nature Conservancy and the Threshold for Quiet Title Actions in Pennsylvania I. Introduction The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania’s decision...

Judicial Gatekeeping of Kinship Care Participation in Pennsylvania Dependency Proceedings: Commentary on the 2025 Amendments to Pa.R.J.C.P. 1241, 1242, 1501, 1514, 1601, and 1608

Date: Dec 2, 2025

Judicial Gatekeeping of Kinship Care Participation in Pennsylvania Dependency Proceedings Commentary on the 2025 Amendments to Pa.R.J.C.P. 1241, 1242, 1501, 1514, 1601, and 1608 I. Introduction The...

Reaffirming Mandatory CLE and Administrative Suspension under Pa.R.C.L.E. 111(b)

Date: Nov 21, 2025

Reaffirming Mandatory CLE and Administrative Suspension under Pa.R.C.L.E. 111(b) I. Introduction On November 19, 2025, the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania issued an order titled “Attorneys...