Pennsylvania Case Commentaries

Newborn Dependency Venue Under Pa.R.J.C.P. 1300(A): A Child’s “Residence” May Follow the Parents When the Infant Has Never Left the Hospital (Justice Mundy, Concurring and Dissenting)

Date: Mar 28, 2026

Newborn Dependency Venue Under Pa.R.J.C.P. 1300(A): A Child’s “Residence” May Follow the Parents When the Infant Has Never Left the Hospital (Justice Mundy, Concurring and Dissenting) Case: In the...

Notice-and-Cure Procedure for CLE Noncompliance Leading to Administrative Suspension Under Pa.R.C.L.E. 111(b)

Date: Mar 21, 2026

Notice-and-Cure Procedure for CLE Noncompliance Leading to Administrative Suspension Under Pa.R.C.L.E. 111(b) Court: Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Date: 2026-03-18 Subject: Administrative suspension...

Commonwealth v. Smith (Pa. 2026): Ineffective Assistance at Capital Resentencing for Failure to Preserve Objections to Irrelevant, Unfairly Prejudicial “Serial Killer” Evidence

Date: Mar 1, 2026

Ineffective Assistance at Capital Resentencing for Failure to Preserve Objections to Irrelevant, Unfairly Prejudicial “Serial Killer” Evidence Case: Commonwealth v. Smith, W. (Supreme Court of...

Pennsylvania Juvenile Delinquency Transfers: Two-Step Intercounty Acceptance, Record-Transmission Protocols, and Deadline Reset

Date: Feb 22, 2026

Pennsylvania Juvenile Delinquency Transfers: Two-Step Intercounty Acceptance, Record-Transmission Protocols, and Deadline Reset Decision/Event: In Re: Order Amending Rules 200, 300, 302, and 630 of...

Section 8371 Bad-Faith Liability Does Not Extend to Surety Bonds (and the Limits of Binding Sureties to a Principal’s Arbitration Award)

Date: Feb 21, 2026

Section 8371 Bad-Faith Liability Does Not Extend to Surety Bonds (and the Limits of Binding Sureties to a Principal’s Arbitration Award) 1) Introduction Eastern Steel Constructors, Inc. v....

Surety Bonds Are Not “Insurance” Under 42 Pa. C.S. § 8371; Non-Consenting Sureties Are Not Bound by Subcontract Arbitration Awards

Date: Feb 21, 2026

Surety Bonds Are Not “Insurance” Under 42 Pa. C.S. § 8371; Non-Consenting Sureties Are Not Bound by Subcontract Arbitration Awards Introduction Eastern Steel Constructors, Inc. (a subcontractor,...

Section 518(2) Finality: Only Orders that Actually Confirm/Modify/Change a Viewers’ Report (Not Pretrial Valuation Rulings) Are Immediately Appealable

Date: Feb 21, 2026

Section 518(2) Finality: Only Orders that Actually Confirm/Modify/Change a Viewers’ Report (Not Pretrial Valuation Rulings) Are Immediately Appealable Case: In Re: Condemnation by the City of...

Traffic-Stop Safety Rule: Police May Temporarily Secure a Firearm in Plain View and Within the Driver’s Reach Without First Determining Licensure

Date: Feb 20, 2026

Traffic-Stop Safety Rule: Police May Temporarily Secure a Firearm in Plain View and Within the Driver’s Reach Without First Determining Licensure Commonwealth v. Hawkins-Davenport (Pa. Feb. 18, 2026)...

Section 205 Co-Employee Immunity Turns on “Scope of Employment” Under the Workers’ Compensation Act

Date: Feb 20, 2026

Section 205 Co-Employee Immunity Turns on “Scope of Employment” Under the Workers’ Compensation Act 1. Introduction Brown, J. v. Gaydos, G. arises from a workplace injury suffered by John Brown, who...

Pa.R.E. 403 Bars Police Interrogation Commentary on a Defendant’s Credibility as Irrelevant and Unfairly Prejudicial (Commonwealth v. Malcolm)

Date: Feb 20, 2026

Pa.R.E. 403 Bars Police Interrogation Commentary on a Defendant’s Credibility as Irrelevant and Unfairly Prejudicial (Commonwealth v. Malcolm) Supreme Court of Pennsylvania (Eastern District) —...

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Approval Framework for Attorney Trust-Account Depositories and IOLTA Participation

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Approval Framework for Attorney Trust-Account Depositories and IOLTA Participation Introduction In Re: Financial Institutions Approved as Depositories for Fiduciary...

Pa.R.D.E. Rule 222: Mandatory Judicial-Service Reporting, Post-Service Status Election, and Disciplinary Screening for Judges Leaving Office Under Adverse Circumstances

Date: Feb 13, 2026

Pa.R.D.E. Rule 222: Mandatory Judicial-Service Reporting, Post-Service Status Election, and Disciplinary Screening for Judges Leaving Office Under Adverse Circumstances Court: Supreme Court of...

PCRA Timeliness: “Newly Discovered Facts” Must Match the Claim—For Brady, the Predicate Fact Is Suppression (Not Merely a Confession)

Date: Jan 31, 2026

PCRA Timeliness: “Newly Discovered Facts” Must Match the Claim—For Brady, the Predicate Fact Is Suppression (Not Merely a Confession) Introduction Commonwealth v. Brown arises from Jamie M. Brown’s...

Pennsylvania Rule 404(b) After Walker: Abrogation of the “Logical Connection” Test and a Proposed Narrow “Unlinked Plan” Framework

Date: Jan 31, 2026

Pennsylvania Rule 404(b) After Commonwealth v. Walker: Abrogation of the “Logical Connection” Test and a Proposed Narrow “Unlinked Plan” Framework Scope note: The provided text is Justice Dougherty’s...

Abrogation of the “Logical Connection” Test for Pa.R.E. 404(b) “Plan” Evidence and a Forethought-Based Approach to Consolidation

Date: Jan 31, 2026

Abrogation of the “Logical Connection” Test for Pa.R.E. 404(b) “Plan” Evidence and a Forethought-Based Approach to Consolidation Case: Commonwealth v. Walker (Justice Dougherty, Concurring and...

Abrogation of the “Logical Connection” Test Under Pa.R.E. 404(b) and a Narrower Conception of “Plan” in Consolidated Sexual-Assault Trials

Date: Jan 31, 2026

Abrogation of the “Logical Connection” Test Under Pa.R.E. 404(b) and a Narrower Conception of “Plan” in Consolidated Sexual-Assault Trials 1. Introduction Commonwealth v. Walker came to the Supreme...

Creating Municipality’s Continuing Right to Compel Conveyance of Authority Projects Under MAA §§ 5619(a) & 5622(a), Despite Board Recomposition

Date: Jan 22, 2026

Creating Municipality’s Continuing Right to Compel Conveyance of Authority Projects Under MAA §§ 5619(a) & 5622(a), Despite Board Recomposition Commentary on Justice Mundy’s concurring and dissenting...

Orders Compelling Common Law Arbitration and Staying Litigation Are Not Immediately Appealable Collateral Orders in Pennsylvania

Date: Jan 22, 2026

Orders Compelling Common Law Arbitration and Staying Litigation Are Not Immediately Appealable Collateral Orders in Pennsylvania I. Introduction In Chilutti, S. v. Uber; Apl. of Uber, the Supreme...

RETSL Section 607 Permits Pre-Confirmation Equitable Challenges, Including Grossly Inadequate Upset-Sale Price (Dougherty, J., concurring and dissenting)

Date: Jan 22, 2026

RETSL Section 607 Permits Pre-Confirmation Equitable Challenges, Including Grossly Inadequate Upset-Sale Price (Dougherty, J., concurring and dissenting) 1. Introduction Case: In re: Upset Sale, Tax...

MAA §5622(a) Conveyance Power Turns on Present Municipal Power/Control After §5610(a.1) Board Reconstitution

Date: Jan 22, 2026

MAA §5622(a) Conveyance Power Turns on Present Municipal Power/Control After §5610(a.1) Board Reconstitution Case: In re: Chester Water Authority Trust (multiple consolidated appeals) Court: Supreme...