Pennsylvania Case Commentaries

Per Curiam Denial of Allowance of Appeal in Consolidated Toll Brothers Homeowner Cases; Supplemental Record Request Moot; Continued Sealing Granted

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Per Curiam Denial of Allowance of Appeal in Consolidated Toll Brothers Homeowner Cases; Supplemental Record Request Moot; Continued Sealing Granted Court: Supreme Court of Pennsylvania (Eastern...

Allocatur Denial in Consolidated Toll Brothers Homeowner Cases: Supplemental Record Moot; Sealing Continued

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Allocatur Denial in Consolidated Toll Brothers Homeowner Cases: Supplemental Record Moot; Sealing Continued 1. Introduction This Pennsylvania Supreme Court disposition arises from a large set of...

Allocatur Denied in Consolidated Toll Brothers Construction-Defect Appeals; Supplemental Record Motion Moot and Sealing Continued

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Allocatur Denied in Consolidated Toll Brothers Construction-Defect Appeals; Supplemental Record Motion Moot and Sealing Continued Introduction This Pennsylvania Supreme Court disposition arises from...

Allocatur Denial in Consolidated Toll Brothers Home-Defect Appeals: Ancillary Record Motions Become Moot; Sealing May Continue

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Allocatur Denial in Consolidated Toll Brothers Home-Defect Appeals: Ancillary Record Motions Become Moot; Sealing May Continue 1. Introduction This Pennsylvania Supreme Court disposition arises from...

Procedural Rule in the Consolidated “Toll Brothers” Petitions: Denial of Allowance of Appeal, Mootness of a Supplemental Reproduced Record, and Continued Sealing

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Procedural Rule in the Consolidated “Toll Brothers” Petitions: Denial of Allowance of Appeal, Mootness of a Supplemental Reproduced Record, and Continued Sealing 1. Introduction This matter consists...

Denial of Allocatur in Consolidated Toll Brothers Petitions; Mootness of Supplemental Record and Continued Sealing

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Denial of Allocatur in Consolidated Toll Brothers Petitions; Mootness of Supplemental Record and Continued Sealing Court: Supreme Court of Pennsylvania (Eastern District) Date: March 31, 2026...

Allocatur Denial in Consolidated Toll Brothers Appeals: No Merits Precedent; Supplemental Record Moot; Sealing Continued

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Allocatur Denial in Consolidated Toll Brothers Appeals: No Merits Precedent; Supplemental Record Moot; Sealing Continued 1. Introduction This Pennsylvania Supreme Court disposition is a consolidated...

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Clarifies Procedural Effect of Allocatur Denial in Consolidated Toll Brothers Litigation: Supplemental Record Moot; Sealing Continued

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Clarifies Procedural Effect of Allocatur Denial in Consolidated Toll Brothers Litigation: Supplemental Record Moot; Sealing Continued 1. Introduction This Supreme Court of...

Denial of Allowance of Appeal Leaves Superior Court Order Intact; Supplemental Record Moot; Sealing Continued (Toll Brothers Consolidated Petitions)

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Denial of Allowance of Appeal Leaves Superior Court Order Intact; Supplemental Record Moot; Sealing Continued (Toll Brothers Consolidated Petitions) Court: Supreme Court of Pennsylvania (Eastern...

Allocatur Denial Does Not Create Precedent: Per Curiam Refusal to Review Consolidated Toll Brothers Appeals (and Continuation of Sealing)

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Allocatur Denial Does Not Create Precedent: Per Curiam Refusal to Review Consolidated Toll Brothers Appeals (and Continuation of Sealing) 1. Introduction This Supreme Court of Pennsylvania...

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Denial of Allocatur in Consolidated Toll Brothers Appeals; Supplemental Record Request Moot; Sealing Continued

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Denial of Allocatur in Consolidated Toll Brothers Appeals; Supplemental Record Request Moot; Sealing Continued 1. Introduction This matter consists of numerous consolidated...

Denial of Allocatur in Consolidated Toll Brothers Home-Construction Appeals: Superior Court Orders Stand; Sealing Continues

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Denial of Allocatur in Consolidated Toll Brothers Home-Construction Appeals: Superior Court Orders Stand; Sealing Continues 1. Introduction This Supreme Court of Pennsylvania disposition concerns a...

Allocatur Denial Leaves Superior Court Ruling Intact; Supplemental Record Becomes Moot; Sealing Continues (Toll Brothers Consolidated Petitions)

Date: Apr 4, 2026

Allocatur Denial Leaves Superior Court Ruling Intact; Supplemental Record Becomes Moot; Sealing Continues (Toll Brothers Consolidated Petitions) 1. Introduction This matter consists of numerous...

Rejecting a Return to Beauty Hall: Downstream Economic Harm and Burdened Transactions Support Associational Standing (Donohue, J., dissenting)

Date: Mar 28, 2026

Rejecting a Return to Beauty Hall: Downstream Economic Harm and Burdened Transactions Support Associational Standing (Donohue, J., dissenting) Case: D.M. and the Pennsylvania Cannabis Coalition v....

Child Support Civil Contempt: Enforcing Rule 1910.25 Financial Disclosures and Requiring Ability-to-Pay Proof Beyond a Reasonable Doubt for Coercive Imprisonment

Date: Mar 28, 2026

Child Support Civil Contempt: Enforcing Rule 1910.25 Financial Disclosures and Requiring Ability-to-Pay Proof Beyond a Reasonable Doubt for Coercive Imprisonment I. Introduction Bredbenner v. Hall,...

Commonwealth v. Belgrave (Pa. 2026): Reversible Error When Prosecutor Calls a Known Recalcitrant Witness—Even Without an Express Fifth Amendment Invocation Before the Jury

Date: Mar 28, 2026

Reversible Error When Prosecutor Calls a Known Recalcitrant Witness—Even Without an Express Fifth Amendment Invocation Before the Jury Introduction In Commonwealth v. Belgrave (Pa. Mar. 26, 2026),...

Strickland Prejudice in Pennsylvania Capital Sentencing: When Failed Impeachment Undermines Proof of a Single, Morally Potent Aggravator

Date: Mar 28, 2026

Strickland Prejudice in Pennsylvania Capital Sentencing: When Failed Impeachment Undermines Proof of a Single, Morally Potent Aggravator Case: Commonwealth v. Johnson (Pa. Supreme Court, Eastern...

Pennsylvania Constitution Bars Per Se Life-Without-Parole for Felony Murder Absent a Culpability Assessment

Date: Mar 28, 2026

Pennsylvania Constitution Bars Per Se Life-Without-Parole for Felony Murder Absent a Culpability Assessment Introduction Commonwealth v. Lee arises from a 2014 home invasion in which Appellant Derek...

Post-Sentence SORNA II (Subchapter I) Constitutional Challenges Are Civil Actions Against PSP in Commonwealth Court—Not PCRA or Habeas in Common Pleas

Date: Mar 28, 2026

Post-Sentence SORNA II (Subchapter I) Constitutional Challenges Are Civil Actions Against PSP in Commonwealth Court—Not PCRA or Habeas in Common Pleas 1. Introduction Commonwealth, Aplt. v. Arnett...

Section 311 Notice Does Not Require Sole Proprietors to Notify Insurers; Section 103 Controls and Section 401 Is Article IV–Limited

Date: Mar 28, 2026

Section 311 Notice Does Not Require Sole Proprietors to Notify Insurers; Section 103 Controls and Section 401 Is Article IV–Limited Case: Erie Insurance Property & Casualty Company v. David Heater...