New Hampshire Case Commentaries

Probate Jurisdiction Over Express-Trust Fiduciary-Duty Counterclaims Despite Foreign Choice-of-Law (and Preservation of Fee-Remedy Challenges)

Date: Jul 9, 2026

Probate Jurisdiction Over Express-Trust Fiduciary-Duty Counterclaims Despite Foreign Choice-of-Law (and Preservation of Fee-Remedy Challenges) 1. Introduction Moffat v. Srebro, 2026 N.H. 25 (N.H....

Unsettled-Law Defeats Plain Error and Voluntary Refusal of Transport Permits Sentencing in Absentia (N.H.)

Date: Jun 18, 2026

Unsettled-Law Defeats Plain Error and Voluntary Refusal of Transport Permits Sentencing in Absentia I. Introduction In State of New Hampshire v. Dale E. Holloway, Jr. (N.H. June 17, 2026), the...

State v. Montgomery (2026 N.H. 24): Severance Required Where Joinder Creates Propensity-Risk, and “Intrinsic” Evidence Has Narrow Limits

Date: Jun 12, 2026

State v. Montgomery (2026 N.H. 24): Severance Required Where Joinder Creates Propensity-Risk, and “Intrinsic” Evidence Has Narrow Limits Introduction In State v. Montgomery, 2026 N.H. 24 (N.H. June...

Adult Guardianship Removal in New Hampshire: RSA 464-A:39 Requires Only a “Best Interests” Showing—Not “Cause”

Date: Jun 11, 2026

Adult Guardianship Removal in New Hampshire: RSA 464-A:39 Requires Only a “Best Interests” Showing—Not “Cause” Case: In re Guardianship of T.M., 2026 N.H. 23 (N.H. June 10, 2026) Court: Supreme Court...

Mutual Conduct Can Waive Written Change-Order Clauses (Even with “No-Waiver-Except-Writing” Language) and Permit Equitable Recovery for Extra-Contract Work

Date: Jun 4, 2026

Mutual Conduct Can Waive Written Change-Order Clauses (Even with “No-Waiver-Except-Writing” Language) and Permit Equitable Recovery for Extra-Contract Work 1. Introduction RJH Builders, LLC v. Robert...

State v. Cherry (2026 N.H. 22): Firearms as “Tools of the Drug Trade” Require a Case-Specific Nexus; Joinder’s “Best Interests of Justice” Must Be Charge-Specific

Date: Jun 3, 2026

State v. Cherry (2026 N.H. 22): Firearms as “Tools of the Drug Trade” Require a Case-Specific Nexus; Joinder’s “Best Interests of Justice” Must Be Charge-Specific 1. Introduction In State v. Cherry,...

Successive RSA 173-B Protection Orders: New Post-Adjudication Abuse Defeats Claim Preclusion and Opens the Door to Prior Acts as Pattern Evidence

Date: Jun 1, 2026

Successive RSA 173-B Protection Orders: New Post-Adjudication Abuse Defeats Claim Preclusion and Opens the Door to Prior Acts as Pattern Evidence Introduction In J.M. v. D.E. (Supreme Court of New...

Back Pay Means Fixed “Salary Loss” Only: No Overtime Awards Under RSA 273-D:3, V

Date: May 20, 2026

Back Pay Means Fixed “Salary Loss” Only: No Overtime Awards Under RSA 273-D:3, V Case: Appeal of N.H. Div. of State Police, 2026 N.H. 21 (N.H. May 15, 2026) Tribunal Below: New Hampshire Personnel...

No Per Se Piercing of Medical/Therapy Privileges for RSA 135:17-a, V Involuntary-Admission Evaluations; “Standard of Care” Alone Is Not a Compelling Justification

Date: May 19, 2026

No Per Se Piercing of Medical/Therapy Privileges for RSA 135:17-a, V Involuntary-Admission Evaluations; “Standard of Care” Alone Is Not a Compelling Justification 1. Introduction State of New...

DHHS Appeals Unit Has Jurisdiction Over Licensed Medicaid Provider Challenges to MCO Recoupment Decisions

Date: May 1, 2026

DHHS Appeals Unit Has Jurisdiction Over Licensed Medicaid Provider Challenges to MCO Recoupment Decisions Introduction In Petition of Metro Treatment of N.H., 2026 N.H. 20, the New Hampshire Supreme...

Continuance Discretion and Proof of Fear in Civil Stalking Orders Under RSA 633:3-a

Date: Apr 30, 2026

Continuance Discretion and Proof of Fear in Civil Stalking Orders Under RSA 633:3-a 1. Introduction In C.A. v. D.N. (No. 2025-0579) and D.W. v. D.N. (No. 2025-0580), the Supreme Court of New...

Continuance Discretion and Evidentiary Sufficiency in Civil Stalking Protective Orders Under RSA 633:3-a

Date: Apr 29, 2026

Continuance Discretion and Evidentiary Sufficiency in Civil Stalking Protective Orders Under RSA 633:3-a Court: Supreme Court of New Hampshire Date: April 28, 2026 Cases: Case No. 2025-0579, C.A. v....

Insurer Liquidation Act Governs Co-Insurer Contribution: Contribution Measured by Allowed Claim (Settlement Amount), Not Liquidation Distributions

Date: Apr 28, 2026

Insurer Liquidation Act Governs Co-Insurer Contribution: Contribution Measured by Allowed Claim (Settlement Amount), Not Liquidation Distributions 1. Introduction Case: In the Matter of Liquidation...

Mandatory Dismissal Means No Reinstatement: RSA 135:17-a, IV Limits Trial-Court Authority After a 12-Month Non-Restoration Finding

Date: Apr 27, 2026

Mandatory Dismissal Means No Reinstatement: RSA 135:17-a, IV Limits Trial-Court Authority After a 12-Month Non-Restoration Finding I. Introduction In State v. Freese, 2026 N.H. 18, the Supreme Court...

Certificates of Rental Occupancy Can Establish a Lawful Preexisting STR Use When the Property Does Not Meet the Ordinance Definition of an ADU

Date: Apr 27, 2026

Certificates of Rental Occupancy Can Establish a Lawful Preexisting STR Use When the Property Does Not Meet the Ordinance Definition of an ADU 1. Introduction In Donald McGowan & a. v. Town of...

UIFSA Long-Arm Proceedings Are “One-State” Cases: RSA 546-B:31 Does Not Bar New Hampshire Support Orders When Personal Jurisdiction Exists

Date: Apr 24, 2026

UIFSA Long-Arm Proceedings Are “One-State” Cases: RSA 546-B:31 Does Not Bar New Hampshire Support Orders When Personal Jurisdiction Exists Case: In the Matter of Stansfield & Patti, 2026 N.H. 17...

Blanket Right-to-Know Denials Require Fee Awards When Non-Exempt Material Is Obvious

Date: Apr 17, 2026

Blanket Right-to-Know Denials Require Fee Awards When Non-Exempt Material Is Obvious Case: Town of Hanover v. Valley News, 2026 N.H. 16 Court: Supreme Court of New Hampshire Date: April 15, 2026 1....

Duty Limits on Construction Sites: No Liability for General Contractors, Subcontractors, or Landowners Absent Creation/Control of the Injury-Causing Danger

Date: Apr 16, 2026

Duty Limits on Construction Sites: No Liability for General Contractors, Subcontractors, or Landowners Absent Creation/Control of the Injury-Causing Danger 1. Introduction In Nelson Salazar Orellana...

State v. Rosen: Rule 404(b) Limits on Prior Double‑Voting History and Admissibility of Third‑Party Confession to the Charged Election (with Richards Hearing Requirement)

Date: Apr 16, 2026

State v. Rosen: Rule 404(b) Limits on Prior Double‑Voting History and Admissibility of Third‑Party Confession to the Charged Election (with Richards Hearing Requirement) 1. Introduction In State v....

Implicit “Personal Risk” Finding May Sustain Denial of Workers’ Compensation Where CAB Credits Expert that Non-Work Cause Was Sole Cause of Death

Date: Apr 16, 2026

Implicit “Personal Risk” Finding May Sustain Denial of Workers’ Compensation Where CAB Credits Expert that Non-Work Cause Was Sole Cause of Death Introduction In Appeal of Estate of Matthew Kelley...