Montana Case Commentaries

Noland v. State and the Montana PSC: Standing, LLC Injury, and Pre‑Enforcement Facial Challenges to Economic Regulation

Date: Dec 27, 2025

Noland v. State and the Montana PSC: Standing, LLC Injury, and Pre‑Enforcement Facial Challenges to Economic Regulation I. Introduction Noland v. State, 2025 MT 294, is a significant Montana Supreme...

Strategic Waiver, Plain Error, and Juror Bias in Montana: Commentary on State v. Soapes, 2025 MT 296

Date: Dec 27, 2025

Strategic Waiver, Plain Error, and Juror Bias in Montana: Commentary on State v. Soapes, 2025 MT 296 I. Introduction In State v. Soapes, 2025 MT 296, the Montana Supreme Court affirmed the conviction...

Deferential Appellate Review of Restitution Findings in Nonprecedential Memorandum Decisions: Commentary on State v. O’Connell (2025 MT 298N)

Date: Dec 27, 2025

Deferential Appellate Review of Restitution Findings in Nonprecedential Memorandum Decisions: Commentary on State v. O’Connell, 2025 MT 298N I. Introduction State v. O’Connell, 2025 MT 298N (DA...

Revocation Courts Cannot Expand Original Sentences by Making Them Consecutive to Later-Imposed Terms: Commentary on M. LaForge v. D. Godfrey (Mont. 2025)

Date: Dec 21, 2025

Revocation Courts Cannot Expand Original Sentences by Making Them Consecutive to Later-Imposed Terms: Commentary on M. LaForge v. D. Godfrey (Mont. 2025) 1. Introduction This commentary analyzes the...

State v. Andersen and the Presumption of Prejudice from Court-Staff Comments on Evidence During Jury Deliberations

Date: Dec 19, 2025

State v. Andersen and the Presumption of Prejudice from Court-Staff Comments on Evidence During Jury Deliberations I. Introduction In State v. Andersen, 2025 MT 293, the Montana Supreme Court...

Reaffirming Strict Duties of Diligence, Communication, and Practice Management in Attorney Discipline: Commentary on Matter of Michael P. Sinks

Date: Dec 17, 2025

Reaffirming Strict Duties of Diligence, Communication, and Practice Management in Attorney Discipline Commentary on Matter of Michael P. Sinks, Supreme Court of Montana (Dec. 16, 2025) 1....

Equitable Modification of Property Awards to Counter Post‑Judgment Asset Manipulation: Commentary on In re Marriage of Steinbeisser, 2025 MT 289

Date: Dec 17, 2025

Equitable Modification of Property Awards to Counter Post‑Judgment Asset Manipulation: Commentary on In re Marriage of Steinbeisser, 2025 MT 289 I. Introduction The Montana Supreme Court’s decision...

Voluntary Absence as Waiver: State v. McKnight and the Limits of Due Diligence in Montana Felony Trials

Date: Dec 17, 2025

Voluntary Absence as Waiver: State v. McKnight and the Limits of Due Diligence in Montana Felony Trials I. Introduction In State v. McKnight, 2025 MT 288, the Montana Supreme Court addressed a...

State v. Lambert: Mandatory Counsel at Probation Revocation Dispositional Hearings and Structural Error for Uncounseled Sentencing

Date: Dec 17, 2025

State v. Lambert: Mandatory Counsel at Probation Revocation Dispositional Hearings and Structural Error for Uncounseled Sentencing I. Introduction In State v. Lambert, 2025 MT 286, the Montana...

Conceding a Jury Question as a Judicial Admission: New Limits on Rule 59 New-Trial Motions in Shahood v. City and County of Butte-Silver Bow

Date: Dec 17, 2025

Conceding a Jury Question as a Judicial Admission: New Limits on Rule 59 New-Trial Motions in Shahood v. City and County of Butte-Silver Bow I. Introduction In Shahood v. City and County of...

MFIJ v. Knudsen: Requiring a Substantive Written Determination Before the Attorney General May Rewrite Montana Ballot Statements

Date: Dec 13, 2025

MFIJ v. Knudsen: Requiring a Substantive Written Determination Before the Attorney General May Rewrite Montana Ballot Statements I. Introduction In Montanans for Fair and Impartial Judges & Montanans...

State v. Smith: Justifiable Use of Force Does Not Bar a Mitigated Deliberate Homicide Lesser-Included Instruction

Date: Dec 11, 2025

State v. Smith: Justifiable Use of Force Does Not Bar a Mitigated Deliberate Homicide Lesser-Included Instruction I. Introduction In State v. Smith, 2025 MT 281, the Montana Supreme Court affirmed...

Reaffirming Particularized Suspicion to Expand Speeding Stops into DUI Investigations: Commentary on State v. Trimble (Mont. 2025)

Date: Dec 11, 2025

Reaffirming Particularized Suspicion to Expand Speeding Stops into DUI Investigations: Commentary on State v. Trimble (Mont. 2025) I. Introduction The Montana Supreme Court’s memorandum decision in...

State v. Mullendore: Clarifying Child-Restraint Negligence, Intervening Causes, Expert Testimony, and Lost-Wage Restitution in Montana Homicide Cases

Date: Dec 11, 2025

State v. Mullendore: Clarifying Child-Restraint Negligence, Intervening Causes, Expert Testimony, and Lost-Wage Restitution in Montana Homicide Cases I. Introduction In State v. Mullendore, 2025 MT...

Due Process, Discovery, and Use of Withdrawn Violations in Montana Probation Revocations: Commentary on State v. Pettit

Date: Dec 11, 2025

Due Process, Discovery, and Use of Withdrawn Violations in Montana Probation Revocations: Commentary on State v. Pettit I. Introduction The Montana Supreme Court’s memorandum decision in State v....

Circumstantial Corroboration of Prior Inconsistent Statements in Child Sex Offense Cases: Commentary on State v. French, 2025 MT 280

Date: Dec 4, 2025

Circumstantial Corroboration of Prior Inconsistent Statements in Child Sex Offense Cases: Commentary on State v. French, 2025 MT 280 I. Introduction In State v. French, 2025 MT 280, the Montana...

Medicaid Estate Recovery Beyond Probate Deadlines: Independent Heir Actions Under § 53‑6‑167(2), MCA – Commentary on DPHHS v. Johnson

Date: Dec 4, 2025

Medicaid Estate Recovery Beyond Probate Deadlines: Independent Heir Actions Under § 53‑6‑167(2), MCA I. Introduction The Montana Supreme Court’s decision in Montana Department of Public Health and...

Concrete, Imminent Harm and the SAMS Safety Threshold: The Montana Supreme Court Raises the Bar for Youth-in-Need-of-Care Adjudications in Matter of J.D.

Date: Dec 4, 2025

Concrete, Imminent Harm and the SAMS Safety Threshold: The Montana Supreme Court Raises the Bar for Youth-in-Need-of-Care Adjudications in Matter of J.D. I. Introduction In Matter of J.D., 2025 MT...

Time-Limited Contractual Rights to Post-Divorce Pet Custody and the Appealability of Contempt Orders in Montana: Commentary on In re Marriage of Burgard & Jacobsen

Date: Dec 4, 2025

Time-Limited Contractual Rights to Post-Divorce Pet Custody and the Appealability of Contempt Orders in Montana: Commentary on In re Marriage of Burgard & Jacobsen I. Introduction The Montana Supreme...

State v. Davisson: No Automatic Reversal for Erroneous “Knowingly” Instructions in SIWOC Prosecutions

Date: Dec 4, 2025

State v. Davisson: No Automatic Reversal for Erroneous “Knowingly” Instructions in SIWOC Prosecutions I. Introduction In State v. J. Davisson, 2025 MT 275, the Supreme Court of Montana confronted a...