State v. Carlin and the Reaffirmation of Montana’s Standards on Substitution of Counsel After a Guilty Plea I. Introduction The decision in State v. Kristoffer Charles Carlin, 2025 MT 278N (DA...
Collateral Estoppel from Federal § 2255 Proceedings to State Legal Malpractice Actions: Commentary on M. Benton v. S. Babcock, 2025 MT 277 I. Introduction In M. Benton v. S. Babcock, 2025 MT 277, the...
Mandatory Administrator Planning and Structural Reforms in Montana’s Lawyer Disciplinary System Commentary on the Supreme Court of Montana’s 2025 Order Inviting Comment on Proposed Amendments to the...
Barbier v. Burns: Dual Amendment Pathways in LLC Operating Agreements and Limits on Hybrid Witness Compensation under Montana Rule 45 I. Introduction Barbier v. Burns, 2025 MT ___, is a significant...
No Parental Standing to Assert a Child’s Ineffective-Assistance Claim in Termination Proceedings: Commentary on Matter of C.M.B., 2025 MT 272 (Mont.) I. Introduction The Montana Supreme Court’s...
No Parental Standing to Challenge a Child’s Counsel in Termination Proceedings: A Commentary on Matter of C.M.B., 2025 MT 272 I. Introduction In Matter of C.M.B., 2025 MT 272, the Montana Supreme...
Mandatory Good‑Faith View Consideration in HOA Covenants and Merger of Preliminary Injunction Orders Commentary on Waddell v. Studer, 2025 MT 269 (Mont. Sup. Ct.) Court: Supreme Court of Montana...
Parental Rehabilitation as a “Change in Circumstances” and the Mandatory Hearing Requirement in Montana Parenting Plan Modifications Commentary on In re the Parenting of A.M.B.-B., 2025 MT 270 (Mont....
Reaffirming Privilege for Parole-Related Communications in Montana Defamation Law: Commentary on Sliwinski v. Rhodes, 2025 MT 273N I. Introduction In Sliwinski v. Rhodes, 2025 MT 273N (DA 25-0385),...
Plain Error, Prosecutorial “Belief” Language, and Ineffective Assistance: Commentary on State v. Lowry (Mont. 2025) 1. Introduction This commentary examines the Montana Supreme Court’s memorandum...
Mere Presence Is Not Corroboration: State v. Matt and Montana’s Strict Accomplice-Testimony Rule I. Introduction In State v. Matt, 2025 MT 264, the Montana Supreme Court reversed a drug-possession...
Zimmermann v. Wardle (Mont. 2025): The Consequences of Failing to Provide a Certified Transcript in Protection-Order Appeals I. Introduction Zimmermann v. Wardle, 2025 MT 266N (DA 25-0083), is a...
No Final Disclosures, No Set-Aside: Montana Supreme Court Clarifies § 40-4-253(5), MCA Requires Perjury in a Final Declaration and Sanctions Vexatious Appeals Introduction In In re the Marriage of...
When Courts Permit Video Appearance, They Must Clarify Limits Upfront: Mid‑Trial Denial of Defendant’s Video Testimony Is Abuse of Discretion; Accountability Proven Across Closely‑Linked Transactions...
Estate of Damjanovich: Holographic Will Valid Only to Appoint Personal Representative; No Power of Appointment Without Transfer and Identifiable Appointees under § 72‑7‑201, MCA Introduction In...
Mandatory Cross-Examination at Montana Protection-Order Hearings and Appellate Remand on Inadequate Records: Commentary on Hennon v. Weber, 2025 MT 260 Introduction In Hennon v. Weber, 2025 MT 260,...
Nonprecedential Affirmance: Applying Law-of-the-Case and Best-Interests Standards to Modify a Third-Party Parenting Plan in Montana Introduction In Parenting of L.M.A.R. & N.R.R. (DA 25-0305), the...
Deferred Prosecution Agreements Cannot Be Incorporated into Plea Agreements under Montana Law Commentary on State v. Pein, 2025 MT 258 (Mont. Nov. 12, 2025) Introduction In State v. Pein, the Supreme...
Pierce: Montana Supreme Court Reaffirms Conduct‑Based “Knowingly” for SIWOC and Clarifies Limits on Alcohol-Use Evidence Introduction In State v. D. Pierce, 2025 MT 257 (Supreme Court of Montana,...
State v. Prado: Harmless-Error Review for Redacted Jail-Call Context Statements and Strict Limits on Plain-Error Claims of “Credibility-Boosting” Background Testimony Introduction In State v. Prado,...