Montana Case Commentaries

Right to Peremptory Substitution of District Judge in De Novo Appeals from Non-Record Justice Courts: French v. Twentieth Judicial District Court (Mont. 2025)

Date: Nov 7, 2025

Right to Peremptory Substitution of District Judge in De Novo Appeals from Non-Record Justice Courts Commentary on French v. Twentieth Judicial District Court, 2025 MT 254 (OP 25-0642) Introduction...

Comparative Negligence in Jail-Custody Cases: Estate of Mabee v. Wheatland County Confirms “Special Circumstances” as the Exception

Date: Nov 7, 2025

Comparative Negligence in Jail-Custody Cases: Estate of Mabee v. Wheatland County Confirms “Special Circumstances” as the Exception Introduction In Estate of Mabee v. Wheatland County, 2025 MT 252,...

“Illusion of Choice” and Strict Compliance in Montana Civil Commitments: No Waiver of the Five‑Day Hearing or Qualified Evaluation Requirements Absent Knowing, Voluntary Consent (Matter of J.L.O.)

Date: Nov 7, 2025

“Illusion of Choice” and Strict Compliance in Montana Civil Commitments: No Waiver of the Five‑Day Hearing or Qualified Evaluation Requirements Absent Knowing, Voluntary Consent Introduction In...

Broad Titles, Liberal Construction: “Vaccination Status” Encompasses EUA/Trial‑Vaccine Mandate Bans Under Montana’s Article V, § 11(3)

Date: Nov 7, 2025

Broad Titles, Liberal Construction: “Vaccination Status” Encompasses EUA/Trial‑Vaccine Mandate Bans Under Montana’s Article V, § 11(3) Introduction In Netzer, Krautter & Brown, P.C. and Donald L....

Experts Are Not Automatically Exempt from Sequestration; Presumption of Vindictiveness Bars Increased Sentences Based on Appeal or Lack of Remorse — Commentary on State v. Grimshaw, 2025 MT 250

Date: Nov 7, 2025

Experts Are Not Automatically Exempt from Sequestration; Presumption of Vindictiveness Bars Increased Sentences Based on Appeal or Lack of Remorse — Commentary on State v. Grimshaw, 2025 MT 250 Case:...

Resentencing Required When a District Court Exceeds the Statutory Maximum—Even with a Fully Suspended Term (State v. S. Foster, 2025 MT 255N)

Date: Nov 7, 2025

Resentencing Required When a District Court Exceeds the Statutory Maximum—Even with a Fully Suspended Term (State v. S. Foster, 2025 MT 255N) Court: Supreme Court of Montana Date: November 4, 2025...

State v. Ellis: Open-Driveway Encounters—No Search When Evidence Is Voluntarily Produced, and Miranda Not Required During Noncustodial Driveway Questioning

Date: Nov 7, 2025

State v. Ellis: Open-Driveway Encounters—No Search When Evidence Is Voluntarily Produced, and Miranda Not Required During Noncustodial Driveway Questioning Introduction In State v. Z. Ellis, 2025 MT...

Enforcing Civility and Fitness: The ODC’s Amended Disciplinary Complaint Against Mark E. Anderson Under MRPC 3.1, 3.5, and 8.4

Date: Nov 1, 2025

Enforcing Civility and Fitness: The ODC’s Amended Disciplinary Complaint Against Mark E. Anderson Under MRPC 3.1, 3.5, and 8.4 Important procedural note: Although the source is labeled as an...

Initial Arraignment Is the Sole Trigger for Automatic Judicial Substitution in Montana Criminal Cases

Date: Oct 31, 2025

Initial Arraignment Is the Sole Trigger for Automatic Judicial Substitution in Montana Criminal Cases Introduction In Caye v. Twentieth Judicial District Court (2025 MT 246), the Supreme Court of...

Basque (Mont. 2025): Denial of Venue Change in Parenting-Plan Enforcement Under Ends-of-Justice and Continuing Jurisdiction (Noncitable)

Date: Oct 31, 2025

Basque (Mont. 2025): Denial of Venue Change in Parenting-Plan Enforcement Under Ends-of-Justice and Continuing Jurisdiction (Noncitable) Introduction In In re the Marriage of Basque, 2025 MT 247N,...

No Lesser-Included: Montana High Court Holds Destruction of a Communication Device Is Not a Lesser-Included Offense of Evidence Tampering (State v. Carlson, 2025 MT 245)

Date: Oct 31, 2025

No Lesser-Included: Destruction of a Communication Device Is Not a Lesser-Included Offense of Evidence Tampering Case: State v. Taylor Jean Carlson, 2025 MT 245 (Mont. Oct. 28, 2025) Court: Supreme...

No Final Opinion Yet: The Disciplinary Case Against Mark E. Anderson Signals Strict Enforcement of MRPC 3.1, 3.5, and 8.4 for Abusive Litigation Conduct

Date: Oct 28, 2025

No Final Opinion Yet: The Disciplinary Case Against Mark E. Anderson Signals Strict Enforcement of MRPC 3.1, 3.5, and 8.4 for Abusive Litigation Conduct Introduction This commentary examines the...

When Parties Fail to Provide Valuation Evidence, a District Court May Order Appraisal or Sale and Still Equitably Divide the Estate: Nonprecedential Affirmance in Marriage of Schafer

Date: Oct 22, 2025

When Parties Fail to Provide Valuation Evidence, a District Court May Order Appraisal or Sale and Still Equitably Divide the Estate: Nonprecedential Affirmance in Marriage of Schafer Court: Supreme...

No Waiver Without a Record: Montana Supreme Court Reaffirms and Clarifies § 53‑21‑119(1), MCA, Requirements for Waiver in Involuntary Commitment Proceedings

Date: Oct 22, 2025

No Waiver Without a Record: Montana Supreme Court Reaffirms and Clarifies § 53‑21‑119(1), MCA, Requirements for Waiver in Involuntary Commitment Proceedings Introduction In Matter of P.G.J., 2025 MT...

No Implied Easements from Settlement Silence: Four‑Corners Enforcement of MOUs, Strict Limits on Easement “Maintenance,” and Fees for Multiplying Proceedings (Schubert v. Toepp, 2025 MT 239)

Date: Oct 22, 2025

No Implied Easements from Settlement Silence: Four‑Corners Enforcement of MOUs, Strict Limits on Easement “Maintenance,” and Fees for Multiplying Proceedings (Schubert v. Toepp, 2025 MT 239)...

State v. Spangler (2025 MT 244N): Nonprecedential Reaffirmation that Single-Witness Testimony Can Sustain Unlawful Restraint; Remand to Correct Judgment to Attempted Assault with a Weapon

Date: Oct 22, 2025

State v. Spangler (2025 MT 244N): Nonprecedential Reaffirmation that Single-Witness Testimony Can Sustain Unlawful Restraint; Remand to Correct Judgment to Attempted Assault with a Weapon...

State v. Burrington: Medically Required Functional Restrictions Can Constitute “Protracted Impairment” for Serious Bodily Injury; Self-Defense May Be Asserted While Disputing the Injury Element

Date: Oct 22, 2025

State v. Burrington: Medically Required Functional Restrictions Can Constitute “Protracted Impairment” for Serious Bodily Injury; Self-Defense May Be Asserted While Disputing the Injury Element...

Privilege Follows the Reporting: Montana High Court Holds Place of Newsgathering Governs Media-Subpoena Privileges

Date: Oct 17, 2025

Privilege Follows the Reporting: Montana High Court Holds Place of Newsgathering Governs Media-Subpoena Privileges Introduction In EQT CHAP LLC v. Environmental Health Sciences, 2025 MT 237, the...

No Stalking Required: Assault-Based Orders of Protection and Deference to Trial Courts Under Montana’s Abuse-of-Discretion Review

Date: Oct 16, 2025

No Stalking Required: Assault-Based Orders of Protection and Deference to Trial Courts Under Montana’s Abuse-of-Discretion Review Note: This is a memorandum opinion designated noncitable under...

Employment-Based Trustee Conflicts Presumed and Beneficiary Access to Partner Financials: The Montana Supreme Court’s Framework in Matter of the Potter Exemption Trust

Date: Oct 16, 2025

Employment-Based Trustee Conflicts Presumed and Beneficiary Access to Partner Financials: The Montana Supreme Court’s Framework in Matter of the Potter Exemption Trust Introduction In Matter of the...