Montana Case Commentaries

State v. Ramirez: When “Mere Presence” and Accomplice-Caution Jury Instructions Are Properly Denied

Date: Oct 16, 2025

State v. Ramirez: When “Mere Presence” and Accomplice-Caution Jury Instructions Are Properly Denied Introduction In State v. E. Ramirez, 2025 MT 232, the Supreme Court of Montana affirmed the...

Single-Count Charging of Felony Theft by Common Scheme Permissible; Rowe Distinguished and Limited to Non-Cognizable “Common Scheme” Charges

Date: Oct 16, 2025

Single-Count Charging of Felony Theft by Common Scheme Permissible; Rowe Distinguished and Limited to Non-Cognizable “Common Scheme” Charges Introduction In State v. Wolfchild, 2025 MT 234N, the...

Nonprecedential Reaffirmation: Absolute Prosecutorial Immunity and Monell’s Policy-or-Custom Requirement Bar Malicious Prosecution and False Arrest Claims

Date: Oct 16, 2025

Nonprecedential Reaffirmation: Absolute Prosecutorial Immunity and Monell’s Policy-or-Custom Requirement Bar Malicious Prosecution and False Arrest Claims Introduction In Stone v. City of Livingston,...

Nonprecedential Clarifications on Civil Protective Orders: Counterman’s Criminal Mens Rea Is Inapplicable; Electronic, Sexualized Emails Can Constitute a “Course of Conduct” for Montana Stalking OOPs

Date: Oct 16, 2025

Nonprecedential Clarifications on Civil Protective Orders: Counterman’s Criminal Mens Rea Is Inapplicable; Electronic, Sexualized Emails Can Constitute a “Course of Conduct” for Montana Stalking OOPs...

Partition in Kind Prevails: Montana Supreme Court Reaffirms Authority to Modify Referees’ Plans and Impose Reciprocal Easements under the UPHPA

Date: Oct 10, 2025

Partition in Kind Prevails: Montana Supreme Court Reaffirms Authority to Modify Referees’ Plans and Impose Reciprocal Easements under the UPHPA Introduction In Barce v. Filler (Supreme Court of...

“Public Repute” Means Community, Not Bureaucracy: Montana Supreme Court Reaffirms Common‑Law Marriage Even Where Partners Marked “Single” on Official Forms

Date: Oct 10, 2025

“Public Repute” Means Community, Not Bureaucracy: Montana Supreme Court Reaffirms Common‑Law Marriage Even Where Partners Marked “Single” on Official Forms Introduction In Estate of Hudson, 2025 MT...

No Herculean Efforts Required: Montana Supreme Court Reaffirms Fact-Dependent “Reasonable Efforts” in Interstate Child Welfare Cases

Date: Oct 10, 2025

No Herculean Efforts Required: Montana Supreme Court Reaffirms Fact-Dependent “Reasonable Efforts” in Interstate Child Welfare Cases Introduction In Matter of B.B.-R., YINC (Supreme Court of Montana,...

Reasonable Efforts Are Fact-Dependent and Need Not Be Herculean; ICPC Omission Alone Does Not Defeat Reunification Efforts: Montana Supreme Court Affirms Termination of Parental Rights in Matter of K.B. & B.B.-R. (Noncitable)

Date: Oct 10, 2025

Reasonable Efforts Are Fact-Dependent and Need Not Be Herculean; ICPC Omission Alone Does Not Defeat Reunification Efforts: Montana Supreme Court Affirms Termination of Parental Rights in Matter of...

Reaffirmation That Guardianship Need Not Be Considered Once Statutory Grounds for Termination Are Met, and That the 15-of-22-Month Presumption Governs Best-Interest Analysis — Matter of P.M.L.O. (Mont. 2025)

Date: Oct 10, 2025

Reaffirmation That Guardianship Need Not Be Considered Once Statutory Grounds for Termination Are Met, and That the 15-of-22-Month Presumption Governs Best-Interest Analysis — Matter of P.M.L.O....

Montana Supreme Court Bars Compelled Two‑Way Video Appearance After Valid Waiver; Successive Commitment Petitions Not Barred by Preclusion — Matter of T.W. (2025 MT 225)

Date: Oct 10, 2025

Montana Supreme Court Bars Compelled Two‑Way Video Appearance After Valid Waiver; Successive Commitment Petitions Not Barred by Preclusion — Matter of T.W. (2025 MT 225) Introduction In Matter of...

Nonprecedential Affirmance of HRC Retaliation Dismissals: Rebutted Presumption and Harmless Procedural Error Under MAPA (Vaccaro v. Three Forks Area Ambulance Service)

Date: Oct 10, 2025

Nonprecedential Affirmance of HRC Retaliation Dismissals: Rebutted Presumption and Harmless Procedural Error Under MAPA Case: Vaccaro v. Three Forks Area Ambulance Service, 2025 MT 230N (Mont. Oct....

Post-Habeas Removal of Illegal Restitution Is Not a Resentencing: The Oral–Written Sentence Rule Does Not Apply — Woods v. Wead (Mont. 2025)

Date: Oct 10, 2025

Post-Habeas Removal of Illegal Restitution Is Not a Resentencing: The Oral–Written Sentence Rule Does Not Apply — Woods v. Wead (Mont. 2025) Introduction In Woods v. Wead (Mont. Oct. 7, 2025), the...

Montana Supreme Court Authorizes Community Justice Workers to Provide Limited Legal Services in Justice and City Courts

Date: Oct 2, 2025

Montana Supreme Court Authorizes Community Justice Workers to Provide Limited Legal Services in Justice and City Courts Introduction In administrative docket AF 11-0765, the Supreme Court of Montana...

Plain-View Hazards on Icy Roads: Comparative Negligence for the Jury; No Default Spoliation for Pre‑Notice Telematics Loss

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Plain-View Hazards on Icy Roads: Comparative Negligence for the Jury; No Default Spoliation for Pre‑Notice Telematics Loss Introduction In Fahrnow v. E-5 Oilfield Services, 2025 MT 220, the Montana...

Richeson and the Limits of Plain-Error Review: Highlighting Unrebutted Expert Evidence Is Not Burden Shifting; Record‑Silent IAC Claims Belong in Postconviction Proceedings

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Richeson and the Limits of Plain-Error Review: Highlighting Unrebutted Expert Evidence Is Not Burden Shifting; Record‑Silent IAC Claims Belong in Postconviction Proceedings Case: State v. L....

Established Facts, Not Volume: Jackson v. State Clarifies Montana’s § 46‑21‑104(1)(c) Threshold for Ineffective-Assistance Postconviction Petitions and Expert-Witness Claims

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Established Facts, Not Volume: Jackson v. State Clarifies Montana’s § 46‑21‑104(1)(c) Threshold for Ineffective-Assistance Postconviction Petitions and Expert-Witness Claims Court: Supreme Court of...

Street-Time Credit Cannot Be Denied for Restitution Nonpayment Without a DOC-Set Payment Schedule and Specific, Recorded Violations: State v. Powell (2025 MT 218)

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Street-Time Credit Cannot Be Denied for Restitution Nonpayment Without a DOC-Set Payment Schedule and Specific, Recorded Violations Commentary on State v. Powell, 2025 MT 218 (Mont. Sept. 30, 2025)...

Reaffirming Montana’s Ariegwe Speedy‑Trial Framework: Defendant‑Caused Continuances Control the Balance; Evidence‑Anchored “Guilt” Statements in Closing Are Not Plain Error

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Reaffirming Montana’s Ariegwe Speedy‑Trial Framework: Defendant‑Caused Continuances Control the Balance; Evidence‑Anchored “Guilt” Statements in Closing Are Not Plain Error Introduction This...

No Second Bite at the Apple under Montana’s MHRA: Exclusive Administrative Pathways, Strict 30/90-Day Deadlines, and Mailing Suffices for Due-Process Notice

Date: Oct 1, 2025

No Second Bite at the Apple under Montana’s MHRA: Exclusive Administrative Pathways, Strict 30/90-Day Deadlines, and Mailing Suffices for Due-Process Notice Note: The Montana Supreme Court designated...

Reverse Adverse Possession of Ditch Easements Requires Uniform, Conspicuous Exclusion; “Prevailing Party” Fees Under § 70‑17‑112, MCA, Turn on Statutory Claims Alone

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Reverse Adverse Possession of Ditch Easements Requires Uniform, Conspicuous Exclusion; “Prevailing Party” Fees Under § 70‑17‑112, MCA, Turn on Statutory Claims Alone Introduction In Apecella v....