2d Circuit Case Commentaries

Appellate Abandonment in Immigration Petitions: Conclusory Briefing Forfeits Review and May Trigger Grievance Referral

Date: Jan 23, 2026

Appellate Abandonment in Immigration Petitions: Conclusory Briefing Forfeits Review and May Trigger Grievance Referral Introduction Minagua-Yaucan v. Bondi (2d Cir. Jan. 21, 2026) is a...

Post-Plea Faretta Defects Are Subject to Harmless-Error Review When Counsel Is Restored Before Any Critical-Stage Prejudice

Date: Jan 23, 2026

Post-Plea Faretta Defects Are Subject to Harmless-Error Review When Counsel Is Restored Before Any Critical-Stage Prejudice I. Introduction In United States v. Hendrix, the Second Circuit affirmed...

United States v. Nash — Record-Supported Adult-Pornography Bans and Consecutive Revocation Sentences

Date: Jan 23, 2026

United States v. Nash — Record-Supported Adult-Pornography Bans and Consecutive Revocation Sentences I. Introduction In United States v. Nash, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit...

Concurrent Sentence Doctrine Bars Davis-Based § 2255 Review Where Unchallenged Life Sentences Make Relief Non-Meaningful

Date: Jan 23, 2026

Concurrent Sentence Doctrine Bars Davis-Based § 2255 Review Where Unchallenged Life Sentences Make Relief Non-Meaningful I. Introduction In Narvaez v. United States (2d Cir. Jan. 21, 2026) (summary...

Ekstein v. Polito — Issue Preclusion Locks In Foreclosure Court’s Post-Judgment Interest Determination

Date: Jan 23, 2026

Ekstein v. Polito: Issue Preclusion Locks In the Foreclosure Court’s Post-Judgment Interest Determination (and Courts Enforce Transfer-Restriction “Recourse Springing” Clauses as Written)...

Quinn v. City of New York: Strict Proof of Prior Written Notice, “Immediate” Creation for the Affirmative-Negligence Exception, and Rule 56(d) Affidavit Discipline

Date: Jan 23, 2026

Quinn v. City of New York: Strict Proof of Prior Written Notice, “Immediate” Creation for the Affirmative-Negligence Exception, and Rule 56(d) Affidavit Discipline Introduction Quinn v. City of New...

Attempted Enticement Under 18 U.S.C. § 2422(b) Turns on Defendant’s Intent and Substantial Step—Not the Minor’s Willingness—and Identity May Be Proven Circumstantially

Date: Jan 21, 2026

Attempted Enticement Under 18 U.S.C. § 2422(b) Turns on Defendant’s Intent and Substantial Step—Not the Minor’s Willingness—and Identity May Be Proven Circumstantially Case: United States v. Lettieri...

Domestic Injury Under Civil RICO Is Merits, Not Jurisdiction; Coercive Detention by Foreign Security Services Is Not “Commercial Activity” Under FSIA

Date: Jan 18, 2026

Domestic Injury Under Civil RICO Is Merits, Not Jurisdiction; Coercive Detention by Foreign Security Services Is Not “Commercial Activity” Under FSIA 1. Introduction In Yerkyn v. Yakovlevich (2d Cir....

Andrade v. Bondi — CAT Remand Required When the Agency Overlooks Evidence of Systemic Prison Torture and Intentional Deprivations

Date: Jan 18, 2026

Andrade v. Bondi — CAT Remand Required When the Agency Overlooks Evidence of Systemic Prison Torture and Intentional Deprivations Introduction In Andrade v. Bondi (2d Cir. Jan. 16, 2026) (summary...

Loper Bright Does Not Displace Prior Chevron-Based Circuit Immigration Precedent; Fact-Weighing in Cancellation Denials Remains Largely Unreviewable

Date: Jan 18, 2026

Loper Bright Does Not Displace Prior Chevron-Based Circuit Immigration Precedent; Fact-Weighing in Cancellation Denials Remains Largely Unreviewable 1. Introduction Hinds v. Bondi (2d Cir. Jan. 16,...

Second Circuit: Drug-Import Convictions Require Proof Defendant Knew the Contraband Was a Controlled Substance (Not Merely “Some” Illicit Cargo)

Date: Jan 17, 2026

Second Circuit: Drug-Import Convictions Require Proof Defendant Knew the Contraband Was a Controlled Substance (Not Merely “Some” Illicit Cargo) 1. Introduction In United States v. Belloisi (2d Cir....

Supervised-Release Revocation Sentencing: Implicit Guidelines Consideration, Limited Use of Arrest History, and Reliance on General Deterrence (United States v. Owens)

Date: Jan 17, 2026

Supervised-Release Revocation Sentencing: Implicit Guidelines Consideration, Limited Use of Arrest History, and Reliance on General Deterrence (United States v. Owens) Note on precedential status:...

Expired Preliminary-Injunction Appeals in School Vaccine Disputes: When “Capable of Repetition” Is Too Speculative

Date: Jan 17, 2026

Expired Preliminary-Injunction Appeals in School Vaccine Disputes: When “Capable of Repetition” Is Too Speculative 1. Introduction In A.A.C. v. Starpoint Central School District (2d Cir. Jan. 16,...

Alta Partners, LLC v. Getty Images Holdings, Inc. (2d Cir. 2026) — Commentary

Date: Jan 16, 2026

De‑SPAC Warrant Exercise: An Effective Form S‑4 Satisfies “Registration Statement” and Market‑Price‑at‑Breach Governs Damages Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit Date:...

Post-Esteras Limits on Retribution at Supervised-Release Revocation: “Offense” (Underlying Conviction) vs. “Violation” (Breach of Trust)

Date: Jan 16, 2026

Post-Esteras Limits on Retribution at Supervised-Release Revocation: “Offense” (Underlying Conviction) vs. “Violation” (Breach of Trust) Case: United States v. Lopez, No. 25-1644-cr (2d Cir. Jan. 15,...

United States v. Harris — Forfeiture of Rule 4(b) Untimeliness Objection When the Government Omits It from an Anders-Stage Summary-Affirmance Motion Despite Obvious Late Filing

Date: Jan 16, 2026

Forfeiture of Rule 4(b) Untimeliness Objection When the Government Omits It from an Anders-Stage Summary-Affirmance Motion Despite Obvious Late Filing Case: United States v. Harris (2d Cir. Jan. 14,...

Successive Compassionate-Release Motions May Be Denied on Unchanged § 3553(a) Factors Despite Belated Remorse and Rehabilitation (United States v. Thai)

Date: Jan 16, 2026

Successive Compassionate-Release Motions May Be Denied on Unchanged § 3553(a) Factors Despite Belated Remorse and Rehabilitation (United States v. Thai) 1. Introduction In United States v. Thai (2d...

Receivership Surplus After Full Restitution May Be Applied to Unpaid SEC Penalties; Commingling Favors Pro Rata Distribution and Defeats Constructive Trust Priority

Date: Jan 16, 2026

Receivership Surplus After Full Restitution May Be Applied to Unpaid SEC Penalties; Commingling Favors Pro Rata Distribution and Defeats Constructive Trust Priority Introduction In SEC v. Marcus et...

Retroactive Terrorism Limitations Waiver Before Expiration; Ex Post Facto Limits on § 3A1.4 “Involved” Prong When Predicate Listing Post-Dates Conduct

Date: Jan 15, 2026

Retroactive Terrorism Limitations Waiver Before Expiration; Ex Post Facto Limits on § 3A1.4 “Involved” Prong When Predicate Listing Post-Dates Conduct Case: United States v. Saab (2d Cir. Jan. 14,...

Rule 11(d)(2) Plea Withdrawal: Conclusory Claims of Pandemic Duress and Standby-Counsel Complaints Do Not Undermine a Sworn Plea Allocution (United States v. Houpe)

Date: Jan 15, 2026

Rule 11(d)(2) Plea Withdrawal: Conclusory Claims of Pandemic Duress and Standby-Counsel Complaints Do Not Undermine a Sworn Plea Allocution Case: United States v. Houpe, No. 24-287 (2d Cir. Jan. 14,...