10th Circuit Case Commentaries

Pattern Jury Instructions Do Not Expand “Minimum Conduct” Under the Categorical Approach: Oregon Second-Degree Assault Remains a Guidelines “Crime of Violence” Despite the Discredited “Natural and Probable Consequences” Accomplice Instruction

Date: Mar 8, 2026

Pattern Jury Instructions Do Not Expand “Minimum Conduct” Under the Categorical Approach: Oregon Second-Degree Assault Remains a Guidelines “Crime of Violence” Despite the Discredited “Natural and...

United States v. Aguilar — § 2244(a)(3) Treats Each Touching of an Enumerated Body Part as a Separate Unit of Prosecution

Date: Mar 8, 2026

United States v. Aguilar: Under 18 U.S.C. §§ 2244(a)(3) and 2246(3), Each Intentional Touching of an Enumerated Body Part Is a Separate “Unit of Prosecution” (No Merger for a Single Encounter)...

Villecco v. Kennedy: Pro Se Appellants Forfeit Review When They Offer Only Conclusory Assertions and Fail to Adequately Brief Error

Date: Mar 8, 2026

Villecco v. Kennedy: Pro Se Appellants Forfeit Review When They Offer Only Conclusory Assertions and Fail to Adequately Brief Error 1. Introduction In Villecco v. Kennedy (10th Cir. Mar. 6, 2026),...

Rule 60(b) “Omitted-Claim” Motions Are Successive § 2254 Petitions Requiring § 2244(b) Authorization

Date: Mar 7, 2026

Rule 60(b) “Omitted-Claim” Motions Are Successive § 2254 Petitions Requiring § 2244(b) Authorization I. Introduction In Bethel v. Louthan (10th Cir. Mar. 5, 2026) (unpublished order), Oklahoma inmate...

United States v. Cooks — Rule 12(c)(3) Good-Cause Requirement Bars Untimely Suppression Challenges on Direct Appeal (Anders Disposition)

Date: Mar 7, 2026

Rule 12(c)(3) Good-Cause Requirement Bars Untimely Suppression Challenges on Direct Appeal (Anders Disposition) Introduction In United States v. Cooks (10th Cir. Mar. 5, 2026) (unpublished “Order and...

Advance-Payment CROA Claims Require Concrete Harm: No Standing When Services Precede Payment and Provide Equal or Greater Value

Date: Mar 6, 2026

Advance-Payment CROA Claims Require Concrete Harm: No Standing When Services Precede Payment and Provide Equal or Greater Value Case: Ensminger v. Credit Law Center (No. 25-3009) | Court: United...

Eaves v. Polis: Transfer Within a Prison System Does Not Moot Systemwide Injunction Claims; Colorado Governor Has Ex Parte Young “Enforcement Connection” Over CDOC

Date: Mar 6, 2026

Eaves v. Polis: Transfer Within a Prison System Does Not Moot Systemwide Injunction Claims; Colorado Governor Has Ex Parte Young “Enforcement Connection” Over CDOC 1. Introduction Case: Eaves v....

Post-Removal § 2241 Habeas Jurisdiction: Supervised Release and Collateral Consequences Do Not Satisfy “In Custody” for Immigration-Process Challenges

Date: Mar 6, 2026

Post-Removal § 2241 Habeas Jurisdiction: Supervised Release and Collateral Consequences Do Not Satisfy “In Custody” for Immigration-Process Challenges Introduction In Moreno v. Attorney General,...

Sex-Segregated Public Elementary Classes Violate Clearly Established Equal Protection (Qualified Immunity Denied)

Date: Mar 6, 2026

Sex-Segregated Public Elementary Classes Violate Clearly Established Equal Protection (Qualified Immunity Denied) I. Introduction Stepp v. Lockhart (10th Cir. Mar. 3, 2026) arises from Talihina...

COA Denial Where Padilla Claim Depends on Disputing Credibility-Based Findings of Deportation Advice

Date: Mar 6, 2026

COA Denial Where Padilla Claim Depends on Disputing Credibility-Based Findings of Deportation Advice Introduction In United States v. Akinsanya (10th Cir. Mar. 3, 2026), the Tenth Circuit denied...

Unpreserved § 2S1.1(a)(1) vs. (a)(2) Disputes Fail on Plain-Error Review When “Additional Involvement” Is Reasonably Debatable

Date: Mar 6, 2026

Unpreserved § 2S1.1(a)(1) vs. (a)(2) Disputes Fail on Plain-Error Review When “Additional Involvement” Is Reasonably Debatable Case: United States v. Idowu (10th Cir. Mar. 3, 2026) (Order and...

United States v. Mayfield — Perjury Sufficiency Anchored to the Jury-Tried Theory; Brief Doyle References Fail Plain-Error Prejudice

Date: Mar 6, 2026

United States v. Mayfield: Perjury Sufficiency Must Rest on a Prosecutor-Argued False Statement; “Blip” Doyle References Do Not Establish Plain-Error Prejudice Introduction Case: United States v....

Stepp v. Lockhart: Brown and United States v. Virginia Clearly Establish that Sex-Segregated Public Elementary Classrooms Violate Equal Protection

Date: Mar 6, 2026

Stepp v. Lockhart: Brown and United States v. Virginia Clearly Establish that Sex-Segregated Public Elementary Classrooms Violate Equal Protection (and Limit Qualified Immunity) I. Introduction Stepp...

Stepp v. McClain (10th Cir. Mar. 3, 2026) — Sex-Based Segregation in Public Elementary Classrooms Violates Equal Protection with “Obvious Clarity” Under Brown and Virginia, Defeating Qualified Immunity

Date: Mar 6, 2026

Sex-Based Segregation in Public Elementary Classrooms Violates Equal Protection with “Obvious Clarity” Under Brown and Virginia, Defeating Qualified Immunity Case: Stepp v. McClain, Nos. 25-7038 &...

NEPA FONSI Does Not Preclude NPATMA “Significant Adverse Impacts” Finding for Air Tour Bans

Date: Mar 6, 2026

NEPA FONSI Does Not Preclude NPATMA “Significant Adverse Impacts” Finding for Air Tour Bans I. Introduction Adams v. FAA (10th Cir. Mar. 3, 2026) arises from the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA)...

United States v. Atkins: No Plain-Error Relief for Unobjected-to Lay Opinion Implying Guilt Without a Showing of Prejudice

Date: Mar 6, 2026

United States v. Atkins: No Plain-Error Relief for Unobjected-to Lay Opinion Implying Guilt Without a Showing of Prejudice Introduction United States v. Atkins (10th Cir. Mar. 3, 2026) arises from a...

Guideline Range Corrected After Sentencing Recess: Same Term May Be Reimposed as an Upward Variance if Independently Supported by § 3553(a)

Date: Mar 5, 2026

Guideline Range Corrected After Sentencing Recess: Same Term May Be Reimposed as an Upward Variance if Independently Supported by § 3553(a) Introduction In United States v. Saunders (10th Cir. Feb....

Berry v. Bondi: No Waiver of Federal-Sector Title VII Exhaustion Defense by Mere Acceptance and Investigation of an Untimely EEO Complaint

Date: Mar 4, 2026

Berry v. Bondi: No Waiver of Federal-Sector Title VII Exhaustion Defense by Mere Acceptance and Investigation of an Untimely EEO Complaint Introduction Parties and posture. Former FBI Special Agent...

Appellate Waiver of Unchallenged Alternative Grounds and Particularized “Clearly Established” Law in Fourth Amendment Qualified-Immunity Appeals (Blackmore v. Carlson)

Date: Mar 4, 2026

Appellate Waiver of Unchallenged Alternative Grounds and Particularized “Clearly Established” Law in Fourth Amendment Qualified-Immunity Appeals Case: Blackmore v. Carlson (No. 24-4074) | Court: U.S....

Sousa v. Chipotle Services, LLC — Pretext at Summary Judgment Requires Affirmative Evidence (Not Credibility Attacks or Speculative Comparators)

Date: Mar 3, 2026

Pretext at Summary Judgment Requires Affirmative Evidence—Credibility Attacks, Speculative Comparator Proof, and “Stellar Performance” Are Insufficient Under the NMHRA Case: Sousa v. Chipotle...