Inherent Powers under the BNSS Cannot Be Used as a Second Revision Except to Prevent Gross Injustice

Case: ANIL AHLUWALIA v. STATE NCT OF DELHI AND ORS

Citation: 2026 DHC 8191 | Court: Delhi High Court | Date: 23 September 2026

Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Girish Kathpalia

1. Introduction

The Delhi High Court considered whether its inherent jurisdiction under Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (“BNSS”) could be invoked after the petitioner had unsuccessfully challenged the same order before the Sessions Court in revision. The case concerns the relationship between Section 438(3) BNSS, which prohibits a second revision, and Section 528 BNSS, which preserves the High Court’s inherent powers.

The petitioner, Anil Ahluwalia, alleged that his wife died during the Covid-19 pandemic because of wrongful conduct and medical negligence at a hospital. His allegations included demands for cash, expensive Remdesivir injections, interruption of oxygen supply, threats to discharge the patient, forgery of prescriptions, and homicide.

After the police allegedly failed to register an FIR, the petitioner filed a criminal complaint with an application under Section 156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (“CrPC”), now Section 175(3) BNSS, seeking a direction for registration and investigation of an FIR.

2. Procedural Background

  1. The Magistrate called for an Action Taken Report from the police.
  2. By order dated 28 August 2023, the Magistrate declined to direct registration of an FIR.
  3. The Magistrate held that the identity of the proposed accused, relevant facts, and evidence were already within the petitioner’s knowledge.
  4. The complaint was not dismissed; it was listed for recording pre-summoning evidence under Section 200 CrPC.
  5. The Magistrate also observed that police assistance could be obtained later under Section 202 CrPC, if necessary.
  6. The Sessions Court dismissed the petitioner’s criminal revision on 19 April 2025.
  7. The petitioner then approached the High Court under Section 528 BNSS, challenging the revisional order.

3. Issue Before the High Court

The central issue was whether a party who has already invoked and exhausted the revisional jurisdiction of the Sessions Court may challenge the same matter before the High Court by presenting the proceeding as a petition under Section 528 BNSS.

More specifically, the Court had to determine whether refusal to direct registration of an FIR caused such gross injustice or grave miscarriage of justice that the statutory prohibition against a second revision could exceptionally be disregarded.

4. Summary of the Judgment

The High Court dismissed the petition as not maintainable. It held that Section 528 BNSS cannot ordinarily be used as a “backdoor” means of obtaining a second revision prohibited by Section 438(3) BNSS.

The Court nevertheless recognised a narrow exception: inherent powers may be exercised where the impugned order produces gross injustice, grave miscarriage of justice, abuse of judicial process, or involves a clear jurisdictional or procedural illegality.

That exception was not attracted because the petitioner had not been left without a remedy. His private complaint remained pending before the Magistrate for pre-summoning evidence. If police assistance became necessary, the Magistrate could direct an inquiry or investigation at a later stage. Therefore, refusal to order immediate registration of an FIR did not terminate the petitioner’s criminal complaint or foreclose adjudication of his allegations.

5. Legal Principle Laid Down

Where a party has already unsuccessfully invoked the revisional jurisdiction of the Sessions Court, the same challenge cannot ordinarily be re-agitated before the High Court under Section 528 BNSS. Inherent powers may be exercised despite Section 438(3) BNSS only in exceptional cases involving gross injustice, grave miscarriage of justice, abuse of process, jurisdictional error, or comparable illegality.

The judgment also confirms that earlier authorities interpreting Sections 397(3) and 482 CrPC continue to govern Sections 438(3) and 528 BNSS because the corresponding BNSS provisions have not materially altered the earlier law.

6. Analysis of the Court’s Reasoning

6.1 Continuity between the CrPC and the BNSS

Section 438 BNSS corresponds to Section 397 CrPC, while Section 528 BNSS corresponds to Section 482 CrPC. Since the language and substance of these provisions remain materially unchanged, the Court held that the body of precedent developed under the CrPC continues to apply under the BNSS.

This is an important transitional ruling: enactment of the BNSS does not reopen legal questions already settled under equivalent CrPC provisions unless the statutory language has materially changed.

6.2 Purpose of the prohibition against a second revision

The Court explained that the statutory bar exists to prevent multiplicity of proceedings, delay in trials, and repeated challenges to the same order before successive superior courts. Permitting routine petitions under Section 528 BNSS after dismissal of a revision would make Section 438(3) ineffective.

Although inherent powers are broad and do not derive their existence solely from Section 528, they are not unlimited. They must be exercised cautiously and cannot be employed to defeat an express legislative prohibition.

6.3 The gross-injustice exception

The Court did not treat Section 438(3) as an absolute restriction on the High Court’s constitutional and inherent responsibility to prevent injustice. Intervention remains possible where there is:

  • a grave miscarriage or failure of justice;
  • abuse of judicial process;
  • non-compliance with a mandatory statutory procedure;
  • a patent jurisdictional error; or
  • an order requiring immediate correction to prevent serious injustice.

The phrase “rarest of rare” was used to stress the exceptional nature of this jurisdiction. It was not used in the technical sense associated with death-penalty sentencing.

6.4 Why the petitioner did not satisfy the exception

The decisive consideration was that the petitioner remained able to prosecute his private complaint. The Magistrate had merely refused to direct immediate police registration of an FIR; the complaint itself had not been rejected.

The petitioner could lead pre-summoning evidence, and the Magistrate could subsequently seek police assistance under Section 202 CrPC or its corresponding BNSS provision, Section 225. Thus, the petitioner was not remediless and no gross injustice resulted from denial of the Section 156(3) application.

The judgment consequently does not decide whether the allegations of homicide, forgery, or medical negligence are true. Those matters remain capable of examination in the pending complaint proceedings.

7. Precedents Cited

Krishnan & Anr. vs Krishnaveni & Anr.

This was the principal authority governing the interaction between revisional and inherent jurisdiction. The Supreme Court held that a party ordinarily cannot invoke Section 482 CrPC to circumvent the bar under Section 397(3) CrPC after having pursued revision before the Sessions Court.

At the same time, it recognised the High Court’s duty to intervene where the record reveals grave miscarriage of justice, abuse of process, failure to follow statutory procedure, or an illegal order. The Delhi High Court adopted this balance: the prohibition is the rule, while intervention to prevent gross injustice is the exception.

Dhariwal Tobacco Products Ltd. & Ors. vs State of Maharshtra & Anr.

The petitioner relied on this decision to argue that the availability of revision does not eliminate the High Court’s inherent jurisdiction. The High Court distinguished it because that case concerned whether a Section 482 petition could be rejected merely because an alternative revisional remedy was available.

The present case involved a materially different situation: the petitioner had already exercised the revisional remedy and was attempting to challenge the same result again. Accordingly, the precedent did not authorise a routine second challenge under inherent jurisdiction.

Exclusive Capital Ltd. vs State, Government of NCT Delhi

This decision involved the same procedural situation—dismissal of a Section 156(3) CrPC application, affirmance by the Sessions Court, and a subsequent petition invoking inherent powers.

It held that inherent jurisdiction may not be used to bypass the prohibition against a second revision except in rare cases of gross injustice. It also established that a complainant is not remediless where the complaint remains pending, the complainant can lead evidence, and the Magistrate can obtain police assistance later. The Court directly applied that reasoning in the present case.

Authorities considered through Exclusive Capital Ltd. vs State, Government of NCT Delhi

  • Amar Nath vs State of Haryana: Addressed statutory limits on revisional interference and supported the principle that express procedural restrictions should not be routinely bypassed.
  • Madhu Limaye vs The State of Maharashtra: Explained that inherent powers survive procedural restrictions but must be used sparingly to prevent abuse of process or secure the ends of justice.
  • State of Haryana vs Bhajan Lal: Reinforced the exceptional character of the High Court’s power to terminate or interfere with criminal proceedings in cases of abuse or manifest injustice.
  • Girish Kumar Suneja vs Central Bureau of Investigation: Emphasised respect for legislative restrictions on repeated or interlocutory challenges and cautioned against using inherent jurisdiction to neutralise such restrictions.

The Sessions Court had also referred to precedents concerning medical negligence, but their titles were not reproduced in the High Court judgment. The High Court’s decision ultimately turned on maintainability rather than the substantive standard of criminal medical negligence.

8. Complex Concepts Simplified

Section 175(3) BNSS / Section 156(3) CrPC
A Magistrate’s power to direct the police to register and investigate a cognizable offence before the Magistrate proceeds with the complaint personally.
Revision
A supervisory remedy through which a higher court examines whether a lower criminal court acted legally, correctly, and within its jurisdiction. It is narrower than an appeal.
Inherent powers
Powers retained by the High Court to prevent abuse of judicial process and secure justice, even where no specific procedural provision supplies the remedy.
Second-revision bar
Once a party chooses revision before either the Sessions Court or the High Court, it cannot ordinarily file another revision before the other forum concerning the same order.
Pre-summoning evidence
Evidence presented by a complainant to enable the Magistrate to decide whether sufficient grounds exist to summon the proposed accused.
Not rendered remediless
The complainant still has an effective legal route. Here, the pending private complaint allowed the petitioner to lead evidence and seek later investigative assistance.

9. Impact of the Judgment

  • BNSS continuity: CrPC precedents governing revision and inherent powers remain applicable to the equivalent BNSS provisions.
  • Control of disguised second revisions: Merely labelling a challenge as a Section 528 petition will not overcome Section 438(3).
  • Higher threshold for intervention: Petitioners must demonstrate patent illegality, abuse of process, or gross injustice—not merely disagreement with concurrent orders.
  • Private complaints remain meaningful remedies: Refusal to order an FIR does not necessarily defeat a complainant’s case where pre-summoning evidence can be led.
  • Protection against premature coercive investigation: Police machinery should not automatically be activated where the complainant knows the accused and possesses the relevant evidence.
  • No ruling on medical negligence merits: The judgment does not exonerate the doctors or hospital; it only declines extraordinary procedural intervention.

10. Editorial Observation

Paragraph 11 refers to recourse under “Article 126 of the Constitution of India.” Article 126 concerns appointment of an acting Chief Justice of India. In context, the intended reference appears likely to be Article 136, which concerns the Supreme Court’s special-leave jurisdiction. This textual anomaly does not affect the ratio of the judgment.

11. Conclusion

The judgment establishes a clear procedural rule under the BNSS: inherent powers cannot ordinarily be used to obtain a second revision after the Sessions Court has already ruled on the same challenge. Intervention is reserved for exceptional cases of gross injustice, grave miscarriage of justice, abuse of process, or patent illegality.

Because Anil Ahluwalia’s complaint remained pending for pre-summoning evidence and the Magistrate retained power to seek police assistance, he had not been left without a remedy. The petition was therefore dismissed as not maintainable, while the substantive allegations remained open for consideration in the complaint proceedings.