All High Courts Case Commentaries

Limits on Section 41-A Cr.P.C. Notices: No Mechanical 15-Day Reporting and No “Guilty” Declarations

Date: Feb 10, 2026

Limits on Section 41-A Cr.P.C. Notices: No Mechanical 15-Day Reporting and No “Guilty” Declarations 1. Introduction In ARMAN KHAN v. STATE OF ORISSA (Orissa High Court, decided on 09-02-2026), nine...

Withheld Investigation Material and Fabricated Section 27 Memoranda: Acquittal in a Circumstantial Case

Date: Feb 10, 2026

Withheld Investigation Material and Fabricated Section 27 Memoranda: Acquittal in a Circumstantial Case Case: Kamlesh Bai Kushwaha v. The State Of Madhya Pradesh (2026 MPHC-JBP 11261) Court: High...

Section 27-A NDPS “Financing” Requires Funding Illicit Traffic (Not Mere Receipt of Funds): Anticipatory Bail Where Implication Rests on Co-Accused Statement and Bank Credits

Date: Feb 10, 2026

Section 27-A NDPS “Financing” Requires Funding Illicit Traffic (Not Mere Receipt of Funds): Anticipatory Bail Where Implication Rests on Co-Accused Statement and Bank Credits 1. Introduction In...

Police-Recorded Dying Declaration under Section 161 CrPC as Substantive Evidence When Certified Fit by Doctor: ASIF v. State of Karnataka (Karnataka HC, 09-02-2026)

Date: Feb 10, 2026

Police-Recorded Dying Declaration under Section 161 CrPC as Substantive Evidence When Certified Fit by Doctor: ASIF v. State of Karnataka (Karnataka HC, 09-02-2026) 1. Introduction The Division Bench...

Technical Limitation Cannot Defeat Terror-Victim Ex Gratia: Mandatory Reconsideration Under the 2019 Central Scheme

Date: Feb 10, 2026

Technical Limitation Cannot Defeat Terror-Victim Ex Gratia: Mandatory Reconsideration Under the 2019 Central Scheme Court: High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh at Jammu Case: Sabza Begum and Anr....

Probationary Judicial Officer Discharge Under Rule 14: Fact-Finding Triggered by a Viral Incident Does Not Convert Termination into Punitive Removal Absent a Formal Misconduct Finding

Date: Feb 8, 2026

Probationary Judicial Officer Discharge Under Rule 14: Fact-Finding Triggered by a Viral Incident Does Not Convert Termination into Punitive Removal Absent a Formal Misconduct Finding 1. Introduction...

Omission of Raja Kaluve in Master Plan/Sanctioned Plan Does Not Defeat Statutory Vesting of “B” Kharab Storm-Water Drains

Date: Feb 7, 2026

Omission of Raja Kaluve in Master Plan/Sanctioned Plan Does Not Defeat Statutory Vesting of “B” Kharab Storm-Water Drains Case: MANTRI TRANQUIL APARTMENTS OWNERS ASSOCIATION v. BRUHAT BENGALURU...

Contractual NHM Termination: Stigma Allegations Do Not Trigger Article 311-Style Departmental Enquiry Where Contract Permits Termination for Unsatisfactory Performance and Natural Justice Is Met

Date: Feb 7, 2026

Contractual NHM Termination: Stigma Allegations Do Not Trigger Article 311-Style Departmental Enquiry Where Contract Permits Termination for Unsatisfactory Performance and Natural Justice Is Met...

MEPS Act Section 9 Does Not Cover Standalone Pay-Scale Disputes: Higher Pay Scale Is Not “Promotion” nor “Reduction in Rank”

Date: Feb 7, 2026

MEPS Act Section 9 Does Not Cover Standalone Pay-Scale Disputes: Higher Pay Scale Is Not “Promotion” nor “Reduction in Rank” Case: DEEPALI DINESH NAIK v. KRANTIVIR CHAFEKAR EDUCATION SOCIETY AND ORS....

Continuing Trespass by State Instrumentalities: Delay & Laches No Bar to Mandamus for Restoration or Statutory Acquisition (with Rental Compensation) under Article 300-A

Date: Feb 7, 2026

Continuing Trespass by State Instrumentalities: Delay & Laches No Bar to Mandamus for Restoration or Statutory Acquisition (with Rental Compensation) under Article 300-A 1. Introduction The Jammu and...

Bail in Heinous Offences on Prolonged Incarceration: Delay Attributable to Prosecution as a Decisive Speedy-Trial Factor

Date: Feb 7, 2026

Bail in Heinous Offences on Prolonged Incarceration: Delay Attributable to Prosecution as a Decisive Speedy-Trial Factor 1. Introduction In Shareen Ganai v. U T of J and K th SHO Police Station...

Dying Declaration in Burn Cases: Mandatory Reliability Safeguards and Limits of Section 106 Evidence Act

Date: Feb 7, 2026

Dying Declaration in Burn Cases: Mandatory Reliability Safeguards and Limits of Section 106 Evidence Act 1. Introduction The Rajasthan High Court (Division Bench) in SOMA v. STATE (2026 RJ-JD...

Encroaching Temples on Waterbody Bunds: No Patta/Regularisation and No Shield Under the Places of Worship Act, 1991

Date: Feb 7, 2026

Encroaching Temples on Waterbody Bunds: No Patta/Regularisation and No Shield Under the Places of Worship Act, 1991 1. Introduction In N.Kumar v. The District Collector (Madras High Court, Madurai...

TIP Not Vitiated by Vague “Media Photos” Admission; Conspiracy Proved by Circumstantial Chain (Motive–Last Seen–Recoveries–FSL)

Date: Feb 7, 2026

TIP Not Vitiated by Vague “Media Photos” Admission; Conspiracy Proved by Circumstantial Chain (Motive–Last Seen–Recoveries–FSL) 1) Introduction Case: SANDEEP v. STATE OF KARNATAKA (Karnataka High...

No Appeal Under Section 14A SC/ST Act Against an Order Framing Charge: Such Order Treated as Interlocutory/Intermediate; Remedy Lies in Revision/Inherent Jurisdiction

Date: Feb 7, 2026

No Appeal Under Section 14A SC/ST Act Against an Order Framing Charge: Such Order Treated as Interlocutory/Intermediate; Remedy Lies in Revision/Inherent Jurisdiction 1. Introduction The decision in...

UAPA Bail: Non-furnishing of Written Grounds of Arrest Is Not Per Se Fatal—Prejudice Test, Delay, and ‘Reasons’ vs ‘Grounds’

Date: Feb 7, 2026

UAPA Bail: Non-furnishing of Written Grounds of Arrest Is Not Per Se Fatal—Prejudice Test, Delay, and ‘Reasons’ vs ‘Grounds’ 1. Introduction This decision of the Karnataka High Court (Division Bench)...

IOA Cannot Add Extra-Olympic Eligibility Conditions Beyond FIS Qualification Criteria

Date: Feb 6, 2026

IOA Cannot Add Extra-Olympic Eligibility Conditions Beyond FIS Qualification Criteria: “World Championship Participation” Not a Mandatory Athlete-Eligibility Filter; “Long List” Cannot Override Final...

Disaster Compensation for Tsunami Losses Cannot Be Denied Solely Due to Later Expiry of Land Grant; Corporate Farming Grantees Eligible Subject to Surrender Condition under 30.07.2012 Policy

Date: Feb 6, 2026

Disaster Compensation for Tsunami Losses Cannot Be Denied Solely Due to Later Expiry of Land Grant; Corporate Farming Grantees Eligible Subject to Surrender Condition under 30.07.2012 Policy 1....

Pending Departmental Enquiry Bars In‑Charge (Ad hoc) Headmaster Posting as a Promotional Benefit, Despite Validity of Degree Obtained Without Permission

Date: Feb 6, 2026

Pending Departmental Enquiry Bars In‑Charge (Ad hoc) Headmaster Posting as a Promotional Benefit, Despite Validity of Degree Obtained Without Permission Case: THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ORS. v. MADHAB...

Working Wife Not Disentitled to Section 125 Cr.P.C. Maintenance: Disparity-in-Income and Matrimonial Standard-of-Living Test

Date: Feb 6, 2026

Working Wife Not Disentitled to Section 125 Cr.P.C. Maintenance: Disparity-in-Income and Matrimonial Standard-of-Living Test 1. Introduction The decision in Ravinder Singh Bisht v. State of U.P. and...