All High Courts Case Commentaries

Continuing Mandamus for Decades-Delayed Land Acquisition: Statewide Mission-Mode Ledger, Payment/Deposit Compliance, and Accountability Under Article 300A

Date: Feb 18, 2026

Continuing Mandamus for Decades-Delayed Land Acquisition: Statewide Mission-Mode Ledger, Payment/Deposit Compliance, and Accountability Under Article 300A 1. Introduction Case: Shahadeo Dagadu Mete...

Section 127 MRTP: Post-notice lapsing cannot be defeated by alleging “defective” purchase notice for want of title documents

Date: Feb 18, 2026

Section 127 MRTP: Post-notice lapsing cannot be defeated by alleging “defective” purchase notice for want of title documents 1. Introduction The Bombay High Court (Ravindra V. Ghuge & Abhay J....

Contractual Service Termination by Non‑State Public-Function Bodies Not Amenable to Writ: “Public Law Element” as the Maintainability Threshold

Date: Feb 18, 2026

Contractual Service Termination by Non‑State Public-Function Bodies Not Amenable to Writ: “Public Law Element” as the Maintainability Threshold 1) Introduction In Atal Khandelwal v. Institute of...

Non-renewal of a fixed-term contract is not punitive “termination”; ministerial backdoor engagement without a sanctioned post/procedure is void

Date: Feb 18, 2026

Non-renewal of a fixed-term contract is not punitive “termination”; ministerial backdoor engagement without a sanctioned post/procedure is void Case TITHI ADHIKARY v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS Court...

PMFBY Data-Entry Error Rule: Nodal Bank Liable to Pay Farmers’ Claims When NCIP Upload Is Wrong/Incomplete

Date: Feb 18, 2026

PMFBY Data-Entry Error Rule: Nodal Bank Liable to Pay Farmers’ Claims When NCIP Upload Is Wrong/Incomplete 1. Introduction This batch of writ petitions before the Rajasthan High Court (Jodhpur) arose...

Premature Release Cannot Be Denied Solely on “Gravity”: SRB Must Give Evidence-Linked Reasons and Courts May Grant Mandamus After Repeated Mechanical Rejections

Date: Feb 18, 2026

Premature Release Cannot Be Denied Solely on “Gravity”: SRB Must Give Evidence-Linked Reasons and Courts May Grant Mandamus After Repeated Mechanical Rejections 1. Introduction In ASIF @ NAEEM v....

Temple Invitations Must Omit Caste Suffixes of Ubayatharars: Prospective HR&CE Duty Under Article 14

Date: Feb 18, 2026

Temple Invitations Must Omit Caste Suffixes of Ubayatharars: Prospective HR&CE Duty Under Article 14 1. Introduction In N.SAMARAN v. THE COMMISSIONER (Madras High Court, 17-02-2026, W.P.No.6606 of...

Admissions, Pleadings, and “Perversity” in Second Appeal: Invalidating an Admitted Lease and Deciding Beyond Issues is Unsustainable

Date: Feb 18, 2026

Admissions, Pleadings, and “Perversity” in Second Appeal: Invalidating an Admitted Lease and Deciding Beyond Issues is Unsustainable 1. Introduction The decision in SHILLONG CLUB LTD v. NATHANIEL...

Delay in Seeking Probate Is Not a Bar: It Is Only a Rebuttable Suspicious Circumstance; Limitation Runs From When Probate Becomes Necessary

Date: Feb 18, 2026

Delay in Seeking Probate Is Not a Bar: It Is Only a Rebuttable Suspicious Circumstance; Limitation Runs From When Probate Becomes Necessary Case: RAJA SHAH AND ORS v. KOWSHIK SHOW AND ORS Court:...

Bail to Medical Practitioners: Jacob Mathew Screening Not Attracted Where a Competent Authority Complains and the Doctor Allegedly Prescribes a Banned Fixed-Dose Syrup Despite Prior Toxicity Warning

Date: Feb 18, 2026

Bail to Medical Practitioners: Jacob Mathew Screening Not Attracted Where a Competent Authority Complains and the Doctor Allegedly Prescribes a Banned Fixed-Dose Syrup Despite Prior Toxicity Warning...

Bail in Serious Sexual-Offence Prosecutions: Victim’s No-Objection and Proposed Special Marriage as a Post-Release Bail-Cancellation Trigger

Date: Feb 18, 2026

Bail in Serious Sexual-Offence Prosecutions: Victim’s No-Objection and Proposed Special Marriage as a Post-Release Bail-Cancellation Trigger 1. Introduction In Mani Miraj Alias Ramdi Miraj Alam v....

Section 34 Specific Relief Act: Declaration May Survive Defective/Missing Consequential Relief; Withdrawal Without Liberty Not an Absolute Bar

Date: Feb 17, 2026

Section 34 Specific Relief Act: Declaration May Survive Defective/Missing Consequential Relief; Withdrawal Without Liberty Not an Absolute Bar 1) Introduction Case: TAJ PARVEEN v. EZAZULLA SHARIFF,...

Habeas Corpus for a Near-Major Minor: Protective Custody in a Children Home Until 18 When the Corpus Refuses Parental Return

Date: Feb 17, 2026

Habeas Corpus for a Near-Major Minor: Protective Custody in a Children Home Until 18 When the Corpus Refuses Parental Return 1. Introduction The Gujarat High Court in BHANGI ANILBHAI GOVABHAI v....

Nishad v. Mumthaz Beegum (2026 KER 13291) — In-Law Liability Requires Specific Proof in Matrimonial Gold/Money Return Claims

Date: Feb 17, 2026

In-Law Liability Requires Specific Proof: Entrustment of Bridal Gold May Be Inferred, but Misappropriation Cannot Be Presumed Against Relatives 1. Introduction Nishad v. Mumthaz Beegum (2026 KER...

NDPS Retesting Bar: A Second Laboratory Test Cannot Be Ordered Merely Because the First Report Is Unfavourable

Date: Feb 17, 2026

NDPS Retesting Bar: A Second Laboratory Test Cannot Be Ordered Merely Because the First Report Is Unfavourable 1. Introduction In MOHAMMAD MANSHA AND OTHERS v. NARCOTICS CONTROL BUREAU(NCB), ZONAL...

Finality of Review Medical Board in CAPFs Recruitment: No Court-Directed “Third Medical Examination” Absent Malafides or Procedural Illegality

Date: Feb 14, 2026

Finality of Review Medical Board in CAPFs Recruitment: No Court-Directed “Third Medical Examination” Absent Malafides or Procedural Illegality 1. Introduction In Younis Ali v. Union of India Ministry...

ITR-Based Income Must Be Accepted in MACT Claims Absent Rebuttal

Date: Feb 14, 2026

Income Tax Returns as Reliable Proof of Deceased’s Income in MACT Claims (Without Enquiry into “Source”), and Mandatory Alignment with Pranay Sethi Future Prospects and Sarla Verma Multiplier 1....

Show-Cause for “Removal & Debarment” Validates Lesser Enlistment Penalties (Downgrading); Past Downgrade Not a Perpetual Bar to Fresh “SS” Registration

Date: Feb 14, 2026

Show-Cause for “Removal & Debarment” Validates Lesser Enlistment Penalties (Downgrading); Past Downgrade Not a Perpetual Bar to Fresh “SS” Registration 1. Introduction This Letters Patent Appeal (LPA...

Rival Claims Are Not a Ground to Deny Interim Custody of Seized Valuables: Custody Should Be Granted on a Prima Facie Basis with Safeguards

Date: Feb 14, 2026

Rival Claims Are Not a Ground to Deny Interim Custody of Seized Valuables: Custody Should Be Granted on a Prima Facie Basis with Safeguards 1) Introduction The Karnataka High Court (Mohammad Nawaz...

Unqualified BPL Fee Exemption Under Section 7(5) RTI Act: Page-Caps in State RTI Fee Rules Are Ultra Vires

Date: Feb 14, 2026

Unqualified BPL Fee Exemption Under Section 7(5) RTI Act: Page-Caps in State RTI Fee Rules Are Ultra Vires 1. Introduction Case: NISHAD SHOBANAN, v. THE UNION OF INDIA (2026 KER 13231), decided by...