state Case Commentaries

In re N.M.: Case-Plan Delay Is Not Reversible Without Prejudice Where Abuse/Neglect Is Untreatable, and Unobjected Hearsay Is Waived on Appeal

Date: Aug 26, 2026

In re N.M.: Case-Plan Delay Is Not Reversible Without Prejudice Where Abuse/Neglect Is Untreatable, and Unobjected Hearsay Is Waived on Appeal 1. Introduction In In re N.M. (W. Va. Aug. 25, 2026)...

Lipscomb v. Hagedorn: Enforcing Contractual Attorney-Fee Clauses in Incorporated Separation Agreements

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Lipscomb v. Hagedorn: Enforcing Contractual Attorney-Fee Clauses in Incorporated Separation Agreements 1. Introduction In Jimmy Lipscomb v. Pamela Hagedorn (W. Va. Aug. 25, 2026), the Supreme Court...

Civil Contempt for Property Return Requires Proof of Present Noncompliance with the Final Decree—No Contempt for Items Not Found in the Party’s Possession

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Civil Contempt for Property Return Requires Proof of Present Noncompliance with the Final Decree—No Contempt for Items Not Found in the Party’s Possession 1. Introduction In Marilyn Fay Minor v....

Absent Bad Faith, a Circuit Court Must Grant the State’s Rule 48(a) Motion to Dismiss When the Defendant Consents

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Absent Bad Faith, a Circuit Court Must Grant the State’s Rule 48(a) Motion to Dismiss When the Defendant Consents 1. Introduction In State of West Virginia ex rel. Dalton Ours v. The State of West...

Mandamus to Require Statutory Findings Before Granting Post-Adjudicatory Improvement Periods

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Mandamus to Require Statutory Findings Before Granting Post-Adjudicatory Improvement Periods Introduction In State of West Virginia ex rel. H.C., P.C., M.C., Z.C. and West Virginia Department of...

State v. Sellers: “Well-Established” Forensic Science Still Requires a Porter Gatekeeping Check When New Standards Cast Doubt

Date: Aug 26, 2026

State v. Sellers: “Well-Established” Forensic Science Still Requires a Porter Gatekeeping Check When New Standards Cast Doubt 1. Introduction In State v. Sellers (Conn. Aug. 25, 2026), the Supreme...

Recording a Judgment (Without Debtor’s Voluntary Compliance) Does Not Moot an Appeal; Failure to Obtain a Stay Is Not Voluntary Satisfaction

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Recording a Judgment (Without Debtor’s Voluntary Compliance) Does Not Moot an Appeal; Failure to Obtain a Stay Is Not Voluntary Satisfaction Introduction In Drushal v. Miller, Slip Opinion No....

Context-Based Interpretation of “Current” Public-Records Requests and Limited Writs Requiring Production or Certification of Nonexistence (Ohio Mandamus)

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Context-Based Interpretation of “Current” Public-Records Requests and Limited Writs Requiring Production or Certification of Nonexistence (Ohio Mandamus) Case: State ex rel. Clark v. Dept. of Rehab....

Production of Nonprofit Records in Discovery Moots Inspection Claims; Courts Decline to Intervene in Uncontested, Superseded Officer Elections Absent Injury

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Production of Nonprofit Records in Discovery Moots Inspection Claims; Courts Decline to Intervene in Uncontested, Superseded Officer Elections Absent Injury 1. Introduction E. Kragh v. MADC is a 2026...

Marriage of French: Rule 60(b) Relief Cannot Substitute for an Untimely Appeal; Voidness Requires a Fundamental Due Process Defect Shown on an Adequate Record

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Marriage of French: Rule 60(b) Relief Cannot Substitute for an Untimely Appeal; Voidness Requires a Fundamental Due Process Defect Shown on an Adequate Record 1. Introduction Case: In re the Marriage...

State v. M. Mitchell (2026 MT 201): Custody During Revocation Is Credited to the Active DOC Term Being Served; the State Is Judicially Estopped From Reclaiming Detention-Credit Error It Invited

Date: Aug 26, 2026

State v. M. Mitchell (2026 MT 201): Custody During Revocation Is Credited to the Active DOC Term Being Served; the State Is Judicially Estopped From Reclaiming Detention-Credit Error It Invited 1....

Plain-Error Resentencing Required When a Court Applies a Post-Offense Sentencing Amendment as “Mandatory”

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Plain-Error Resentencing Required When a Court Applies a Post-Offense Sentencing Amendment as “Mandatory” Case: State v. M. Partridge, 2026 MT 204N (Mont. Aug. 25, 2026) (memorandum opinion;...

State v. Hatfield (2026 MT 202) — No Delegation of Financial Sentencing Obligations to Parole; Mislabeling “Crime of Violence” Requires Striking, Not Resentencing Absent Reliance

Date: Aug 26, 2026

No Delegation of Financial Sentencing Obligations to Parole; Mislabeling “Crime of Violence” Requires Striking, Not Resentencing Absent Reliance Case: State v. T.W. Hatfield, 2026 MT 202 (Mont. Aug....

Will-Serve Letters Imply Performance Within a “Reasonable Time” and Do Not Create Perpetual Municipal Capacity Obligations

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Will-Serve Letters Imply Performance Within a “Reasonable Time” and Do Not Create Perpetual Municipal Capacity Obligations Introduction West Dev. v. Town of W. Yellowstone (2026 MT 203) arose from a...

Immediate Suspension for Noncooperation with Disciplinary Subpoenas and Unaccounted Estate Funds Under 22 NYCRR 1240.9

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Immediate Suspension for Noncooperation with Disciplinary Subpoenas and Unaccounted Estate Funds Under 22 NYCRR 1240.9 1. Introduction Matter of Stabile, Joanne (Appellate Division, Second...

State v. Keville (2026 N.H. 31): Sufficiency of Circumstantial Evidence and Post-Police-Search Disposal as Proof of Falsifying Physical Evidence

Date: Aug 26, 2026

State v. Keville (2026 N.H. 31): Sufficiency of Circumstantial Evidence and Post-Police-Search Disposal as Proof of Falsifying Physical Evidence 1. Introduction In State v. Keville, the Supreme Court...

Delaware FOIA: No Attorney-Fee Awards in State-Agency “On-the-Record” Appeals; Agencies Must Provide Sworn Search Details and Disclose Segregable Personnel-File Information (Including Anonymized Demographics)

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Delaware FOIA: No Attorney-Fee Awards in State-Agency “On-the-Record” Appeals; Agencies Must Provide Sworn Search Details and Disclose Segregable Personnel-File Information (Including Anonymized...

ALLER v. STATE (Ariz. Aug. 24, 2026) Commentary

Date: Aug 26, 2026

New Arizona Rule: Former Defendants Must Show “Particularized Need” to Use Lawfully Obtained Grand Jury Transcripts in Related Civil Suits Case: ALLER v. STATE, Supreme Court Of The State Of Arizona...

State v. Garces, Jr. (Haw. Aug. 24, 2026) — Hawaiʻi Constitution Requires an Express “Fifth Miranda Warning” and Continuing Right-to-Counsel Advisement (Prospective Only)

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Hawaiʻi Constitution Requires an Express “Fifth Miranda Warning” and Continuing Right-to-Counsel Advisement (Prospective Only) Case: State v. Garces, Jr., Supreme Court of Hawaiʻi (Aug. 24, 2026),...

UMB Bank, N.A. v. Tupulua — Standing in Foreclosure Requires Clear, Decoded Proof of Note Possession at Filing; Post-Ruling Stipulations Cannot Cure Ambiguity Inequitably

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Standing in Foreclosure Requires Clear, Decoded Proof of Note Possession at Filing; Post-Ruling Stipulations Cannot Cure Ambiguity Inequitably I. Introduction Case: UMB Bank, N.A. v. Tupulua, Supreme...