federal Case Commentaries

Credibility Is Not Enough: Corroboration May Be Required, and Post-BIA Evidence Is Excluded from Judicial Review of Removal Orders

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Credibility Is Not Enough: Corroboration May Be Required, and Post-BIA Evidence Is Excluded from Judicial Review of Removal Orders 1. Introduction Ntwari v. Bondi (10th Cir. Aug. 14, 2026) concerns a...

Temporal Proximity Alone Does Not Make a Separate State Offense “Relevant Conduct” Triggering Mandatory Concurrency Under U.S.S.G. § 5G1.3(c) on Plain-Error Review

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Temporal Proximity Alone Does Not Make a Separate State Offense “Relevant Conduct” Triggering Mandatory Concurrency Under U.S.S.G. § 5G1.3(c) on Plain-Error Review 1) Introduction In United States v....

Westfall Act Saving Provision Inapplicable to § 233(c) Deemed-Clinic Malpractice Removals (Reaffirming Evans)

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Westfall Act Saving Provision Inapplicable to § 233(c) Deemed-Clinic Malpractice Removals (Reaffirming Evans) I. Introduction In Irma Herrera v. United States of America (7th Cir. Aug. 14, 2026),...

Qualified Immunity for Arguable Probable Cause and Non–Clearly Established Juvenile Interrogation Tactics; Fair-Trial Fabrication Liability Requires Trial Use of Evidence

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Qualified Immunity for Arguable Probable Cause and Non–Clearly Established Juvenile Interrogation Tactics; Fair-Trial Fabrication Liability Requires Trial Use of Evidence Case: Johnnie Savory v....

Judicial Estoppel Requires Clear Inconsistency and Prior Judicial Acceptance; Rule 23(b)(2) Proper for Reinstatement Injunction with Incidental Reimbursement in Retiree-Health CBA Cases

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Judicial Estoppel Requires Clear Inconsistency and Prior Judicial Acceptance; Rule 23(b)(2) Proper for Reinstatement Injunction with Incidental Reimbursement in Retiree-Health CBA Cases Lynnette...

Sixth Circuit Limits Standing for Forward-Looking Relief Based on Alleged “Imprimatur” Reputational Harm from Government Citation of Third-Party “Hate Map”

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Sixth Circuit Limits Standing for Forward-Looking Relief Based on Alleged “Imprimatur” Reputational Harm from Government Citation of Third-Party “Hate Map” 1. Introduction American Freedom Law...

Indefinite Development Holds as “De Facto Finality” for Ripeness in Takings and Due-Process Land-Use Claims

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Indefinite Development Holds as “De Facto Finality” for Ripeness in Takings and Due-Process Land-Use Claims I. Introduction In SW Nashville EB Owner, LLC v. Metro. Gov't of Nashville & Davidson Cnty....

Title III “Demand” Formalities and “Come Into Possession” Limits (for Now): Sixth Circuit Denies En Banc Rehearing in United States v. Benson

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Title III “Demand” Formalities and “Come Into Possession” Limits (for Now): Sixth Circuit Denies En Banc Rehearing in United States v. Benson I. Introduction Case: United States v. Jocelyn Benson, in...

Inevitable Discovery Through Inventory Search Despite Tow-Option Omission When Towing Is Unavoidable

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Inevitable Discovery Through Inventory Search Despite Tow-Option Omission When Towing Is Unavoidable Introduction In United States v. Quantrese Brazzell (Sixth Circuit, Aug. 14, 2026), the court...

Sentencing After Drug-Quantity Verdicts: Higher Weights as “Overlapping Conduct” Under U.S.S.G. § 1B1.3(c) (and Not Necessarily “Acquitted Conduct”)

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Sentencing After Drug-Quantity Verdicts: Higher Weights as “Overlapping Conduct” Under U.S.S.G. § 1B1.3(c) (and Not Necessarily “Acquitted Conduct”) I. Introduction In United States v. Tianna Barber...

RFC Absenteeism Limits Need Evidentiary Support: Missed Appointments Alone Do Not Require a “Three Days per Month” Work-Absence Finding

Date: Aug 21, 2026

RFC Absenteeism Limits Need Evidentiary Support: Missed Appointments Alone Do Not Require a “Three Days per Month” Work-Absence Finding I. Introduction In Scott William Cartlidge v. Acting...

Rule 10b-5(b) Misstatement Liability Does Not Depend on a “Fraudulent Scheme,” but PSLRA Scienter Still Requires a Cogent Inference; Rule 9(b) Governs Securities Act Claims Sharing the Same Fraud Narrative

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Rule 10b-5(b) Misstatement Liability Does Not Depend on a “Fraudulent Scheme,” but PSLRA Scienter Still Requires a Cogent Inference; Rule 9(b) Governs Securities Act Claims Sharing the Same Fraud...

United States v. Reed: No Temporal Limitation Required for a Cellphone Warrant Tied to an Ongoing Possession Offense of Unknown Duration

Date: Aug 18, 2026

United States v. Reed: No Temporal Limitation Required for a Cellphone Warrant Tied to an Ongoing Possession Offense of Unknown Duration Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit...

Marquez-Cortez v. Bondi: Sua Sponte Issue-Exhaustion and Tightened Proof of “Social Distinction,” Nexus, and CAT Acquiescence in Gang-Violence Claims

Date: Aug 18, 2026

Marquez-Cortez v. Bondi: Sua Sponte Issue-Exhaustion and Tightened Proof of “Social Distinction,” Nexus, and CAT Acquiescence in Gang-Violence Claims 1. Introduction In Marquez-Cortez v. Bondi (10th...

Royalty Protest Clauses Bar Decades-Later Recalculations; “Adjoining Lands” Includes All Lands in Any Contiguous Lease

Date: Aug 18, 2026

Royalty Protest Clauses Bar Decades-Later Recalculations; “Adjoining Lands” Includes All Lands in Any Contiguous Lease 1. Introduction Wildcat Coal LLC v. Pacific Minerals Inc., et al. (doing...

Urena v. Travelers: EPL Endorsements Do Not Displace “All Claims” Related-Claims Clauses Absent a True Conflict

Date: Aug 18, 2026

EPL Endorsements Do Not Displace “All Claims” Related-Claims Clauses Absent a True Conflict (and Prior-and-Pending Exclusions Do Not Create Coverage) Introduction In Urena v. Travelers Casualty and...

Cosel v. Wendt (1st Cir. 2026): Federal Courts Should Avoid Unnecessary Erie Predictions on Unsettled Massachusetts Entireties-and-Divorce Creditor Rules; Nonparty May Restrain Enforcement of a Prior Judgment Under Restatement § 76

Date: Aug 18, 2026

Federal Courts Should Avoid Unnecessary Erie Predictions on Unsettled Massachusetts Entireties-and-Divorce Creditor Rules; Nonparty May Restrain Enforcement of a Prior Judgment Under Restatement § 76...

ESA Incidental-Take Plans Must Compare the Biological Value of Lost and Replacement Habitat Before Relying on Translocation/Mitigation Assumptions

Date: Aug 18, 2026

ESA Incidental-Take Plans Must Compare the Biological Value of Lost and Replacement Habitat Before Relying on Translocation/Mitigation Assumptions Case: Friends of Animals v. U.S. Fish and Wildlife...

Cross-Commissioned State Officers in Indian Country: Temporary Detention Before Confirming Indian Status Can Be “Under Color of” State Law (and Not a Jurisdictional Bar)

Date: Aug 18, 2026

Cross-Commissioned State Officers in Indian Country: Temporary Detention Before Confirming Indian Status Can Be “Under Color of” State Law (and Not a Jurisdictional Bar) 1. Introduction Walden v. The...

Retaliation-Only Witness Crimes Are Not “Obstruction of Justice” Aggravated Felonies Without Intent to Interfere with Legal Process

Date: Aug 18, 2026

Retaliation-Only Witness Crimes Are Not “Obstruction of Justice” Aggravated Felonies Without Intent to Interfere with Legal Process I. Introduction Bangs v. Blanche (1st Cir. Aug. 11, 2026) addresses...