federal Case Commentaries

“Any Other Purpose” Means Any: Subpart R Allows Case-by-Case Approval of Phosphogypsum Road Projects, and Preamble Language Cannot Override Unambiguous Regulatory Text

Date: Aug 15, 2026

“Any Other Purpose” Means Any: Subpart R Allows Case-by-Case Approval of Phosphogypsum Road Projects, and Preamble Language Cannot Override Unambiguous Regulatory Text I. Introduction In Center for...

Subchapter S Election Is Not Property of the Bankruptcy Estate: Shareholder-Controlled Tax Status Falls Outside § 541 and the § 362 Automatic Stay

Date: Aug 15, 2026

Subchapter S Election Is Not Property of the Bankruptcy Estate: Shareholder-Controlled Tax Status Falls Outside § 541 and the § 362 Automatic Stay Case: John H. Owoc v. The Liquidating Trustee on...

Express “Innocent-Insured” Intentional-Loss Exclusions Are Enforceable Under Alabama Law (and Hosey Does Not Create a Public-Policy Bar)

Date: Aug 15, 2026

Express “Innocent-Insured” Intentional-Loss Exclusions Are Enforceable Under Alabama Law (and Hosey Does Not Create a Public-Policy Bar) 1. Introduction Case: Martin Renfroe v. USAA General Indemnity...

Georgia Sovereign Immunity Not Waived by Student Handbook/Admission Letter Absent Written Consideration; ADA/RA Claims Require Plausible “By Reason Of” Causation

Date: Aug 15, 2026

Georgia Sovereign Immunity Not Waived by Student Handbook/Admission Letter Absent Written Consideration; ADA/RA Claims Require Plausible “By Reason Of” Causation Case: Shannon Waller, Jr. v. Board of...

“As Necessary” Confers Discretion: The Eleventh Circuit Upholds FRA’s Two-Person Crew Default and Treats Vacatur as Eliminating a Prior “Policy” for APA Change-in-Position Review

Date: Aug 15, 2026

“As Necessary” Confers Discretion: The Eleventh Circuit Upholds FRA’s Two-Person Crew Default and Treats Vacatur as Eliminating a Prior “Policy” for APA Change-in-Position Review Introduction In...

“As Necessary” Means Discretion: The Eleventh Circuit Upholds FRA’s Two-Person Default Crew Rule and Rejects Vacatur for Missed Rulemaking Deadlines

Date: Aug 15, 2026

“As Necessary” Means Discretion: The Eleventh Circuit Upholds FRA’s Two-Person Default Crew Rule and Rejects Vacatur for Missed Rulemaking Deadlines Introduction In Indiana Rail Road Company v....

“As Necessary” in the Federal Railroad Safety Act Confers Broad Discretion: Eleventh Circuit Upholds FRA’s Two-Person Crew Default with Risk-Based One-Person Pathways

Date: Aug 15, 2026

“As Necessary” in the Federal Railroad Safety Act Confers Broad Discretion: Eleventh Circuit Upholds FRA’s Two-Person Crew Default with Risk-Based One-Person Pathways Introduction This consolidated...

“As Necessary” Means Discretion: FRA May Adopt Precautionary Two-Person Crew Rules Without Statistical Proof, and Missing the 12‑Month Rulemaking Deadline Does Not Void the Rule

Date: Aug 15, 2026

“As Necessary” Means Discretion: FRA May Adopt Precautionary Two-Person Crew Rules Without Statistical Proof, and Missing the 12‑Month Rulemaking Deadline Does Not Void the Rule Case: Association of...

“As Necessary” Means Discretion: The Eleventh Circuit Upholds FRA’s Two-Person Crew Rule and Rejects Deadline-Vacatur and Data-Threshold Attacks

Date: Aug 15, 2026

“As Necessary” Means Discretion: The Eleventh Circuit Upholds FRA’s Two-Person Crew Rule and Rejects Deadline-Vacatur and Data-Threshold Attacks I. Introduction This consolidated set of...

“As Necessary” Means Discretion: Upholding FRA’s Two-Person Default Crew Rule Under Deferential APA Review

Date: Aug 15, 2026

“As Necessary” Means Discretion: Upholding FRA’s Two-Person Default Crew Rule Under Deferential APA Review Eleventh Circuit (Aug. 11, 2026) — consolidated petitions challenging FRA’s 2024 “Crew Size...

Post-Dismissal Allowance of § 503(b) Fees in Unconfirmed Chapter 13 Cases Under § 1326(a)(2)

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Post-Dismissal Allowance of § 503(b) Fees in Unconfirmed Chapter 13 Cases Under § 1326(a)(2) Case: Gregory Brian Myers v. Undine C. George Court: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit...

Unclassified Title, For-Cause Protection: Clear Charter Rights Trigger Pretermination Due Process Absent a “Clear and Unmistakable” Waiver

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Unclassified Title, For-Cause Protection: Clear Charter Rights Trigger Pretermination Due Process Absent a “Clear and Unmistakable” Waiver Case: Michael Washington v. City of Cincinnati Court: U.S....

Sixth Circuit: Tasing a Submissive, Non-Resisting Person Is Excessive Force; Right Clearly Established by July 2020

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Sixth Circuit: Tasing a Submissive, Non-Resisting Person Is Excessive Force; Right Clearly Established by July 2020 1. Introduction In Cornelius Phelps v. City of Saginaw, Michigan (6th Cir. Aug. 13,...

Harboring “Intent to Safeguard” Under 8 U.S.C. § 1324 May Be Inferred from Coercive Isolation and Exploitative Domestic Labor; Cultural Norms Need Not Mitigate Sentence

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Harboring “Intent to Safeguard” Under 8 U.S.C. § 1324 May Be Inferred from Coercive Isolation and Exploitative Domestic Labor; Cultural Norms Need Not Mitigate Sentence I. Introduction United States...

Pre-Enforcement Standing Requires a Credible, Plaintiff-Specific Threat: “Intellectual Diversity” Laws and Interim University Policies

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Pre-Enforcement Standing Requires a Credible, Plaintiff-Specific Threat: “Intellectual Diversity” Laws and Interim University Policies 1. Introduction David McDonald v. Trustees of Indiana University...

Mootness Risk Is Only a Factor in Rule 54(b) Certification; Monell Liability Requires Specific, Similar Patterns and Causation

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Mootness Risk Is Only a Factor in Rule 54(b) Certification; Monell Liability Requires Specific, Similar Patterns and Causation 1. Introduction Aaron Davis v. Tyler W.A. Duncan (6th Cir. Aug. 13,...

Unpaid Domestic Servitude as “Harboring for Private Financial Gain”: Intent to Shield Inferred from Coercive Control, and Credibility Attacks Rarely Defeat Sufficiency

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Unpaid Domestic Servitude as “Harboring for Private Financial Gain”: Intent to Shield Inferred from Coercive Control, and Credibility Attacks Rarely Defeat Sufficiency 1. Introduction United States...

Post-Release “Registration” Orders Are Unauthorized Absent a Term of Supervised Release

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Post-Release “Registration” Orders Are Unauthorized Absent a Term of Supervised Release United States v. Jerid Hinz (7th Cir. Aug. 13, 2026) 1. Introduction In United States v. Jerid Hinz, the...

Gray-Market Prescription Drugs: “Material Differences” and Quality-Control Bypass Render Foreign-Labeled Medicines Non-Genuine Under the Lanham Act; Contributory Liability Requires Knowledge (Not Prior Notice or “Control”)

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Gray-Market Prescription Drugs: “Material Differences” and Quality-Control Bypass Render Foreign-Labeled Medicines Non-Genuine Under the Lanham Act; Contributory Liability Requires Knowledge (Not...

Sixth Circuit: No § 2255 Evidentiary Hearing Where the Record Forecloses Prejudice from Alleged Misadvice on a Physician’s Good-Faith Defense Under 21 U.S.C. § 841(a)

Date: Aug 14, 2026

Sixth Circuit: No § 2255 Evidentiary Hearing Where the Record Forecloses Prejudice from Alleged Misadvice on a Physician’s Good-Faith Defense Under 21 U.S.C. § 841(a) I. Introduction In Afzal Beemath...