federal Case Commentaries

Pleading “Context” and Clearly-Established Law to Defeat Qualified Immunity in Fifth Circuit Excessive-Force Cases

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Pleading “Context” and Clearly-Established Law to Defeat Qualified Immunity in Fifth Circuit Excessive-Force Cases Introduction Hughey v. Tippah County (5th Cir. Aug. 20, 2026) arises from an alleged...

§ 523(a)(6) Nondischargeability in the Fifth Circuit: “Objective Substantial Certainty of Harm” Suffices Without Subjective Intent to Injure

Date: Aug 26, 2026

§ 523(a)(6) Nondischargeability in the Fifth Circuit: “Objective Substantial Certainty of Harm” Suffices Without Subjective Intent to Injure Introduction Mahadevan v. Bikkina is a Fifth Circuit...

Threat of Custodial Arrest to Secure an Unannotated Signature on a Texas Traffic Citation Does Not, Without More, State a Fourth or Fourteenth Amendment § 1983 Claim

Date: Aug 26, 2026

Threat of Custodial Arrest to Secure an Unannotated Signature on a Texas Traffic Citation Does Not, Without More, State a Fourth or Fourteenth Amendment § 1983 Claim I. Introduction In Soward v....

IDEA “Stay-Put” Relief Is Unavailable for Past, Completed School Years Absent a Showing of Current Jeopardy (and Post-Relief Claims Are Moot)

Date: Aug 26, 2026

IDEA “Stay-Put” Relief Is Unavailable for Past, Completed School Years Absent a Showing of Current Jeopardy (and Post-Relief Claims Are Moot) 1. Introduction Juca v. Banks (2d Cir. Aug. 20, 2026)...

Exhaustion-Enforced Waiver and CAT Acquiescence: Failure to Challenge Nexus Before the BIA Bars Asylum/Withholding Review

Date: Aug 25, 2026

Exhaustion-Enforced Waiver and CAT Acquiescence: Failure to Challenge Nexus Before the BIA Bars Asylum/Withholding Review 1. Introduction In Cesar Plaza Rivera v. Attorney General United States of...

Third Circuit: Applying Ross “On‑Mission” Categories to Passenger Questioning and Construing “Can I Search You?” as General Consent to a Full Pat-Down

Date: Aug 25, 2026

Third Circuit: Applying Ross “On‑Mission” Categories to Passenger Questioning and Construing “Can I Search You?” as General Consent to a Full Pat-Down I. Introduction United States v. Christopher...

Drug-Premises Enhancement Applies When Drug Distribution Is a Significant (Not Sole) Purpose of a Residence

Date: Aug 25, 2026

Drug-Premises Enhancement Applies When Drug Distribution Is a Significant (Not Sole) Purpose of a Residence 1. Introduction In United States v. Jason Mika (3d Cir. Aug. 21, 2026) (nonprecedential),...

Rule 33 New Trials for Deadlock Instructions: Misstatement “You Have to” Requires Undue Coercion and Prejudice in Context

Date: Aug 25, 2026

Rule 33 New Trials for Deadlock Instructions: Misstatement “You Have to” Requires Undue Coercion and Prejudice in Context I. Introduction United States v. Philip Epps (Third Circuit, Aug. 21, 2026)...

FDA’s “Comparative-Efficacy” PMTA Requirement Is a Substantive Rule Requiring APA Notice-and-Comment

Date: Aug 24, 2026

FDA’s “Comparative-Efficacy” PMTA Requirement Is a Substantive Rule Requiring APA Notice-and-Comment 1. Introduction In NicQuid, L.L.C. v. FDA, a consolidated set of petitions, multiple e-cigarette...

Free Return Travel and Anecdotal Country Conditions Do Not Compel Asylum/CAT Relief Absent a “Pattern of Sustained Pursuit”

Date: Aug 24, 2026

Free Return Travel and Anecdotal Country Conditions Do Not Compel Asylum/CAT Relief Absent a “Pattern of Sustained Pursuit” Case: Zhuravlev v. Blanche, No. 25-60410 (5th Cir. Aug. 19, 2026) (per...

Pipeline Safety Act Citizen Suits: The 60‑Day Notice-and-Delay Requirement Is a Mandatory Condition Precedent Requiring Dismissal

Date: Aug 24, 2026

Pipeline Safety Act Citizen Suits: The 60‑Day Notice-and-Delay Requirement Is a Mandatory Condition Precedent Requiring Dismissal 1. Introduction Sunoco Pipeline LP v. Daniel La Hart (3d Cir. Aug....

Florida Robbery by Sudden Snatching Categorically Qualifies as an INA “Theft Offense” Aggravated Felony

Date: Aug 24, 2026

Florida Robbery by Sudden Snatching Categorically Qualifies as an INA “Theft Offense” Aggravated Felony 1. Introduction In Rishi Ramdial v. U.S. Attorney General (11th Cir. Aug. 21, 2026), the...

Catanese v. Curtis — Conclusory Fourth Amendment Claims, Waiver, and Qualified Immunity in Emergency-Aid “Sober Home” Entries

Date: Aug 24, 2026

Catanese v. Curtis — Conclusory Fourth Amendment Claims, Waiver, and Qualified Immunity in Emergency-Aid “Sober Home” Entries 1. Introduction Catanese v. Curtis (1st Cir. Aug. 21, 2026) arose from...

Catanese v. Curtis — Conclusory Fourth Amendment Allegations Cannot Defeat Summary Judgment; Qualified Immunity for Follow-On Emergency-Aid Entries

Date: Aug 24, 2026

Conclusory Fourth Amendment Allegations Cannot Defeat Summary Judgment; Qualified Immunity for Follow-On Emergency-Aid Entries Catanese v. Curtis (1st Cir. Aug. 21, 2026) I. Introduction This case...

APA Notice-and-Comment Required for FDA’s “Comparative Efficacy” PMTA Standard When Imposed Through Informal Adjudication

Date: Aug 24, 2026

APA Notice-and-Comment Required for FDA’s “Comparative Efficacy” PMTA Standard When Imposed Through Informal Adjudication Case: Elite Brothers, L.L.C. v. FDA (consolidated petitions including...

FDA “Comparative Efficacy” PMTA Requirement Is a Substantive Rule Requiring APA Notice-and-Comment

Date: Aug 24, 2026

FDA “Comparative Efficacy” PMTA Requirement Is a Substantive Rule Requiring APA Notice-and-Comment Case: Vertigo Vapor, L.L.C. v. FDA (consolidated petitions) Court: United States Court of Appeals...

CAFA Local-Controversy “Significant Basis” Requires a Conduct-Comparative Analysis; § 1291 Review Barred When Jurisdictional Remand Characterization Is Colorable

Date: Aug 24, 2026

CAFA Local-Controversy “Significant Basis” Requires a Conduct-Comparative Analysis; § 1291 Review Barred When Jurisdictional Remand Characterization Is Colorable 1. Introduction Daniel La Hart and...

Nonsignatory Cannot Invoke a Delegation Clause Absent Clear Assent; Texas Direct-Benefits Estoppel May Still Compel Arbitration of Warranty Claims

Date: Aug 24, 2026

Nonsignatory Cannot Invoke a Delegation Clause Absent Clear Assent; Texas Direct-Benefits Estoppel May Still Compel Arbitration of Warranty Claims Introduction In Greg Kerr v. General Motors LLC (3d...

Dismissals Based on Rooker-Feldman or Eleventh Amendment Immunity Must Be Without Prejudice; Other Claim-Defeating Doctrines May Warrant With-Prejudice Dismissal

Date: Aug 24, 2026

Dismissals Based on Rooker-Feldman or Eleventh Amendment Immunity Must Be Without Prejudice; Other Claim-Defeating Doctrines May Warrant With-Prejudice Dismissal Introduction In Richard Silverberg v....

Chain of Custody Need Not Be Proven Beyond a Reasonable Doubt in the Third Circuit

Date: Aug 24, 2026

Chain of Custody Need Not Be Proven Beyond a Reasonable Doubt in the Third Circuit Introduction In United States v. Kenneth Strickland (3d Cir. Aug. 18, 2026), Kenneth Strickland appealed jury...