Puerto Rico Case Commentaries

Imperfect Breath-Test Observation Does Not Require Exclusion: Reliability Must Be Established from the Whole Record

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Imperfect Breath-Test Observation Does Not Require Exclusion: Reliability Must Be Established from the Whole Record Case: Derek Alexander Knapp v. Commissioner of Public Safety Court: Supreme Court...

Workers’ Compensation Appeals Must Respect Supported Implicit Findings on Expert Foundation

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Workers’ Compensation Appeals Must Respect Supported Implicit Findings on Expert Foundation Case: Jennifer Williams v. Delta Air Lines, Inc., and ACE USA, administered by Sedgwick Claims Management...

Florida Clarifies Final-Order Rehearing and Separates It from Jury New-Trial Practice

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Florida Clarifies Final-Order Rehearing and Separates It from Jury New-Trial Practice Case: In Re: Amendments to Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.530, Florida Small Claims Rule 7.180, and Florida...

Late-Filed Charges Do Not Warrant Automatic Speedy-Trial Discharge: Florida Requires Notice and Recapture

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Late-Filed Charges Do Not Warrant Automatic Speedy-Trial Discharge: Florida Requires Notice and Recapture Case: State of Florida v. Deangelo Robinson Court: Supreme Court of Florida Case number:...

ADA Retaliatory Hostile-Environment Claims Require Material Adversity and But-For Causation

Date: Nov 17, 2026

ADA Retaliatory Hostile-Environment Claims Require Material Adversity and But-For Causation Case: Melissa Smith v. Emory Health Inc. Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit...

Qualified Immunity in Home Death Investigations: Unsettled Law and the Need to Properly Request Amendment

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Qualified Immunity in Home Death Investigations: Unsettled Law and the Need to Properly Request Amendment Case: Nadine Frakes v. City of Boynton Beach Court: United States Court of Appeals for the...

Guaranteed-Value Auto Coverage: Repair Costs Govern Unless the Policy’s Total-Loss Conditions Are Met

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Guaranteed-Value Auto Coverage: Repair Costs Govern Unless the Policy’s Total-Loss Conditions Are Met Case: Weston Phillips v. Hagerty Insurance Agency, LLC Court: United States Court of Appeals for...

Curable Diversity Defects Do Not Excuse Nonspecific Objections to a Magistrate Judge’s Report

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Curable Diversity Defects Do Not Excuse Nonspecific Objections to a Magistrate Judge’s Report Case: Zak Shaik v. TokMedia Enterprises, LLC Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh...

Deference to Labor Arbitration When a Collective Bargaining Agreement Incorporates Statutory Duties

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Deference to Labor Arbitration When a Collective Bargaining Agreement Incorporates Statutory Duties Case: PPL Electric Utilities v. IBEW Local 1600 Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Third...

Pennsylvania F3 Robbery Is Not Generic Robbery Under the 2021 Sentencing Guidelines

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Pennsylvania F3 Robbery Is Not Generic Robbery: Mere Snatching Cannot Support the Guidelines Enhancement Case: United States v. Mashaq White, No. 22-2197, United States Court of Appeals for the Third...

Revocation Sentencing: Prior Leniency May Inform Deterrence, but Not Retribution

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Revocation Sentencing: Prior Leniency May Inform Deterrence, but Not Retribution Case: United States v. Thomas Autry, No. 25-2490 Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit Decided:...

Digital Plain View: Opening Files Within an Authorized Search and Discovering Evidence of Another Crime

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Digital Plain View: Opening Files Within an Authorized Search and Discovering Evidence of Another Crime Case: United States v. Troy Anderson, No. 25-2680 Court: United States Court of Appeals for the...

Full-Scheme Drug Sentencing and the Limits of Recusal Based on a Litigant’s Attacks

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Full-Scheme Drug Sentencing and the Limits of Recusal Based on a Litigant’s Attacks Case: United States v. William Richardson Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit Filed:...

Overbroad Journalist-Metadata Orders Are Challengeable Under the Stored Communications Act, and Secrecy Orders Require Meaningful Tailoring

Date: Nov 16, 2026

Overbroad Journalist-Metadata Orders Are Challengeable Under the Stored Communications Act, and Secrecy Orders Require Meaningful Tailoring Case: In re: Application of the United States of America...

United States v. Anthony Lynch: Ground-Specific Preservation of Rule 11 Errors and the Limits of Appeal Waivers

Date: Nov 16, 2026

United States v. Anthony Lynch: Ground-Specific Preservation of Rule 11 Errors and the Limits of Appeal Waivers Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit Case: No. 24-4343 Decided:...

Gore v. State Farm: Evidence and Documentation Requirements for Resisting Insurance Summary Judgment

Date: Nov 16, 2026

Gore v. State Farm: Evidence and Documentation Requirements for Resisting Insurance Summary Judgment Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit Case: No. 25-60625 Decision date:...

Admission into Evidence Does Not Permit a Pleading to Enter the Jury Room Under Alabama Rule 51

Date: Nov 16, 2026

Admission into Evidence Does Not Permit a Pleading to Enter the Jury Room Under Alabama Rule 51 Case: Pharming Capital, LLC v. Turner, No. SC-2025-0453 Court: Supreme Court of Alabama Opinion date:...

State Ownership and Financial Integration Alone Do Not Confer § 14 Immunity on a University’s Healthcare LLC

Date: Nov 16, 2026

State Ownership and Financial Integration Alone Do Not Confer § 14 Immunity on a University’s Healthcare LLC Case: Marsh v. U.S.A. Healthcare Management, LLC Court: Supreme Court of Alabama Decision...

Potential Mootness and Interdependent Claims Limit Rule 54(b) Certification

Date: Nov 16, 2026

Potential Mootness and Interdependent Claims Limit Rule 54(b) Certification Case: Carpenter v. Jacobs Court: Supreme Court of Alabama Date: November 13, 2026 Opinion: Justice Cook Disposition: Appeal...

Certified Questions May Be Declined After Acceptance: Unresolved Telecommunications Rights at Railroad Crossings

Date: Nov 16, 2026

Certified Questions May Be Declined After Acceptance: Unresolved Telecommunications Rights at Railroad Crossings Case: Norfolk Southern Corporation et al. v. Bellsouth Telecommunications, LLC, d/b/a...