Pennsylvania Case Commentaries

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Rejects Market Share Liability in Lead Poisoning Case

Date: Feb 20, 1997

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Rejects Market Share Liability in Lead Poisoning Case Introduction The case of Dominique D. Skipworth, a minor, represented by her legal guardians Pandora Williams and...

Reining in Judicial Delays: Standards Established in In Re: Jeffrey Alan Smith

Date: Dec 11, 1996

Reining in Judicial Delays: Standards Established in In Re: Jeffrey Alan Smith Introduction The case of In Re: Jeffrey Alan Smith addresses critical issues surrounding judicial accountability,...

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Establishes Limits on County Waste Flow Control Ordinances Under Commerce and Contracts Clauses

Date: Nov 2, 1996

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Establishes Limits on County Waste Flow Control Ordinances Under Commerce and Contracts Clauses Introduction The case of Empire Sanitary Landfill, Inc. and Danella...

Timely Filing of Appeals by Pro Se Inmates: Smith v. Pennsylvania Board of Probation and Parole

Date: Sep 25, 1996

Timely Filing of Appeals by Pro Se Inmates: Smith v. Pennsylvania Board of Probation and Parole Introduction Smith v. Pennsylvania Board of Probation and Parole is a landmark decision by the Supreme...

Affirmation of Death Sentence and Ineffective Assistance of Counsel in Commonwealth v. Jones

Date: Sep 19, 1996

Affirmation of Death Sentence and Ineffective Assistance of Counsel in Commonwealth v. Jones Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Gilbert Jones, decided on September 18, 1996, by the Supreme...

Reaffirming Standards for Awarding Attorney Fees in Frivolous Litigation: Thunberg v. Straus et al.

Date: Sep 18, 1996

Reaffirming Standards for Awarding Attorney Fees in Frivolous Litigation: Thunberg v. Straus et al. Introduction The case of Janice Lee Thunberg v. Howard Straus, Diana Gazey, Administratrix of the...

At-Will Employment and Administrative Hearings: Insights from Werner v. Zazyczny

Date: Aug 22, 1996

At-Will Employment and Administrative Hearings: Insights from Werner v. Zazyczny Introduction The case of Daniel H. Werner, Jr. v. Joseph L. Zazyczny, decided by the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania on...

Evaluation of Aggravating Circumstances in Capital Sentencing: Commonwealth v. Auker

Date: Aug 1, 1996

Evaluation of Aggravating Circumstances in Capital Sentencing: Commonwealth v. Auker Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Robert Donald Auker (545 Pa. 521) is a seminal case adjudicated by...

Barud v. Commonwealth: Unconstitutional DUI Statute under 75 Pa.C.S.A. § 3731(a)(5)

Date: Jul 31, 1996

Barud v. Commonwealth: Unconstitutional DUI Statute under 75 Pa.C.S.A. § 3731(a)(5) Introduction In Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. David M. Barud (545 Pa. 297, 1996), the Supreme Court of...

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Upholds General Assembly's Preemption of Municipal Assault Weapon Regulations

Date: Jul 19, 1996

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Upholds General Assembly's Preemption of Municipal Assault Weapon Regulations Introduction The case of Councilman Angel Ortiz et al. v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania...

Expanding Appellate Remedies: Appeal Nunc Pro Tunc in Summary Criminal Cases

Date: Jun 27, 1996

Expanding Appellate Remedies: Appeal Nunc Pro Tunc in Summary Criminal Cases Introduction The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, in the landmark case Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Christopher Stock...

Exclusive Representation by County Commissioners in PLRB Proceedings Established

Date: Jun 20, 1996

Exclusive Representation by County Commissioners in PLRB Proceedings Established Introduction In the landmark case of The County of Berks, ex rel. Mark C. Baldwin, District Attorney v. Pennsylvania...

Affirmation of Absolute Privilege for High Public Officials in Defamation Cases

Date: Jun 19, 1996

Affirmation of Absolute Privilege for High Public Officials in Defamation Cases Introduction The case of Stanley B. Lindner v. James F. Mollan addressed the application of the doctrine of absolute...

Strict Limits on Independent Source Doctrine: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Melendez

Date: May 23, 1996

Strict Limits on Independent Source Doctrine: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Melendez Introduction In Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Melendez, 544 Pa. 323 (1996), the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania...

Summary Judgment Standards in Defamation Cases Involving Public Figures: Ertel v. Patriot-News

Date: Apr 18, 1996

Summary Judgment Standards in Defamation Cases Involving Public Figures: Ertel v. Patriot-News Introduction The case of Allen E. Ertel v. The Patriot-News Company, Dick Sarge, and William C....

Asymptomatic Pleural Thickening Not Compensable: Simmons v. PACOR, Inc. and Others

Date: Apr 5, 1996

Asymptomatic Pleural Thickening Not Compensable: Simmons v. PACOR, Inc. and Others Introduction The case of James R. and Eleanor Simmons, Theodore and Mary Murray, and William and Paula Giffear...

Parole Jurisdiction in Consecutive Sentences: Clarification of the Parole Board's Authority

Date: Mar 30, 1996

Parole Jurisdiction in Consecutive Sentences: Clarification of the Parole Board's Authority Introduction The case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Tilghman, Jamison, and Hall presents a pivotal...

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Limits Application of Bethea to Constitutional Factors in Sentencing Departures

Date: Mar 30, 1996

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Limits Application of Bethea to Constitutional Factors in Sentencing Departures Introduction The case of COMMONWEALTH of Pennsylvania v. Sandra Smith (543 Pa. 566) presents...

Finality of Criminal Convictions for Collateral Estoppel in Civil Proceedings: SHAFFER v. SMITH

Date: Mar 29, 1996

Finality of Criminal Convictions for Collateral Estoppel in Civil Proceedings: SHAFFER v. SMITH, 543 Pa. 526 (1996) Introduction The landmark case of SHAFFER v. SMITH, decided by the Supreme Court of...

Negligence Standard Affirmed for Prescription Drug Liability: An Analysis of Hahn v. Upjohn

Date: Mar 29, 1996

Negligence Standard Affirmed for Prescription Drug Liability: An Analysis of Hahn v. Upjohn 543 Pa. 558, Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1996 Introduction The case of Charles D. Hahn v. Howard A....