Pennsylvania Case Commentaries

Establishing Employer's Burden in Terminating Workers' Compensation Benefits: Insights from Susan Udvari v. USAir, Inc.

Date: Dec 25, 1997

Establishing Employer's Burden in Terminating Workers' Compensation Benefits: Insights from Susan Udvari v. USAir, Inc. Introduction The case of Susan Udvari v. USAir, Inc. (550 Pa. 319), adjudicated...

Comprehensive Commentary on Riccio v. American Republic Insurance Company: Interpretation of 'Spine' in Policy Exclusions and Coordinated Jurisdiction Rule

Date: Dec 24, 1997

Interpretation of 'Spine' in Insurance Policy Exclusions and Coordinated Jurisdiction Rule: Riccio v. American Republic Insurance Company Introduction Antonio N. Riccio, the appellant, filed a...

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Commonwealth v. Gribble: Upholding Specific Intent and Proportionality Review

Date: Nov 21, 1997

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Commonwealth v. Gribble: Upholding Specific Intent and Proportionality Review Introduction The case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. William R. Gribble reached the...

Caterpillar, Inc. v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review: Employee Speech in Support of Union Activity Not Willful Misconduct

Date: Nov 21, 1997

Caterpillar, Inc. v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review: Employee Speech in Support of Union Activity Not Willful Misconduct Introduction The case of Caterpillar, Inc., Appellant, v....

Affirmation of Severance Discretion and State of Mind Hearsay Exception in Commonwealth v. Collins

Date: Nov 21, 1997

Affirmation of Severance Discretion and State of Mind Hearsay Exception in Commonwealth v. Collins Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Ronald Collins (550 Pa. 46) is a significant case...

Reaffirmation of Rape Shield Law Protections: Commonwealth v. Weber

Date: Sep 19, 1997

Reaffirmation of Rape Shield Law Protections: Commonwealth v. Weber Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael P. Weber is a landmark 1997 decision by the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania that...

Establishing the "Prisoner Mailbox" Rule for Timely Appeals by Pro Se Incarcerated Appellants

Date: Sep 18, 1997

Establishing the "Prisoner Mailbox" Rule for Timely Appeals by Pro Se Incarcerated Appellants Introduction COMMONWEALTH of Pennsylvania v. David Jones, Appellee, (549 Pa. 58) is a pivotal case...

Affirmation of Death Penalty with Prior Murder Conviction as Aggravating Factor in COMMONWEALTH v. HAWKINS

Date: Sep 18, 1997

Affirmation of Death Penalty with Prior Murder Conviction as Aggravating Factor in COMMONWEALTH v. HAWKINS Introduction In the landmark case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Thomas W. Hawkins, Jr.,...

Procedural Safeguards and Prosecutorial Conduct in Capital Cases: Commonwealth v. Morales

Date: Sep 18, 1997

Procedural Safeguards and Prosecutorial Conduct in Capital Cases: Commonwealth v. Morales Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Salvador Morales, decided on September 17, 1997, by the Supreme...

Affirmation of Death Penalty in Commonwealth v. Hall: An In-Depth Analysis

Date: Sep 18, 1997

Affirmation of Death Penalty in Commonwealth v. Hall: An In-Depth Analysis Introduction The case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Darrick Hall (549 Pa. 269) serves as a pivotal example in...

Substance Over Procedure: CINTAS CORP. v. LEE'S CLEANING SERVICES Upholds Proper Service Despite Minor Return of Service Defect

Date: Sep 17, 1997

Substance Over Procedure: CINTAS CORP. v. LEE'S CLEANING SERVICES Upholds Proper Service Despite Minor Return of Service Defect Introduction The case of Cintas Corporation v. Lee's Cleaning Services,...

Discovery Rule and Repressed Memory in Statute of Limitations: Dalrymple v. Brown

Date: Aug 26, 1997

Discovery Rule and Repressed Memory in Statute of Limitations: Dalrymple v. Brown Introduction Linda Parisano Dalrymple v. Eugene Brown is a landmark case decided by the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania...

Res Ipsa Loquitur in Medical Malpractice: Hightower-Warren & Jones-Wright v. Silk Establishes New Precedent

Date: Jul 24, 1997

Res Ipsa Loquitur in Medical Malpractice: Hightower-Warren & Jones-Wright v. Silk Establishes New Precedent Introduction The case of Nadine Hightower-Warren and Desiree Jones-Wright, Guardians for...

Enhanced Scrutiny for Anonymous Tips in Terry Stops: Insights from Commonwealth v. Jackson

Date: Jul 24, 1997

Enhanced Scrutiny for Anonymous Tips in Terry Stops: Insights from Commonwealth v. Jackson Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Carl Jackson, 548 Pa. 484 (1997), is a seminal case that...

Establishing Corporate Negligence in Healthcare: Welsh v. Nason Hospital

Date: Jul 24, 1997

Establishing Corporate Negligence in Healthcare: Welsh v. Nason Hospital Introduction The case of Bobbi Jo Welsh, acting as the Administratrix of the Estate of Kyle A. Gaines, Deceased, and Bobbi Jo...

Mandatory Award of Attorneys' Fees for Prevailing Employees under the Wage Payment and Collection Law: Oberneder v. Link Computer Corp.

Date: Jun 18, 1997

Mandatory Award of Attorneys' Fees for Prevailing Employees under the Wage Payment and Collection Law: Oberneder v. Link Computer Corp. Introduction Oberneder v. Link Computer Corp., decided by the...

Defining Gross Negligence Under the Mental Health Procedures Act: Insights from Albright v. Abington Memorial Hospital

Date: Jun 18, 1997

Defining Gross Negligence Under the Mental Health Procedures Act: Insights from Albright v. Abington Memorial Hospital Introduction The case of John W. Albright, as executor of the Estate of...

Duty to Defend Affirmed in General Accident Insurance Co. v. Allen

Date: Apr 24, 1997

Duty to Defend Affirmed in General Accident Insurance Co. of America v. Eugene R. Allen et al. (547 Pa. 693) Introduction The case of General Accident Insurance Company of America (Appellant) versus...

Judicial Conduct and Procedural Limitations: The Cicchetti Case Analysis

Date: Apr 1, 1997

Judicial Conduct and Procedural Limitations: The Cicchetti Case Analysis Introduction The case of Richard D. Cicchetti, Former Judge and President Judge of the Court of Common Pleas in Fayette...

Superseding Cause and Adequate Warnings in Product Liability: Davis v. Berwind Corporation

Date: Feb 25, 1997

Superseding Cause and Adequate Warnings in Product Liability: Davis v. Berwind Corporation Introduction The case of Kimberly Davis v. Berwind Corporation, Bepex Corporation, and Boldt Industries,...