Pennsylvania Case Commentaries

Affirmation of Post-Conviction Relief Denial in Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Mumia Abu-Jamal

Date: Oct 30, 1998

Affirmation of Post-Conviction Relief Denial in Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Mumia Abu-Jamal Introduction In the landmark case of COMMONWEALTH of Pennsylvania v. Mumia Abu-Jamal, the Supreme Court...

Preservation of Appellate Issues under Pa.R.Crim.P. 1410: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Frank Lord

Date: Oct 29, 1998

Preservation of Appellate Issues under Pa.R.Crim.P. 1410: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Frank Lord Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Frank Lord is a pivotal decision rendered by the...

Reaffirmation of Standards for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel and Brady Compliance in Post-Conviction Relief: Commonwealth v. Copenhefer

Date: Oct 6, 1998

Reaffirmation of Standards for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel and Brady Compliance in Post-Conviction Relief: Commonwealth v. Copenhefer Introduction In the landmark case of Commonwealth of...

Effective Assistance of Counsel in Capital Cases: Insights from Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Melvin K. Howard

Date: Oct 2, 1998

Effective Assistance of Counsel in Capital Cases: Insights from Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Melvin K. Howard Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Melvin K. Howard, 553 Pa. 266,...

Common Pleas Court's Authority Over Recount Petitions: Establishing Jurisdictional Defects in Verification

Date: Oct 1, 1998

Common Pleas Court's Authority Over Recount Petitions: Establishing Jurisdictional Defects in Verification Introduction The In re OPENING OF BALLOT BOXES, MONTOUR COUNTY, Pennsylvania, appeals by...

Protection Against Retaliatory Discharge for Workers' Compensation Claims Established in Pennsylvania

Date: Aug 21, 1998

Protection Against Retaliatory Discharge for Workers' Compensation Claims Established in Pennsylvania Introduction The case of David L. Shick v. Donald L. Shirey Lumber serves as a landmark decision...

Personal Privacy Expectation Required for Standing in Search and Seizure Cases: Commonwealth v. Hawkins

Date: Aug 20, 1998

Personal Privacy Expectation Required for Standing in Search and Seizure Cases: Commonwealth v. Hawkins Introduction In the landmark case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Raphieal Lamon Hawkins,...

KITUSKIE v. CORBMAN: Establishing the Relevance of Collectibility in Legal Malpractice Actions

Date: Aug 8, 1998

KITUSKIE v. CORBMAN: Establishing the Relevance of Collectibility in Legal Malpractice Actions Introduction KITUSKIE v. CORBMAN, et al., 552 Pa. 275 (1998), marks a significant milestone in...

Reaffirming the Sufficiency of Eyewitness Evidence and Limitations on Ineffective Counsel Claims in Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Dennis

Date: Jul 23, 1998

Reaffirming the Sufficiency of Eyewitness Evidence and Limitations on Ineffective Counsel Claims in Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Dennis Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. James Dennis is...

Adams Sanitation Company, Inc. v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania: Expanding Environmental Responsibility Under Section 316 of the Clean Streams Law

Date: Jul 22, 1998

Adams Sanitation Company, Inc. v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania: Expanding Environmental Responsibility Under Section 316 of the Clean Streams Law Introduction Adams Sanitation Company, Inc. v....

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Spotz: Specific Intent and Accomplice Liability

Date: Jul 21, 1998

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Spotz: Specific Intent and Accomplice Liability Introduction The case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Mark Spotz (552 Pa. 499,...

Clarifying Scienter: Pennsylvania Supreme Court Sets Standard for Attorney Misrepresentation Under Rule 8.4(c)

Date: Jul 9, 1998

Clarifying Scienter: Pennsylvania Supreme Court Sets Standard for Attorney Misrepresentation Under Rule 8.4(c) Introduction In the landmark case Office of Disciplinary Counsel v. Anonymous Attorney...

Collateral Estoppel Limitations in Unemployment Compensation Proceedings: RUE v. K-MART CORP.

Date: Jun 17, 1998

Collateral Estoppel Limitations in Unemployment Compensation Proceedings: RUE v. K-MART CORP. Introduction Patricia RUE v. K-MART CORPoration is a landmark decision by the Supreme Court of...

Resentencing Protocols and Aggravating Circumstances in Commonwealth v. Lesko

Date: May 22, 1998

Resentencing Protocols and Aggravating Circumstances in Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Lesko Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. John Charles Lesko is a landmark case adjudicated by the...

Enforceability of "Household Exclusion" Clauses in Underinsured Motorist Coverage: Analysis of Eichelman v. Nationwide Insurance Company

Date: May 22, 1998

Enforceability of "Household Exclusion" Clauses in Underinsured Motorist Coverage: Analysis of Eichelman v. Nationwide Insurance Company Introduction Eichelman v. Nationwide Insurance Company is a...

Deference to Jury Credibility Determinations: Insights from Martin v. Evans

Date: Apr 25, 1998

Deference to Jury Credibility Determinations: Insights from Martin v. Evans Introduction In the landmark case of Martin v. Evans, 551 Pa. 496 (1998), the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania addressed...

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Abandons Presumption of Prejudice in Inactivity Dismissals: Jacobs v. Halloran

Date: Apr 3, 1998

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Abandons Presumption of Prejudice in Inactivity Dismissals: Jacobs v. Halloran Introduction Lisa R. Jacobs v. Harry Halloran, Patricia Halloran, Lynda Fyffe-McFadden,...

Incorporating Non-Docket Activity in Case Inactivity Evaluations: Marino v. Hackman et al.

Date: Apr 3, 1998

Incorporating Non-Docket Activity in Case Inactivity Evaluations: Marino v. Hackman et al. Introduction Charles and Mollie Marino v. James Harry Hackman, Jay Rollman Sons, and William Rollman Truck...

Reversing Parental Rights Termination: Emphasizing Child Welfare Under Section 2511 of the Pennsylvania Adoption Act

Date: Mar 28, 1998

Reversing Parental Rights Termination: Emphasizing Child Welfare Under Section 2511 of the Pennsylvania Adoption Act Introduction The case titled In the Matter of the Adoption of Charles E.D. M. II...

Totality of Circumstances in Assessing Voluntary Confessions: Commonwealth v. Nester

Date: Mar 26, 1998

Totality of Circumstances in Assessing Voluntary Confessions: Commonwealth v. Nester Introduction The case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jeffrey Nester (551 Pa. 157, 1998) marks a significant...