Pennsylvania Case Commentaries

Collateral Order Doctrine Affirmed in BEN v. SCHWARTZ: Expanding Appealability of Discovery Orders

Date: Apr 22, 1999

Collateral Order Doctrine Affirmed in BEN v. SCHWARTZ: Expanding Appealability of Discovery Orders Introduction In the landmark case Ewa Marta Ben and Arthur T. Ben v. Burton Schwartz, D.D.S. and Dr....

Collateral Order Doctrine and Settlement Approval: Analysis of Cosmo Geniviva v. Frisk

Date: Apr 2, 1999

Collateral Order Doctrine and Settlement Approval: Analysis of Cosmo Geniviva, Jr. v. Nick A. Frisk, Jr. Introduction The case of Cosmo S. Geniviva, Jr., Executor of the Estate of Helen U. Geniviva...

Exemption Criteria Under 72 P.S. § 7202(b) Clarified in Glenn Johnston, Inc. v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania

Date: Mar 27, 1999

Exemption Criteria Under 72 P.S. § 7202(b) Clarified in Glenn Johnston, Inc. v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Introduction Glenn Johnston, Inc. v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania is a pivotal case...

Knowing Endangerment Exclusion: No Duty to Defend or Indemnify Haver Pharmacy

Date: Mar 6, 1999

Knowing Endangerment Exclusion: No Duty to Defend or Indemnify Haver Pharmacy Introduction The legal landscape of professional liability insurance often hinges on the precise language of insurance...

Standard for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel under the Post Conviction Relief Act: Insights from Commonwealth v. Kimball

Date: Jan 23, 1999

Standard for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel under the Post Conviction Relief Act: Insights from Commonwealth v. Kimball Introduction The case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Daniel Kimball, 555...

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Affirms Reider: Parole Denials Remain Outside Judicial Review

Date: Jan 23, 1999

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Affirms Reider: Parole Denials Remain Outside Judicial Review Introduction In the landmark case of Nathaniel Rogers, Christopher Reed, and Michael K. Meehan v....

Immunity of General Contractors as Statutory Employers under the Workers' Compensation Act

Date: Jan 22, 1999

Immunity of General Contractors as Statutory Employers under the Workers' Compensation Act Introduction The case of William Fonner v. Shandon, Inc. and Jendoco Construction Corporation (No....

Commonwealth v. Pursell: Reinforcing Standards for Ineffective Assistance of Post-Conviction Counsel in PCRA Proceedings

Date: Jan 20, 1999

Commonwealth v. Pursell: Reinforcing Standards for Ineffective Assistance of Post-Conviction Counsel in PCRA Proceedings Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Alan Pursell, 555 Pa. 233 (1999),...

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Upholds Department of Corrections' Authority over Inmate Clothing Regulations

Date: Dec 24, 1998

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Upholds Department of Corrections' Authority over Inmate Clothing Regulations Introduction The case of Elwood Small et al. v. Martin F. Horn, Secretary, Department of...

Revisiting Appellate Review Standards for Mandatory Minimum Sentencing: Commonwealth v. Myers (1998)

Date: Dec 24, 1998

Revisiting Appellate Review Standards for Mandatory Minimum Sentencing: Commonwealth v. Myers (1998) Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Deborah Ann Myers is a landmark decision by the...

Limitations on Commonwealth Court Jurisdiction Over Inmate Administrative Appeals in Pennsylvania

Date: Dec 23, 1998

Limitations on Commonwealth Court Jurisdiction Over Inmate Administrative Appeals in Pennsylvania Introduction The case Purcell Bronson v. Central Office Review Committee, decided by the Supreme...

Enhancing the Scope of Terry Frisk: Commonwealth v. Graham (1998)

Date: Dec 23, 1998

Limitations on the Plain View Doctrine in Terry Stops: Commonwealth v. Graham (1998) Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Durrell Graham is a seminal case adjudicated by the Supreme Court of...

Constitutional Validation of PCRA’s Time-Limits on Post-Conviction Relief: Commonwealth v. Otis Peterkin

Date: Dec 22, 1998

Constitutional Validation of PCRA’s Time-Limits on Post-Conviction Relief: Commonwealth v. Otis Peterkin Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Otis Peterkin is a landmark decision by the...

Judicial Assessment of Causation in Workers' Compensation Unaffected by Utilization Review Organization's Reasonableness Determinations

Date: Dec 17, 1998

Judicial Assessment of Causation in Workers' Compensation Unaffected by Utilization Review Organization's Reasonableness Determinations Introduction In the landmark case of Timothy Hoffmaster v....

Establishment of Duty to Warn in Mental Health Cases: Emerich v. Philadelphia Center for Human Development

Date: Nov 26, 1998

Establishment of Duty to Warn in Mental Health Cases: Emerich v. Philadelphia Center for Human Development Introduction The landmark case of Ronald B. Emerich, Administrator of the Estate of Teresa...

Robinson v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania: Standards for Evidence Admissibility and Jury Instructions in Capital Sentencing

Date: Nov 25, 1998

Robinson v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania: Standards for Evidence Admissibility and Jury Instructions in Capital Sentencing Introduction In the landmark case Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Antyane...

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Rules Punitive Damages Unavailable Under Human Relations Act in Hoy v. Angelone

Date: Nov 25, 1998

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Rules Punitive Damages Unavailable Under Human Relations Act in Hoy v. Angelone Introduction The case of Louise Hoy v. Dominick Angelone, Gregory Thomas, and Village Super...

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Commonwealth v. Baez: Comprehensive Legal Commentary

Date: Nov 24, 1998

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Commonwealth v. Baez: Comprehensive Legal Commentary Introduction Case Title: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Orlando Baez, 554 Pa. 66 (1998) Court: Supreme Court of...

Establishing the Enforceable Right to Effective Post-Conviction Counsel in Pennsylvania: Commonwealth v. Albrecht

Date: Nov 24, 1998

Establishing the Enforceable Right to Effective Post-Conviction Counsel in Pennsylvania: Commonwealth v. Albrecht Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Alfred K. Albrecht, Sr., 554 Pa. 31...

Affirmation of Death Sentence in COMMONWEALTH v. RIOS: Accomplice Liability and Aggravating Factors in First-Degree Murder

Date: Nov 24, 1998

Affirmation of Death Sentence in COMMONWEALTH v. RIOS: Accomplice Liability and Aggravating Factors in First-Degree Murder Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Miguel Rios is a landmark case...