Pennsylvania Case Commentaries

Clarifying Prosecutors' Brady Obligations and Appropriate Remedies for Discovery Violations: Commonwealth v. Burke

Date: Oct 18, 2001

Clarifying Prosecutors' Brady Obligations and Appropriate Remedies for Discovery Violations: Commonwealth v. Burke Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Donald Scott Burke is a seminal case...

Strict Adherence to Appeal Deadlines: Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Reverses Superior Court Decision

Date: Oct 18, 2001

Strict Adherence to Appeal Deadlines: Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Reverses Superior Court Decision Introduction The case of Mark A. Criss and Kathryn J. Stevenson v. Sharon Marie Wise (566 Pa. 437)...

Interpretation of "Subject To" in PFA Orders: Commonwealth v. Stallworth

Date: Oct 5, 2001

Interpretation of "Subject To" in PFA Orders: Commonwealth v. Stallworth Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Leroy Stallworth is a noteworthy case adjudicated by the Supreme Court of...

Retroactive Application of Racial Jury Selection Claims in PCRA Denied

Date: Sep 27, 2001

Retroactive Application of Racial Jury Selection Claims in PCRA Denied Introduction The case Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. William Tilley (566 Pa. 312) serves as a pivotal decision in...

A Comprehensive Commentary on Commonwealth v. Breakiron: Upholding the One-Year Filing Deadline in Post-Conviction Relief

Date: Sep 27, 2001

Affirmation of Untimely PCRA Petition Denial Reinforces One-Year Filing Deadline in Post-Conviction Relief Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Mark Breakiron is a pivotal case decided by the...

Clarifying 'Separate and Legitimate' in Pennsylvania's Whistleblower Law: O’Rourke v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania

Date: Aug 22, 2001

Clarifying 'Separate and Legitimate' in Pennsylvania's Whistleblower Law: O’Rourke v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Introduction The case of William H. O'Rourke v. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania...

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Sets Standards for Class Certification under UTPCPL: Emphasizing Individual Reliance and Causation

Date: Jul 27, 2001

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Sets Standards for Class Certification under UTPCPL: Emphasizing Individual Reliance and Causation Introduction The case of Frederic Weinberg, Sheilah Guarino, and Marc...

Tenure Termination Review Standard in Murphy v. Duquesne University

Date: Jul 18, 2001

Tenure Termination Review Standard in Murphy v. Duquesne University Introduction Cornelius F. Murphy, Jr. v. Duquesne University of the Holy Ghost is a significant case decided by the Supreme Court...

Reinstatement Denied: Upholding Legal Integrity in the Perrone Case

Date: Jul 18, 2001

Reinstatement Denied: Upholding Legal Integrity in the Perrone Case Introduction The Disciplinary Docket in the Matter of William James Perrone Petitioner for Reinstatement is a landmark decision...

Limitations on Municipal Authority to Impose Development Moratoriums under the Pennsylvania Municipalities Planning Code

Date: Jun 21, 2001

Limitations on Municipal Authority to Impose Development Moratoriums under the Pennsylvania Municipalities Planning Code Introduction The case of Irvin S. Naylor, Harry H. Fox, Jr., and Valley Acres,...

Establishing the Discovery Rule's Role in Workers' Compensation Notice Periods: Sell v. Workers' Compensation Appeal Board

Date: May 23, 2001

Establishing the Discovery Rule's Role in Workers' Compensation Notice Periods: Sell v. Workers' Compensation Appeal Board Introduction The case of Joan Sell v. Workers' Compensation Appeal Board...

PAPPAS v. ASBEL: Defining ERISA Preemption in Medical Malpractice within HMOs

Date: Apr 4, 2001

PAPPAS v. ASBEL: Defining ERISA Preemption in Medical Malpractice within HMOs Introduction In the landmark case of Basil Pappas and Theodora Pappas, H/W v. David S. Asbel, D.O., Pennsylvania Hospital...

Ex Post Facto Challenges in Parole Denials: Insights from Coady v. Vaughn

Date: Mar 23, 2001

Ex Post Facto Challenges in Parole Denials: Insights from Coady v. Vaughn 1. Introduction Coady v. Vaughn, 564 Pa. 604 (2001), is a seminal case adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania's...

Homicide by Vehicle and DUI Offenses Do Not Merge for Sentencing Purposes: Commonwealth v. Collins

Date: Jan 18, 2001

Homicide by Vehicle and DUI Offenses Do Not Merge for Sentencing Purposes: Commonwealth v. Collins Introduction In Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Casey S. Collins, 564 Pa. 144 (2001), the Supreme...

Reversing Employer Status: Pennsylvania Supreme Court's Landmark Ruling on Independent Contractors in Workers' Compensation

Date: Nov 28, 2000

Reversing Employer Status: Pennsylvania Supreme Court's Landmark Ruling on Independent Contractors in Workers' Compensation Introduction The case of Universal Am-Can, Ltd. and National Union/AIAC v....

Illegality of Detention Invalidates Consent to Search: Freeman v. Commonwealth

Date: Aug 25, 2000

Illegality of Detention Invalidates Consent to Search: Freeman v. Commonwealth Introduction In Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Diana Ericker Freeman (563 Pa. 47, 757 A.2d 884, 2000), the Supreme...

Duty of Care of Therapists Limited to Patients in Alleged Parental Sexual Abuse Cases: Althaus v. Cohen

Date: Aug 23, 2000

Duty of Care of Therapists Limited to Patients in Alleged Parental Sexual Abuse Cases: Althaus v. Cohen Introduction Althaus v. Cohen, 562 Pa. 547 (2000) is a landmark case decided by the Supreme...

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Commonwealth v. Spotz: Establishing Rigorous Evidentiary Standards

Date: Aug 23, 2000

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Commonwealth v. Spotz: Establishing Rigorous Evidentiary Standards Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Mark Newton Spotz (562 Pa. 498) is a landmark decision...

Appellees v. Appellants: Reversing the Superior Court on Trial Court Discretion in Mistrial Motions

Date: Aug 22, 2000

Appellees v. Appellants: Reversing the Superior Court on Trial Court Discretion in Mistrial Motions Introduction The case of Robert D. Harman and Dorothy E. Harman on behalf of Christopher Harman, a...

Affirmation of Juvenile Act Amendments: Transfer Provisions and Burden of Proof in Commonwealth v. Cotto

Date: Jun 21, 2000

Affirmation of Juvenile Act’s Transfer Provisions and Burden of Proof in Commonwealth v. Cotto Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Abraham Martinez Cotto (562 Pa. 32), decided on June 20,...