Pennsylvania Case Commentaries

Affirmation of the Gist of the Action Doctrine: Fraud Claims Barred Within Contractual Relationships

Date: Nov 9, 2002

Affirmation of the Gist of the Action Doctrine: Fraud Claims Barred Within Contractual Relationships Introduction The case of eToll, Inc. v. Elias/Savion Advertising, Inc. addressed critical issues...

Restrictive Covenants Non-Assignable Without Explicit Provision: Hess v. Gebhard Co.

Date: Oct 17, 2002

Restrictive Covenants Non-Assignable Without Explicit Provision: Hess v. Gebhard Co. Introduction In Hess v. Gebhard Co., Inc., and Eugene Hoaster Company, Inc. (570 Pa. 148, decided October 16,...

Rox Coal Co. v. Workers' Compensation Appeal Board: Affirmation of Waiver Rules and Evidentiary Standards in Workers' Compensation Claims

Date: Oct 2, 2002

Rox Coal Co. v. Workers' Compensation Appeal Board: Affirmation of Waiver Rules and Evidentiary Standards in Workers' Compensation Claims Introduction The case of Rox Coal Company v. Workers'...

Commonwealth v. Reid: Upholding Consent Searches and Admissibility of Prior Conduct in Death Penalty Sentencing

Date: Oct 1, 2002

Commonwealth v. Reid: Upholding Consent Searches and Admissibility of Prior Conduct in Death Penalty Sentencing Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Albert E. Reid is a landmark case decided...

Chambers v. Commonwealth: Reinforcing the Importance of Jury Instructions in Capital Sentencing

Date: Sep 27, 2002

Chambers v. Commonwealth: Reinforcing the Importance of Jury Instructions in Capital Sentencing Introduction Chambers v. Commonwealth is a pivotal case decided by the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania in...

Affirmation of Death Penalty in Commonwealth v. Drumheller: Analysis of Aggravating Circumstances and Evidentiary Admissibility

Date: Sep 21, 2002

Affirmation of Death Penalty in Commonwealth v. Drumheller: Analysis of Aggravating Circumstances and Evidentiary Admissibility Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Troy G. Drumheller is a...

COMMONWEALTH v. BOND: Reinforcing PCRA Limitations on Waived and Previously Litigated Claims

Date: Aug 24, 2002

COMMONWEALTH v. BOND: Reinforcing PCRA Limitations on Waived and Previously Litigated Claims Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jesse Bond (572 Pa. 588, 2002) is a seminal decision by the...

Strict Enforcement of Rule 227.1 in Preserving Appellate Rights

Date: Aug 22, 2002

Strict Enforcement of Rule 227.1 in Preserving Appellate Rights Introduction The case Mary Chalkey, a/k/a Mary Matula v. Franklin Delano Roush, Jr. (569 Pa. 462) adjudicated by the Supreme Court of...

Limits of Planning Commission Authority in Master Plan Modifications: Bailey v. Zoning Board of Adjustment

Date: Jul 18, 2002

Limits of Planning Commission Authority in Master Plan Modifications: Bailey v. Zoning Board of Adjustment Introduction The case of Bailey, Wynn, Walker, and Metz v. Zoning Board of Adjustment of the...

Supreme Court Upholds 'Regularly Used, Non-Owned Car' Exclusion in UIM Policies, Affirming Cost Containment Public Policy

Date: Jul 18, 2002

Supreme Court Upholds 'Regularly Used, Non-Owned Car' Exclusion in Underinsured Motorist (UIM) Policies, Affirming Cost Containment Public Policy Introduction The case of Sid Burstein and Doreen...

Exigent Circumstances in Warrantless Vehicle Searches: An Analysis of Commonwealth v. Perry

Date: Jun 4, 2002

Exigent Circumstances in Warrantless Vehicle Searches: An Analysis of Commonwealth v. Perry Introduction In the landmark case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Shawney Perry, decided on June 3,...

Machipongo Land and Coal Co. v. Commonwealth: Refining Regulatory Takings Doctrine and Property Denominator Analysis

Date: May 31, 2002

Machipongo Land and Coal Co. v. Commonwealth: Refining Regulatory Takings Doctrine and Property Denominator Analysis Introduction Machipongo Land and Coal Company, Inc. and the Victor E. Erickson...

Reaffirming Jurisdictional Boundaries: Termination of Parental Rights in Orphans' Court

Date: Apr 11, 2002

Reaffirming Jurisdictional Boundaries: Termination of Parental Rights in Orphans' Court Introduction The case of In the Interest of A.L.D., Jr. serves as a pivotal examination of the procedural and...

Strict Adherence to Statutory Waiver in Post Conviction Relief: Insights from COMMONWEALTH v. BRACEY

Date: Jan 1, 2002

Strict Adherence to Statutory Waiver in Post Conviction Relief: Insights from COMMONWEALTH v. BRACEY Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Edward Bracey (568 Pa. 264) is a significant decision...

Insurer's Bad Faith Refusal to Settle Breaches Fiduciary Duty: Liability for Compensatory Damages Affirmed

Date: Jan 1, 2002

Insurer's Bad Faith Refusal to Settle Breaches Fiduciary Duty: Liability for Compensatory Damages Affirmed Introduction In the landmark case of The Birth Center v. The St. Paul Companies, Inc., the...

Affirmation of In Loco Parentis Doctrine for Third-Party Custody Standing in T.B. v. L.R.M.

Date: Dec 29, 2001

Affirmation of In Loco Parentis Doctrine for Third-Party Custody Standing in T.B. v. L.R.M. Introduction The case of T.B., Appellee v. L.R.M., Appellant (567 Pa. 222), adjudicated by the Supreme...

Affirmation of Denial in Post-Conviction Relief: Commonwealth v. Michael Pierce

Date: Dec 22, 2001

Affirmation of Denial in Post-Conviction Relief: Commonwealth v. Michael Pierce Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Michael Pierce, 567 Pa. 186, is a pivotal case decided by the Supreme...

Williams v. Commonwealth: Establishing Rigorous Standards for Post-Conviction Relief and Counsel Effectiveness in Capital Cases

Date: Oct 20, 2001

Williams v. Commonwealth: Establishing Rigorous Standards for Post-Conviction Relief and Counsel Effectiveness in Capital Cases Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Craig Williams stands as a...

Regulatory Estoppel and the Interpretation of "Sudden and Accidental" in Insurance Policies: Sunbeam Corp. v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Co.

Date: Oct 20, 2001

Regulatory Estoppel and the Interpretation of "Sudden and Accidental" in Insurance Policies: Sunbeam Corp. v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Co. Introduction In the landmark case Sunbeam Corporation et al....

Expansion of Reasonable Suspicion: Pennsylvania Supreme Court Aligns with ILLINOIS v. WARDLOW

Date: Oct 19, 2001

Expansion of Reasonable Suspicion: Pennsylvania Supreme Court Aligns with ILLINOIS v. WARDLOW Introduction The case of IN THE INTEREST OF D.M., Appeal of: D.M. (566 Pa. 445) adjudicated by the...