Pennsylvania Case Commentaries

Right to Counsel on Petition for Allowance of Appeal: Establishing Effective Assistance Under Pennsylvania PCRA

Date: Jun 10, 2003

Right to Counsel on Petition for Allowance of Appeal: Establishing Effective Assistance Under Pennsylvania PCRA Introduction The case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. John Liebel, adjudicated by...

Admissibility of Confessions and Evidence of Prior Acts in Capital Cases

Date: Jun 7, 2003

Admissibility of Confessions and Evidence of Prior Acts in Capital Cases Introduction The case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Gerald Watkins (577 Pa. 194) presents a critical examination of the...

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Commonwealth v. Bomar: Implications for Capital Sentencing and Procedural Compliance

Date: May 31, 2003

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Commonwealth v. Bomar: Implications for Capital Sentencing and Procedural Compliance Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Arthur Bomar is a landmark case...

Affirmation of Parental Rights Termination in In Re: Adoption of M.E.P. Establishes Precedent on Parental Incapacity and Absence of Parent-Child Bond

Date: May 30, 2003

Affirmation of Parental Rights Termination in In Re: Adoption of M.E.P. Establishes Precedent on Parental Incapacity and Absence of Parent-Child Bond Introduction The case of In Re: Adoption of...

Res Ipsa Loquitur in Medical Malpractice: Expert Testimony Required for Complex Procedures - TOOGOOD v. ROGAL

Date: May 30, 2003

Res Ipsa Loquitur in Medical Malpractice: Expert Testimony Required for Complex Procedures - TOOGOOD v. ROGAL Introduction TOOGOOD v. ROGAL, decided by the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania in 2003,...

Interpretation of "Within this State" in Corporate Net Income Tax Apportionment

Date: Apr 26, 2003

Interpretation of "Within this State" in Corporate Net Income Tax Apportionment Introduction COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA, Appellant v. GILMOUR MANUFACTURING COMPANY, Appellee is a pivotal case...

Preservation of Railroad Rights-of-Way: BUFFALO TOWNSHIP v. JONES Establishes Key Precedent

Date: Jan 1, 2003

Preservation of Railroad Rights-of-Way: BUFFALO TOWNSHIP v. JONES Establishes Key Precedent Introduction In BUFFALO TOWNSHIP v. JONES, the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, Western District, addressed a...

Prudential Property and Casualty Insurance Co. v. Colbert: Broadening the Definition of "Insured" under Pennsylvania's MVFRL

Date: Jan 1, 2003

Prudential Property and Casualty Insurance Co. v. Colbert: Broadening the Definition of "Insured" under Pennsylvania's MVFRL Introduction In the landmark case of Prudential Property and Casualty...

Supreme Court Broadens Scope of Rule 1035.3(b) in Summary Judgment Motions

Date: Jan 1, 2003

Supreme Court Broadens Scope of Rule 1035.3(b) in Summary Judgment Motions Introduction In Gerrow v. John Royle Sons, Inc. and Shincor Silicones, Inc., the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania addressed...

Affirmation of Expectation Interest Damages in Academic Breach of Contract: Ferrer v. Trustees of the University of Pennsylvania

Date: Dec 31, 2002

Affirmation of Expectation Interest Damages in Academic Breach of Contract: Ferrer v. Trustees of the University of Pennsylvania Introduction In the landmark case of JORGE F. FERRER, M.D., Appellant...

Overruling the Hubbard Rule: Pennsylvania Supreme Court's Landmark Decision in Commonwealth v. Grant

Date: Dec 22, 2002

Overruling the Hubbard Rule: Pennsylvania Supreme Court's Landmark Decision in Commonwealth v. Grant Introduction In Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Taibu Modamu Grant, the Supreme Court of...

No Duty to Maintain Automated External Defibrillators for Tennis Clubs: Pennsylvania Supreme Court Decision

Date: Dec 21, 2002

No Duty to Maintain Automated External Defibrillators for Tennis Clubs: Pennsylvania Supreme Court Decision Introduction The case of Jerry Atcovitz and Roslyn Atcovitz, H/W v. Gulph Mills Tennis...

Enhanced Protections for Freedom of Expression under Pennsylvania's Constitution in PAP'S A.M. v. CITY OF ERIE

Date: Dec 20, 2002

Enhanced Protections for Freedom of Expression under Pennsylvania's Constitution in PAP'S A.M. v. CITY OF ERIE Introduction PAP'S A.M. T/D/B/A KANDYLAND, Appellant v. THE CITY OF ERIE et al. is a...

Mouzon v. Commonwealth: Expanding Appellate Review of Sentencing Excessiveness in Pennsylvania

Date: Dec 20, 2002

Mouzon v. Commonwealth: Expanding Appellate Review of Sentencing Excessiveness in Pennsylvania Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Jerome Mouzon is a landmark decision by the Supreme Court...

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Establishes Exclusion of Oil and Gas Interests from Real Estate Taxation Without Explicit Statutory Authority

Date: Dec 20, 2002

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Establishes Exclusion of Oil and Gas Interests from Real Estate Taxation Without Explicit Statutory Authority Introduction The case of Independent Oil and Gas...

Automatic Waiver of Appellate Issues Under Rule 1925: Analysis of COMMONWEALTH v. BUTLER

Date: Dec 20, 2002

Automatic Waiver of Appellate Issues Under Rule 1925: Analysis of COMMONWEALTH v. BUTLER Introduction Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Albert Butler is a pivotal case decided by the Supreme Court of...

Retroactivity of Constitutional Amendments Under Pennsylvania's Post Conviction Relief Act: COMMONWEALTH v. ABDUL-SALAAM

Date: Dec 14, 2002

Retroactivity of Constitutional Amendments Under Pennsylvania's Post Conviction Relief Act: COMMONWEALTH v. ABDUL-SALAAM Introduction In the landmark case Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Seifullah...

Reaffirmation of Capricious Disregard Standard in Workers' Compensation Appeal Review

Date: Dec 11, 2002

Reaffirmation of Capricious Disregard Standard in Workers' Compensation Appeal Review Introduction The case of Leon E. Wintermyer, Inc. and American General Group v. Workers' Compensation Appeal...

Fraudulent Misrepresentation in Prenuptial Agreements: Porreco v. Porreco

Date: Nov 28, 2002

Fraudulent Misrepresentation in Prenuptial Agreements: Porreco v. Porreco Introduction The case of Louis J. Porreco v. Susan J. Porreco (571 Pa. 61) addresses critical issues surrounding the validity...

Affirmation of PCRA Denial in Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Robert Wharton Establishes Strict Compliance in Post Conviction Relief

Date: Nov 26, 2002

Affirmation of PCRA Denial in Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Robert Wharton Establishes Strict Compliance in Post Conviction Relief Introduction The case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Robert...