Oklahoma Case Commentaries

Implementing Legislation Cannot Convert Constitutionally Fixed Board Terms into At-Will Service: TSET Board Seven-Year Terms Protected

Date: Jan 17, 2026

Implementing Legislation Cannot Convert Constitutionally Fixed Board Terms into At-Will Service: TSET Board Seven-Year Terms Protected Case: TOBACCO SETTLEMENT ENDOWMENT TRUST FUND v. STITT, Cite as:...

Attorney-Client Privilege for Public Bodies Does Not Expire When the “Pending” Matter Ends: ORA Requests Cannot Pierce Confidential Jones Day Investigative Reports

Date: Jan 15, 2026

Attorney-Client Privilege for Public Bodies Does Not Expire When the “Pending” Matter Ends: ORA Requests Cannot Pierce Confidential Jones Day Investigative Reports Case: NONDOC MEDIA and WILLIAM W....

“Further Implement” Does Not Mean “Substantively Alter”: Oklahoma Legislature Cannot Convert Constitutionally Fixed Board Terms into At-Will Service (TSET Board)

Date: Jan 14, 2026

“Further Implement” Does Not Mean “Substantively Alter”: Oklahoma Legislature Cannot Convert Constitutionally Fixed Board Terms into At-Will Service (TSET Board) 1. Introduction In TOBACCO SETTLEMENT...

Attorney-Client Privilege for Oklahoma Public Bodies Does Not Expire When the “Pending” Matter Concludes (and Is Not Waived by Subpoenaed Joint-Interest Disclosures)

Date: Jan 14, 2026

Attorney-Client Privilege for Oklahoma Public Bodies Does Not Expire When the “Pending” Matter Concludes (and Is Not Waived by Subpoenaed Joint-Interest Disclosures) I. Introduction In NONDOC MEDIA...

Deemed Legislative Approval Does Not Cure Open Meeting Act Defects in Statewide Academic Standards

Date: Dec 17, 2025

Deemed Legislative Approval Does Not Cure Open Meeting Act Defects in Statewide Academic Standards Case: REV. DR. MITCH RANDALL v. LINDEL FIELDS (Okla. Sup. Ct. Dec. 16, 2025) | Posture: Original...

Oklahoma Probate Appeals: Untimely Challenges to Vacatur Orders and Nonappealability of Preliminary Heirship Determinations Absent a “Substantial Right”

Date: Dec 10, 2025

Oklahoma Probate Appeals: Untimely Challenges to Vacatur Orders and Nonappealability of Preliminary Heirship Determinations Absent a “Substantial Right” Case: IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF MELISSA...

Oklahoma Open Records Act: County Jail Public Trusts Are Not “Law Enforcement Agencies” Absent Duties to Enforce Criminal Laws and Initiate Prosecutions

Date: Nov 26, 2025

Oklahoma Open Records Act: County Jail Public Trusts Are Not “Law Enforcement Agencies” Absent Duties to Enforce Criminal Laws and Initiate Prosecutions Case: LAWSON v. LeFLORE CO. DETENTION CENTER...

Oklahoma Open Records Act Does Not Require Production of Native Email Files or Embedded Metadata

Date: Nov 26, 2025

Oklahoma Open Records Act Does Not Require Production of Native Email Files or Embedded Metadata 1. Introduction BROOKE v. REED (Okla. Nov. 25, 2025) addresses a recurring modern public-records...

Causation and “Impact” as Gatekeepers to COVID-19 Medical Immunity: Commentary on Austbo v. Greenbriar (2025 OK 85)

Date: Nov 19, 2025

Causation and “Impact” as Gatekeepers to COVID-19 Medical Immunity: A Commentary on Larry Austbo v. Greenbriar Nursing Home No. Two, Inc., 2025 OK 85 I. Introduction In Larry Austbo, Surviving Spouse...

Agency Heads May Serve as Cabinet Secretaries: 74 O.S. § 10.3 as a Freestanding Exception to Dual-Office Prohibition

Date: Nov 13, 2025

Agency Heads May Serve as Cabinet Secretaries: 74 O.S. § 10.3 as a Freestanding Exception to Dual-Office Prohibition Introduction STITT v. DRUMMOND, 2025 OK 82 (Okla. Nov. 12, 2025), presents a...

State ex rel. OBA v. Durbin: Clarifying First Amendment Limits on Lawyers’ Speech and Rejecting Anti‑SLAPP Defenses in Bar Discipline

Date: Oct 22, 2025

State ex rel. OBA v. Durbin: Clarifying First Amendment Limits on Lawyers’ Speech and Rejecting Anti‑SLAPP Defenses in Bar Discipline I. Introduction The Oklahoma Supreme Court’s decision in State of...

Temporary Medical Relocation, Lost Wills, and Executor Renunciation in Oklahoma Probate: Commentary on Estate of Cunningham v. McClendon

Date: Oct 15, 2025

Temporary Medical Relocation, Lost Wills, and Executor Renunciation in Oklahoma Probate: A Commentary on Estate of Cunningham, Moore & Oklahoma City Community Foundation v. McClendon I. Introduction...

Uniform Exclusion of Tort Bad‑Faith Claims for Service Warranties: America’s Car Mart v. Cantrell and Oklahoma’s Service Warranty Act

Date: Oct 15, 2025

Uniform Exclusion of Tort Bad‑Faith Claims for Service Warranties: America’s Car Mart v. The Honorable Damon Cantrell (Okla. 2025) I. Introduction The Oklahoma Supreme Court’s decision in America’s...

Business Court “Divisions” Are District Court Divisions: Judges Must Be Elected; Legislature Cannot Create New Trial Courts by Statute

Date: Oct 8, 2025

Business Court “Divisions” Are District Court Divisions: Judges Must Be Elected; Legislature Cannot Create New Trial Courts by Statute I. Introduction In WHITE AND WADDELL v. STITT (2025 OK 68), the...

Barfell v. Freeman Health System: Oklahoma Courts Must Apply Ford’s “Relate To” Prong When Assessing Specific Personal Jurisdiction

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Barfell v. Freeman Health System: Oklahoma Courts Must Apply Ford’s “Relate To” Prong When Assessing Specific Personal Jurisdiction Court: Supreme Court of Oklahoma | Citation: 2025 OK 61 | Date:...

Survivors’ Act Resentencing Is “Postconviction Relief,” and District Courts Cannot Appoint OIDS in Noncapital Survivors’ Act Proceedings

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Survivors’ Act Resentencing Is “Postconviction Relief,” and District Courts Cannot Appoint OIDS in Noncapital Survivors’ Act Proceedings Introduction In PYBAS v. THE HONORABLE JEFF CRITES, 2025 OK...

BJORKMAN v. NOBLE (2025 OK 62): Attorney Abandonment and No-Hearing Damages/Fee Awards as “Unavoidable Casualty or Misfortune” Requiring Vacation of Judgment

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Attorney Abandonment Plus No-Hearing, Unsupported Damages/Fee Awards Constitute “Unavoidable Casualty or Misfortune” Warranting Vacation of Judgment Case: BJORKMAN v. NOBLE, 2025 OK 62 (Supreme Court...

Deferred Felony Child Endangerment Plus Alcohol-Related Recidivism Warrants Actual Suspension Under RGDP Rule 7

Date: Sep 24, 2025

Deferred Felony Child Endangerment Plus Alcohol-Related Recidivism Warrants Actual Suspension Under RGDP Rule 7 Case: STATE ex rel. OKLAHOMA BAR ASSOCIATION v. GIES, 2025 OK 59 (Okla. Sept. 23, 2025)...

Prospective-Only Enforcement of RESCTA’s “Large Load” Rule: No Third-Party Transmission “Extensions,” But Existing Service Remains Undisturbed

Date: Sep 24, 2025

Prospective-Only Enforcement of RESCTA’s “Large Load” Rule: No Third-Party Transmission “Extensions,” But Existing Service Remains Undisturbed 1. Introduction In OKLAHOMA ELECTRIC COOPERATIVE v....

Top-Two “Open Primary” Initiatives in Oklahoma: No Facial First Amendment Infirmity; Gist Adequate; Ballot-Title Review Deferred Until Post-Circulation

Date: Sep 17, 2025

Top-Two “Open Primary” Initiatives in Oklahoma: No Facial First Amendment Infirmity; Gist Adequate; Ballot-Title Review Deferred Until Post-Circulation Case: IN RE INITIATIVE PETITION NO. 448, STATE...